My thoughts on the collatz conjecture and the math concerning bodies
[deleted]
Posted Jun 4, 2022, 7:22 AM UTC · edited
[deleted]
Posted Jun 4, 2022, 7:22 AM UTC · edited
This is the most incoherent rambling I've ever seen in my life.
[removed]
[removed]
7, 22, 11, 34, 17, 52, 26, 13, 40, 20, 10, 5, 16, 8, 4, 2, 1. Man, that was troublesome!
Hi, u/BodyMath! This is an automated reminder:
We, the moderators of r/NumberTheory, appreciate that your post contributes to the NumberTheory archive, which will help others build upon your work.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
So my impression after skimming this is that you believe the Collatz Conjecture ought to be true. Not in the sense of "it's probably true given numerical evidence". You believe it ought to be true on a prescriptive level. You see the difficulty of proving it as a failure of math.
But Collatz was basically contrived to be difficult. You can make similar conjectures using numbers other than 1s, 2s, and 3s for your "Collatz function" and it's often easier. It's this specific version of that class of problem that is difficult.
Sorry to burst your bubble, but out of interest I wrote a program in C# that calculates the full sequence for your formula of almost any whole number.
I found out every whole number up to 1 000 000 converges to 1, without exceptions. You can probably also prove this mathematically for any positive whole number.
Well no one has ever proven it mathematically works for any positive number
Let me prove to you it works with 4
4 is even so it goes to 2, 2 is even so it goes to 1. Done, proved for 4.
One down, only a few more positive integers to check.
Well you said it hadn't been proved for any number. Now it's proved for at least one !
Really? I saw a few patterns so I assumed it would be straightforward to make a mathematical proof based on them. I am not that much of a mathematician myself so it was based on vague intuition.
I just looked it up, and I see what you mean. I didn't know the Collatz conjecture was this famous unsolved problem.
You can probably also prove this mathematically for any positive whole number.
If you think it's that easy, perhaps you'd care to do it yourself? You can post your proof in this subreddit when you've written it up.
Mathematicians have already found that every whole number up to 2^62 converges to 1, without exceptions.
They've also found that for almost all positive integer values of n, by applying the rules of the problem, n will eventually reach a value below f(n), where f(n) is any strictly increasing function.
Note that the above works for almost all positive integers (which means that as the sample size approaches infinity, the portion of the numbers which don't go below f(n) approaches zero). But we haven't managed to prove that it works for all numbers.
Mathematicians have already found that every whole number up to 262 converges to 1, without exceptions.
I read about that. I don't think I have the necessary computing power to go that far lol
Hi, u/BodyMath! This is an automated reminder:
We, the moderators of r/NumberTheory, appreciate that your post contributes to the NumberTheory archive, which will help others build upon your work.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
Can you please describe, in a few short sentences, what you're trying to do? Most people here will be reluctant to read such a wall of text
And there is no known answer: neither proof nor disproof. So we’d appreciate if you could put in a “TL/DR”
TL:DR: Uhhhhhhh
"Rambling" about the collatz conjecture is just an anchor for getting into the differnt dimensions i describe from the line
10:2=5
you can skip to that part. Its in the middle. Read the first part, if you are interested.
TL/DR:
I try to figure out why there is a difference between calculating real world objects ("units"), Length and Points/dots. And how they might come together.
Can you please describe, in a few short sentences, what you're trying to do?
Can you define this difference? What properties of conceptual units of length do not apply to “points/dots”?
The difference between points and dots is simple. Dots are 2D, so they have area; while points are 0D, so they are much airier.