When does insurance become cost prohibitive?
Edit: just to be clear, im not trying to get rid of my insurance, and I understand living in a hurricane rich area means higher premiums. I'm just trying to figure out if it doesn't make sense to own a house where 30-45% of your monthly payments are just for carying insurance. We've only been in the house because it's been cheap. So I guess this is more of an opinion question on if we should consider a lifestyle upgrade.
We bought a house about 5 years ago for just under 100k on the gulf coast. Due to the increase in severe weather over the last few years our insurance premiums have gone through the roof. mortgage is only about 750/month, and, after shoping around quite a bit, we've got another 300-350/mo for insurances. What we carry for hurricanes is about 2/3 of overall insurance costs. I can pay for the additional cost of insurance premiums, but is there ever a point when it doesn't make sense to keep a house because insurance premiums make up most of the monthly cost?
30% of our monthly cost is in carrying insurance, and that seems ludicrous to me. In that it seems like i could go up substantially in size and quality of home, but the insurance premiums would reasonably be similar.
Posted Jun 7, 2022, 7:45 PM UTC · edited
If you had a paid off home, would you rather pay out of pocket to rebuild when a hurricane damages your home?
Well, I certainly wouldn't drop the insurance. In just curious if it makes sense to keep the house when 1/3 of owning the home is just insurance premiums. Only reason I'm still in it is because it's been so cheap thus far.
I guess the way I'm thinking about it is like I'm paying the insurance of a new mustang, but I'm driving a 20 year old civic. If I have to carry an insanely expensive policy, why not have a property that feels more justifiable to have a crazy policy on it.
Which I guess is more so me trying to get a validation on a lifestyle upgrade. Thanks for helping me talk this out
What are your other options? I'm guessing you want to live in this location. If you sell and go somewhere with cheaper rates will you get a house in a location that's acceptable to you? We all live in areas that have some level of risk and benefit. You have to determine for yourself how much your location is worth to you.
I'm thinking just upgrade to a larger, nicer house. The increased rates aren't really a financial burden, I'm just not sure how to feel about the ratio of insurance to mortgage. It seems like we could get a much larger, and nicer home where the insurance wouldn't be as large of a piece of the pie.
I think that’s a smart way of looking at it. If I were in your boat, I’d look at the “all in” cost including insurance compared to the “all in” cost in a bigger nicer home with lower insurance rates.
Be sure to actually check insurance rates in the new area you’re considering. Insurance premiums have come up a lot in areas that used to be inexpensive.
It is pretty similar though. If you had a paid off civic, would you carry full insurance? Same for a more expensive or sportier car. It would depend on how much the insurance costs, how much they pay out if you total it, and how likely you think that is.
So for your house, obviously if you stay there for 50 years and it never pays out you would be better off self insuring. Or there is a hurricane next year insurance is a great deal. If you pay off the mortgage, and the home is badly damaged with insurance it sounds like you can afford to get a loan and rebuild, so self insuring is an option. If you stay there for 30 years, the home is destroyed once and moderately damaged once would you save money self insuring?
I don't really understand one part, how much insurance do you have? If the replacement cost is $450k I would expect higher premiums than if the replacement cost is $200k. Maybe you could shop around for policies with a lower replacement cost if you have too much coverage now. But also maybe the replacement cost is actually higher than the market value of the home and you need the insurance
The issue isn't that I'm over insured, or feel like I'm paying too much for premiums. My question strictly relates to the ratio of insurance to mortgage. I also said in my original post that I've shopped around a lot to look at all available policies. About 2/3 of my total insurance cost is more or less non-negotiable because I live in a high risk area of hurricanes. Pretty much any house in the area, from where I'm currently living up to a 350k home (as much house as I can currently buy), I'll have about $2000+/- 200 per year as a premium for insurances against hurricane damage.
So right now, about 1/3 of my monthly expenses is going to paying a premium, where if I had a 350k home it would be more like 1/6 of my monthly payment. So my quest is really centered around on if it makes sense to have a lifestyle upgrade because it would comprise a smaller percentage of the overall pie. Like, if it's always going to be $2000 to play, then why do it on a cheap house and not a medium-expensive house.
I don't think it is 100% that all homes in the same area have the same insurance cost. Things like elevation, building materials, replacement cost based on the type of home will make insurance costs lower in some cases.
But ya it sucks living some place where hurricanes inevitably destroy homes, and it is likely to get worse in the future. But homes/land is probably pretty cheap. At least you aren't in Miami where you have high insurance costs and crazy high prices.
My in laws cancelled their insurance because it was over $5k per year and they have never filed a claim. After about 5 years Irma came through and damaged the roof and caved in part of the ceiling. Was about $15k in damage. They saved over $25k not paying crazy insurance prices, FEMA gave them $9k and the rest came out of pocket. I was in the process of selling my house when I got the new bill for insurance in April, $8500 per year. My house is old but I also did all hurricane upgrades like windows, doors, roof was 8 years old and built to code. Screw insurance companies.
That's a great story. The older I get, the more I feel like insurance is a scam. Spend 10-15k per year on all my premiums for all different kinds of insurances, most they'll ever pay out is pennies on that dollar. And they'll fight tooth and nail to not pay it too. Makes me feel like I should just escrow all the money I would've paid them anyway much like your parents did.
I wish I could self insure with a mortgage, the home I'm under contract for, my insurance is $1900 per year for 5x the land, a house twice the size and a separate apartment in the rear. It's crazy how location changes how much you pay. I left Miami for central Florida.
Well, I certainly wouldn't drop the insurance. In just curious if it makes sense to keep the house when 1/3 of owning the home is just insurance premiums. Only reason I'm still in it is because it's been so cheap thus far.
I guess the way I'm thinking about it is like I'm paying the insurance of a new mustang, but I'm driving a 20 year old civic. If I have to carry an insanely expensive policy, why not have a property that feels more justifiable to have a crazy policy on it.
Which I guess is more so me trying to get a validation on a lifestyle upgrade. Thanks for helping me talk this out
You leave out some details here. Size of home is a big factor. Is it on the water as in gulf front? What is your hurricane deductible? Depending on what your deductible is and what your total replacement cost is you may be able to save money by chosing 5% deductible which means any hurricane damage you pay $5k per $100k of total replacement cost coverage. It can save a lot of money on premiums if you have cash in savings.
Bang. Fast answer: can you afford to self insure? No? Then insure.