How does the conservation of potential energy work with scales?

To quote Feynman "To summarize: every reversible machine, no matter how it operates, which drops one pound one foot and lifts a three-pound weight always lifts it the same distance, X (1/3 feet)." From what I know if we place a one pound object and a two pound object on a scale or on a seesaw, the lighter object is lifted with the same distance as the heavier one is lowered, or am I just imagining things? EDIT: I switched some words by accident.

Posted May 29, 2022, 1:00 PM UTC · edited

14
starkeffectEducation and outreach•

First imagine that the seesaw is balanced.

2
mfb-Particle physics•

Draw a sketch and you'll find your mistake.

From what I know if we place a one pound object and a two pound object on a scale or on a seesaw, the lighter object lowers with the same distance as the larger one is lifted

If you arrange them to change their height at the same rate then the heavier object will go down.

1
simpleroOP•

Sorry, I made a mistake when writing the question. I meant to say that the heavier one is of course lowered and the lighter object is lifted on the seesaw and the scale. But isn't the distance with which the lighter object is lifted the same distance as the distance with which the heavier object is lowered?

1
thephoton•

Not if you have the heavier object closer to the fulcrum and the lighter object farther from the fulcrum so that the scale will balance.

If you're thinking of having equal lever arms, so it's not balanced, then the heavier arm will fall until it hits a stop and then I suspect this is not a "reversible machine". If there's no stop then it falls until it comes back again on the other side to the height where it started...in which case potential energy is conserved.

2