r/chomsky•
beauseph

Chomsky says we should form coalitions with suppressed groups. Can occupy form a coalition with the liberty movement in America? The same one trying to redefine the term "conservative", and whose de facto leaders (RP / GJ) have foreign policy views Chomsky has said are uncontestable?

reddit.com/r/evolutionReddit/comments/v3wel/i...
reddit.com

Posted Jun 16, 2012, 2:07 PM UTC

1021
dada_•

This is a very vague proposition. The purpose of forming a coalition and teaming up to do something is to strengthen one's numbers and pursue a common interest in spite of the differences between the parties. So even if parties A and B have very different ultimate visions, they can team up if they agree on what has to be done to get halfway to their respective end goals.

What's the halfway point that Ron Paul and Noam Chomsky agree on? Sure, there's the issue of foreign policy, which has some legitimate basis for cooperation, although I'm not entirely sure if it's as big a common ground as people think it is. Keep in mind that Ron Paul is an isolationist who wants to completely withdraw from the international stage, including the UN and obligations to international law, which could lead to a very lopsided situation where the US is focused solely on preserving its own wealth and massive advantages without regard for anything. I don't see him doing anything about the massive abuses perpetrated by US companies operating in foreign territory anytime soon, for example.

The ideological common ground between Ron Paul and Noam Chomsky is minor. Much smaller than people think. Their Venn diagrams only just barely overlap. Even when you get into the abstract issues, such as the opposition to state power, it's scant at best. Ron Paul is an anti-federalist, not a real libertarian in any sense of the original definition. And Noam Chomsky doesn't believe in simply abolishing the state. That's what armchair anarchists dream about when they're supposed to be working. If we abolished the state tomorrow, everything would collapse. The goal is to move towards a people-controlled society.

Above all, Chomsky believes in improving the living conditions of working people and slowly moving towards democratization and labor organization and to free ourselves from the shackles of our corporate overlords, and on those notions Ron Paul is firmly in the other camp. There's a reason why Chomsky endorsed Jill Stein rather than anyone else for president.

edit: and by the way, the post that's linked to is just silly. "Chomsky doesn't understand because he's a linguist." That's not a substantive argument. The entire comment seems intellectually vacuous to me.

Nor is Chomsky a "godfather of the Occupy movement". He endorsed the movement, he's happy to see young people taking to the streets to protest, he occasionally talks about it, and he gave a speech at Occupy Boston once—to my knowledge, the only time he ever spoke at an Occupy rally. As much as there is a confluence of values and mindset, he's in no position of significant moral leadership.

3
beausephOP•

There are obvious flaws with Paul. I doubt that a President Paul could nullify every single international treaty any more than President Obama could pass some of his policies with a powerful obstructionist Congress. But I'd much rather watch a series of debates between Obama and Paul, where the debates would be on NDAA, Wikileaks, endless wars, etc, than Obama and Romney.

And the liberty movement is desperately trying to break free of the neoconservative power structure. "Conservativism" is trying to redefine itself in America. All the meanwhile, the "99%" ideologically is disturbed with the idea of outreaching to them. And I was involved with Occupy Boston until the infighting really got bad.

1
dada_•

I doubt that a President Paul could nullify every single international treaty any more than President Obama could pass some of his policies with a powerful obstructionist Congress.

Yeah, international treaties are very hard to get rid of by their very nature. However, that concept depends on one's interest in being part of the international political establishment. If Ron Paul wants to trash that whole concept, we might see a different picture altogether.

Although I wouldn't mind a discussion between Obama and Ron Paul, and agree that it would be interesting to watch, the idea of him being either a serious candidate for presidency or a serious fighter for the rights and benefits of the 99% is just absurd.

His plan is to turn the current system of state-capitalism into unrestrained laissez-faire capitalism, which doesn't exist anywhere else in the Western world, but does exist abundantly in Africa—which is why it looks the way it does today. I'm not a capitalist, but the only form of capitalism that makes sense is state-capitalism; Paul's plans would ruin the economy, so the corporate masters would never permit it to happen. And furthermore, this would destroy all democratic victories of the past two centuries. Worker health-safety regulations, social security, healthcare subsidies and everything else would be gone under his vision of society.

