r/motorcycle•
vaei-

Can a motorcycle "weave side to side" unintentionally?

I feel stupid just writing this. I was dealing with a distracted truck focusing on his passenger, off-roading his left wheel track (we drive on left) repeatedly, about to rear end me, someone overtook, cop accidentally pulled me over and realized but decided to double down.

I've requested a hearing but in New Zealand you are guilty until proven innocent for infringements and police have no dash camera no body camera so they don't get caught doing exactly this so my goal is to make my own statement and have it on his record.

But there is one significant thing in his sworn testimony. "I noticed the motorcycle was weaving side to side within the passing lane".

So he made a mistake because there's no passing lane which is weird but here's my deal. He claims I was doing the speed of the overtaking vehicle, 123kph (77mph) but since I was trying to build a space cushion I was carefully slowing myself and the distracted vehicle down and was closer to 70kph, speed limit 100kph.

But I cannot make my motorcycle weave without intentional significant rhythmic input to the bars. And that never looks like a loss or lack of control or impaired driving. The cop is imagining a car with the driver being unstable on the steering wheel and his hands causing it to rotate side to side resulting in weaving. But motorcycles don't do this. I think any motorcyclist can realize this but a judge won't, a court room won't, and clearly neither will a cop.

I'm not going to ask for legal advice, I would just like to know how you would present this information to someone in this context that would make it clear motorcycles don't do this.

For example a two wheeled vehicle gets stability from momentum so at the claimed speeds it takes a lot of input to cause it to move significantly enough for an observer to notice on a straight road, and then what I described about the wheel in a car vs bars. I just don't know how to say it in a way that eliminates any possibility he wasn't lying in their eyes.

This whole thing is such a shit show. I've been dealing with it for over a year now because the courts keep doing illegal shit (this is the 2nd hearing request because they violated my right to attend and found me guilty without evidence; speed readings aren't sufficient).

Posted May 28, 2022, 8:40 PM UTC · edited

010
username_taken0001•

You are in a court of law, not the court of laws of physics. Logic, science and "true" hardly matters even with the expert witnesses. Your only chance "to win" is to have a good lawyer. Your expectation should be that no one sane is going to hear your, nor read your explanations, thus trying to do it on your own is going to be just a waste of time.

3
vaei-OP•

The lawyer said unless I can prove I didn't speed I can't win because the courts are biased towards police and accept a speed reading as evidence (without evidence of what vehicle was pinged or the circumstances) and the burden of proof is on you to either prove it wasn't you or your speeding was legal (life at risk). In my case both were true.

I told the lawyer I'm not interested in winning and want to put this on the cops record for the next time he does it. The lawyer said then it's worth it.

NZ is a class based justice system and I cannot get a lawyer to represent me for this. It's in a city that costs over $600 round trip just for plane tickets and much more to ride/drive, need to go twice without a lawyer or three times with one. Our legal aid system would not cover a lawyer for this anyway. We have avl to attend remotely (audio visual link) and a lawyer told me they violated my right to a hearing when declining my application so I've applied for a rehearing.

In the meantime I'm doing everything I can to paint the picture as clearly and irrefutably as possible that the cop is a lying criminal. The fact a motorcycle at highway speed isn't going to weave side to side when losing control is just one of the empirically incorrect lies, it's all about painting a picture.

1
rayark9•

They can have tank slappers unintentionally. But that is deflection of the front wheel with a loss of control. Or imperfect road surface gravel ruts or grooves. Sounds like you were in contol. You can find and edit together more videos like this.https://youtu.be/C0_d-SjyTgY. ( take out the flat tire wobbly one). And show the judge that even without a rider a bike wants to go relatively straight. . Mabey worth a shot. https://youtu.be/MQL61B__OIQ another one.

1
vaei-OP•

I actually encountered a low speed tank slapper recently due to a groove from an inadequately filled patch of surface. I haven't had high speed tank slappers and at the time was on an R3 which can't even reach a high speed; maybe if you death gripped it and topped it out it would do it? Doubt it at the claimed 123kph.

I looked at some videos of tank slappers and was wondering how I'd cover that when presenting this, but now I'm wondering if to a third party observer on the side of the road - and that's the thing he was facing the side of my vehicle so he wouldn't have been able to tell even if I was weaving - if a tank slapper would appear to weave the motorcycle side to side - would be more accurate to say it was shaking violently and the loss of control would be directly stated rather than suggested.

1
SirryCelestial•

Get some kiwi legal advice. Especiaply if you think the court is doing something shady.

1
vaei-OP•

Ahh I have been. They said I'll lose unless I can prove I didn't speed or the speeding was legal. I said I just want to tell them what the cop did for the next time he does it to someone else. They said then it's worth doing.

The court is definitely doing something shady and I'm considering initiating a judicial review but I need to talk to lawyer first about that procedure. I want to use it to force cops to record video at minimum.

1
rayark9•

Yes. And even if it was a tank slapper. It is the fault of the road surface and not you.

1
iHamNewHere•

Could it be the cop has mistaken your “weaving” for the turbulence created by the truck pushing your motorbike around?

This Reddit post shows what I mean.

You may have put some input into the bars (intentional or not) to counter the effects of the turbulence which possibly could have added to how dramatic this weaving looked from an outside observer.

1
vaei-OP•

It was a Ford Ranger behind me not a passing semi in the oncoming lane. A Ford Ranger can't do this

I always counteract passing semi using knee flappering, and the effect isn't drastic enough

1
[deleted]•

Do you have a lawyer?

0