Season 2 flows much better when binging then waiting week to week.

I remember there were many people frustrated with a lot of the experimental directions taken episode to episode when Legion was first releasing on FX, and though I never really felt that way myself I certainly understood the criticism. I liked Season 2 a lot at the time where some people were a bit more lukewarm.

Rewatching the series on Hulu and I have to say Season 2 ebbs and flows with the ideas it's playing with from episode to episode really well without ever really making me feel frustrated about things like creative tangents, too much or too little attention being given to certain characters, the pace of the plot advancing, etc.

Damn this show is so fuckin' good.

Posted Jun 6, 2022, 2:30 AM UTC · edited

8512
HoldWhatDoor84•

Season 2 is so fucking good. The narrations are some of the best bits in the entire show and it contextualizes everything in the whole series in such an open-to-interpretation kind of way. No other show like it.

27
Bebopdavidson•

Jon Hamm!!!

4
SomeNoteToMyself•

This show works so much better binged.

16
JoyousMN•

Absolutely fantastic show. I loved season 2. I few things didn't land perfectly for me but I loved that they never took the easy route.

4
Guardax•

This happens all the time with tv shows, people binge the first season after it came out and don't like the next season when they're watching one episode at a time

4
birdy810•

Yeah some people won't have the patience for season 2 if they watch it live. It's 3 episodes longer and definitely slower, especially in the back half. Personally I loved episodes 1-7. But episodes 8-10 kind of sucked the momentum out of the season.

3
AfricanRain•

Completely agree with shows like this Hannibal and Better Call Saul that they’re best binged because you don’t get as frustrated with lack of plot developments and slow moving stories

2
CourtJester111•

Finished watching Season 2 and am onto Season 3. Not gonna lie, I'm really unclear as to what multiple things David did wrong? There's the one OBVIOUS thing with Syd which is clearly fucked up. The rest of the cast seem to describe him as doing multiple things wrong though and I'm really not sure where they're getting that from. The mind blasting soldiers thing, literally the other characters kill worker level goons all the time, sue him for doing the same thing. Torturing Oliver, mfer was being mind controlled by Farouk and David was mentally torturing him for information on where to find Syd. They act as if Kerry wouldn't do the same thing to find Cary or that Melanie wouldn't do the same thing to find Oliver. Even Syd would probably do similar shit to find David, she's shown a clear disregard for human life throughout the show. Also to bring up the Syd thing, as much as what happened was terrible and is unjustifiable, are we really supposed to feel deep empathy for the person who raped her mother's boyfriend? "You drugged me and raped me." No dickhead he made you forget you guys had an argument and then you voluntarily boned him.

1
ProtoRedditOP•

The easiest way to answer this is to implore you to approach the show less literally and with a little more willingness to take the thoughts, feelings, actions, and developments of all its characters as an invitation to understand something and ask all the interesting questions associated with the process of coming to understand something.

Rather than say, "these characters are wrong", ask "why do they feel they're right" and then SOLVE for that. Find in yourself the answers they came to. Think of their perspective so thoroughly that you can argue back with everything you just wrote.

This show is EXACTLY about feeling empathy for people who may not deserve it or may even be wrong, deluded, traumatized, or under any number of psychological influences. This includes all the characters. Empathy is about understanding, not agreement.

I understand your confusion though, to be clear, I just want to emphasize that whether or not Syd is "right" that David "drugged and raped her" is ultimately immaterial. (Though for some reason which I still struggle to understand everyone who goes down this line of thinking goes HEY BUT THIS THING SHE DID AS A CURIOUS CHILD MAKES HER BAD TOO - which, to be clear, resulted in her rape, not her "raping her mother's boyfriend".)

The show is so great because it's confusing and ambitious enough to ask the audience to: empathize with someone who can't empathize with someone else because that someone else traumatized the already developmentally traumatized first someone because the someone else also can't empathize with them because they were so un-empathized with themselves during their own developmental trauma that their entire sense of self is too caught up in sustaining a delusion that they're a good person and therefore deserve the empathy they're not getting.

Also just keep watching. Season 3 clears up a lot, and the ambiguity of whether or not certain characters are good/bad and why is rather neatly tied up from all perspectives. There's one episode especially that's essentially entirely about some of the things we're talking.

2
tester421•

Though for some reason which I still struggle to understand everyone who goes down this line of thinking goes HEY BUT THIS THING SHE DID AS A CURIOUS CHILD MAKES HER BAD TOO - which, to be clear, resulted in her rape, not her "raping her mother's boyfriend".)

What? She used her power to impersonate her mom to have sex with her mom's boyfriend, which is cut-and-dry rape by deception. She also stole her mom's body to do it, which means she also raped her mom.

She may have also been traumatized by how things went down, but that doesn't mean she's not the perpetrator here. She's also clearly unrepentant about ruining her rape victim's life by letting him take the fall - when the incident is brought up later, she only seems to care about how raping that guy wasn't as good as she thought it would be.

(Also, just because she's a rapist doesn't mean that what went down in the S2 finale was perfectly fine - raping a rapist is still rape).

1
ProtoRedditOP•

Oof. Not going down this rabbit hole. Knew someone would get caught on that...

I invite you to watch the scenes again.

1
JimmysCocoboloDesk•

From what I remember the argument wasn’t necessarily what he did but the fact he appeared to derive pleasure from doing so. From the killings to torture. The thing with Syd was just the last straw as it was seen as ‘treachery’. Also it could be argued that David made her forget because he knew she wouldn’t have sex if with him if she had that knowledge, so he knew it was a fucked up thing to do. If you also pay attention to the way the scene is filmed and the underscore playing, it’s not portrayed as a romantic thing. Both he and Syd are fucked up and the relationship had become toxic after the honeymoon stage, which is why I think they ultimately never got back together.

1