Anyone who has even the vaguest idea of Chomsky's ideas about society should immediately reject any advocacy of a Ron Paul presidency.

On a side note, I've actually never heard of the "liberty movement" before in my life. It doesn't even seem to exist on Wikipedia in the form that you allude to. I doubt it's much of a movement at all.

3
beausephOP•

Oh the movement exists, and it's pioneering itself on reddit and other social media! And I agree with a lot of your points on Paul, however it's the movement, the "We the People" that must be courted...whether to keep encouraging them to amass delegates behind the scenes, or to throw their support behind Johnson.

I'd much rather see Occupy understand the Randian or libertarian philosophies, and literally morph those memes into something constructive, rather than watch idly by as the burgeoning liberty movement finds itself stonewalled by everybody except, well, anarchists such as Kokesh who seems to want a confrontation with the military. I absolutely refuse to let anarchists co-opt the libert movement or occupy movement, and they are prevalent in both.

2
ethanwashere•

It's clear Paul doesn't have a chance, but hypothetically I really question how much he would be able to do.

1
ethanwashere•

I like how Libertarians actually have balls when it comes to civil liberties and foreign policy compared to liberals...

1
dada_•

I like how Libertarians actually have balls when it comes to civil liberties and foreign policy compared to liberals...

Ron Paul is really just an anti-federalist. If a state wants to ban marijuana, or even, say, reinstate old sodomy laws, that would be fine with him. He's against federal legislative involvement. With regard to foreign policy, it's as I said: he's basically an ultra-nationalist who wants the US to completely withdraw from its international obligations, including the UN. He's not about to send any former US presidents to The Hague to stand trial for war crimes.

It's about time people stop pretending he's the silver bullet. He's a deeply flawed ultra-capitalist right-winger who believes in ending healthcare subsidies, social security, abortion rights, corporate regulations of any kind, and that global warming is a giant liberal hoax.

Those interested in what they deem to be the good parts of his platform should go to Youtube and give Chomsky a listen. He also believes in getting the US foot off the world's neck and in important civil liberties, without destroying the country on the side. And try and look up Jill Stein, the Green Party candidate for president. If you want to advocate for change, do it the right way.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
beausephOP•

"Chomsky doesn't understand because he's a linguist."

That's not what I said at all so maybe your interpretation is what's intellectually vacuous? Whatever I said my point was that I'd expect a linguist to understand the value of an antiwar libertarian movement seizing the term "conservative" for themselves. It's a valuable change after watching neoconservatives writing the agenda for the past few decades, and after having Obama enter office saying we need to look forward and not backwards with regards to Bush era war crimes.

Even the term "liberal" has undergone massive change in American history, so it's not unprecedented.

1
dada_•

"Chomsky doesn't understand because he's a linguist."

That's not what I said at all so maybe your interpretation is what's intellectually vacuous?

Maybe I misread it. What you said was this:

It's too bad that Chomsky, seen as a godfather of the occupy movement and has endorsed Ron Paul's foreign policy, and is a LINGUIST, doesn't seem to understand this perspective.

So what you're saying is that despite adding "linguist" to the list of qualifications, you actually don't consider it a qualification as to why he doesn't understand? Then why did you add it?

But in any case, I don't think you can just redefine the term that easily, because literally half of US corporate power depends on the term "conservative" as their primary brand. I'm not convinced that it's a fruitful fight to be had. We should be focused on getting the message of democracy and worker solidarity out there and passing legislation that actually helps people.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
breakfast-pants•

Very doubtful--a Chomsky-Ayn Rand alliance?

2
danecarney•

Occupy: Fuck Major Corporations!

Tea Party: Fuck Big Government!

Chomsky/anarchists/libertarian-socialists/etc

2
beausephOP•

Well said :). Basically, can't we just save the whole Keynesian versus Austrian economics debate until after...we have a fully transparent government not in the pockets of corporations?

1
liberal_libertarianMOD•

Removed, this isn't a work of Chomsky.

1