Stoicism is very easy to put into practice

Stoic Theory/Study

Many people have seen the posts that say "Stoicism is hard/impossible to put into practice". Invariably the reality of people's situation is that they're actually trying to put Stoicism into action without any practice.

Epictetus talks about the impossibility of this in the 6th Discourse of the first book:

For what does reason purport to do?

‘Establish what is true, eliminate what is false and suspend judgement in doubtful cases.’

And is that all one has to learn?

‘Yes.’

Well, is it enough if you don’t want to be conned in the use of money, just to be told to accept real coins and reject counterfeit ones?

‘No, it is not enough.’

What else is necessary?

‘Obviously the art of testing and distinguishing genuine coins from fake ones.’ And so too in the case of reason, in addition to what we named, we also have to learn how to test and distinguish what is true, false and unclear.

A person who believes that they can simply react to situations with calm because the Stoics were able to, is like a person who believes they have the expertise to distinguish real coins from fake ones simply because they've heard somebody else is capable of doing it, or they are like a person who believes they can match the current weightlifting world record simply because they know that it is possible for a human to lift such a weight.

If you had never attended a gym and then tried to lift the current world record in some particular lift, and found yourself incapable of doing it, would you say "weight lifting is impossible to put into practice"? Of course not - this would make no sense: the only reasonable thing to say is "I cannot perform this task because I have not practiced it".

The moment you do something each day - reading, journaling, contemplating, then you have a Stoic practice. It takes a quanta of time and absolutely no expertise to begin practicing something, which means that it is unambiguously easy to practice Stoicism. Putting it into practice can be no harder than what you are currently used to - you, plus a little Stoic practice, must be equal to or a small improvement over your current mentality.

It is only by throwing out whatever you know now to try and masquerade as an expert in an unpractised art that you can make your life more difficult than it already is.

Posted Jun 2, 2022, 12:15 PM UTC

11511
[deleted]•

[deleted]

31

Seneca on a happy life book 20, talks about how while many may not succeed, it’s the mere attempt which is admirable. Maybe we will not be free of vices by the time we die, but we are far better than those who relish in them.

7
polkemans•

refining and crafting character

This is huge and something I wish more people in general thought about. So many people throw up their hands and go "I am who/how I am" as an excuse for poor behavior. As if they're just cursed with a shitty personality. We are all capable of self creation. If you don't like who you are, act like who you want to be.

5
BluntFrank00•

Well said!

To add:

What is the first business of one who practices philosophy? To get rid of self-conceit. For it is impossible for anyone to begin to learn that which he thinks he already knows. - Epictetus

9
sagittariisXII•

If you want to be a stoic, be a stoic. If you want to be a successful stoic, practice daily.

9
starsAndStars_33•

Well said! I see so many posts in this forum that are of the form "How to endure X as a stoic" or "How to deal with Y as a stoic". Don't get me wrong, there is no fault in asking questions but it shows that people think Stoicism is a quick fix similar to "get a six-pack in 10 days". In reality, one needs to understand the core principles and then apply them to whatever life throws at you. But this takes time and effort. I spend at least one hour a day reading, thinking, and journaling, and it only takes me a couple of days without practicing Stoicism to notice how my old habits and ways of viewing the world to start coming back. Being Stoic requires a lot of effort but to me it is worth it as it the world view that make the most sense.

3
UncleJoshPDX•

Thank you for writing this. But isn't this quote from the 7th Discourse? Or do different editions rearrange them?

1
BenIsProbablyAngryOP•

It's both - you're right that they do appear as different numbers in different books, although rarely do they go off-kilter so early.

It is actually Discourse 6, not 7, you are right.

1

You can tell the character of every man when you see how he gives and receives praise. Seneca

The true test of a man's character is what he does when no one is watching. Former UCLA basketball coach John Wooden

I agree.

The fact that anybody is trying to apply Stoic principles to their life is actually in a state of 'doing', not trying. You either do, or you don't.

Sure, the effort can be large or small, and it's beneficial to your character no matter how small. Small steps can lead to long journeys.

1
mcgriddeon•

Thank you for this excellent post. It has inspired me to put more effort into my daily practice.

1
itsastonka•

Boom

1

New stoic here. Thank you! A light bulb lit in my noggin!

1