hudsongrundy•

I love that album, unsure why it's hated. It's an amazing album with some of their best songs

9
sinkindespair•

People hate this album?

7
hudsongrundy•

Okay well hate was probably the wrong word. But alot of people dislike it. Wanted growlers to go back to their roots

3
hell-etcOP•

very late reply but i for the most part do see some hate / dislike towards this album, but i LOVE all the songs , i cant even describe how they make me feel , glad there’s people out there who appreciate it

2
Djgfnd•

Not trying to start the same argument as I did on Discogs but it's an EP not an album

0
emptyb0nez•

Still an album bro

4
Djgfnd•

Here we go again... There is a name or classification for a release of music that is composed of extras, outtakes and/or B sides left over from the recording of an album. It's called an EP or extended play

0
emptyb0nez•

pretty much an album

6

You’re quite wrong…

An EP is considered 1-3 songs with one song of at least 10 minutes in length and a total running time of 30 minutes or less. Or an EP is considered 4-6 songs with a total running time of 30 minutes or less.

3
Yallblewa3-1lead•

When everyone tells you you’re wrong then you’re wrong.

3
whalemeatagain•

EP means “extended play” which is longer than a single but shorter than an album. The content is irrelevant—it’s the length that is important.

From Wikipedia:

“In the United States, the Recording Industry Association of America, the organization that declares releases "gold" or "platinum" based on numbers of sales, defines an EP as containing three to five songs or under 30 minutes. On the other hand, The Recording Academy's rules for Grammy Awards state that any release with five or more different songs and a running time of over 15 minutes is considered an album, with no mention of EPs.”

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extended_play

Casual Acquaintances is barely over 30 minutes and has 10 songs. So, it would not qualify as an EP according to the RIAA or the Recording Academy.

So many albums by so many artists out there are composed of outtakes and b-sides and half finished ideas. But no one considers them EPs, but maybe a “compilation” instead.

If you wanna get technical, then Hot Tropics would be considered an EP, and that would have nothing to do with the source of the music.

2
hudsongrundy•

Too many songs for an ep

3