Can I hold my apartment complex liable for theft from storage rental?
This concerns an apartment complex located in Irving, Texas.
This complex is one of those 4 floor, interior hallways with units built around a gated parking garage type buildings. The intent is that one cannot enter the hallways or parking facility unless they enter through the front office, or have an RFID key fob to access locked exterior doors. The storage rental is a separate "closet", approximately 5'x10' with a door that leads into the common hallway, secured with an electronic deadbolt that is coded to the same RFID key that I use to access my apartment.
Thanks to another resident's ring doorbell, we were able to capture video of two unknown people entering my storage and removing items. To the best of our knowledge, they were able to force the locks open with a small pick because the doors swing outward into the hallways, and that leaves the deadbolt accessible in the gap of the door. The complex had their maintenance people perform adjustments of some kind to the locks to make them stay locked. The lock shows no electronic key accessed it during the time of the break in. Three weeks later, the unit was broken into again, as best we can tell in the same way. This time I captured the individual on my own wireless camera that I had mounted inside the storage closet.
At this point, we had already made a claim on our renters insurance for the initial theft. Our agent said if we made a second claim like this, that we would be subject to an additional deductible and a surcharge or outright cancellation. The property manager suggested they could make the second claim on our behalf, against the property's insurance. Now their insurance company is denying the claim on the basis that the persons who removed the property is not employed by the property, therefore they are not liable for their actions.
Additionally, after speaking with several other residents and the police, this is an ongoing occurrence at this property going back at least 4 years. Many units have been broken into, sometimes several times a year. The exterior doors I mentioned earlier are relevant because they are in such poor repair that about half of them are completely broken and do no latch at all. Thus any random person can walk into the property from outside at any hour of the night. In the 4 months since this event, no repairs have been attempted on any of these security doors. The parking garage has approximately 11 cameras in it, but in each incident, the management have told us they captured nobody during the times of the burglaries. I do not believe they work either.
Is there a case here for some kind of negligence that would make them liable? A failure to secure the property as per our lease? Are the responsible for the function of the lock on the storage as I am not allowed per lease terms to add my own lock or modify theirs in any way. Do you have any advice for what I can say to this insurance adjuster that might make a compelling argument for coverage? The adjuster is going to forward my next correspondence to their legal dept, so I want to make sure I don't waste this opportunity to reference the correct terms or situations.
Posted May 31, 2022, 9:35 PM UTC
The thief is liable. Go through your renters insurance, not theirs, they are correct. It may be a calculation as to what makes the most sense financially based on their comments. Sorry this happened.