Here we go! It's TIME! It's what we've been waiting for all week! It's the AMA with Dog Bite Attorney, Kenneth Phillips! Go for it! Post your questions below!
I'll start this with the questions that were asked in the earlier post...
Kenneth will be answering questions from 1:00-2:00 pm EST on June 10, 2022
Posted Jun 10, 2022, 5:01 PM UTC · edited
Hi everybody! I’m here. Let’s start with breed specific laws.
Does the ESA loophole still apply in areas with BSL and if so what steps could be taken to close that loophole without effecting legitimate service dogs?
There's a big difference between an emotional support animal and a service animal. I'm in favor of strict enforcement of the laws regarding service animals. I do not believe that any animal can be a service animal, and I've come to believe that there is widespread abuse of the emotional support animal laws. Law enforcement needs to strictly apply and and the force the service animal laws, and look very suspiciously on claims that certain animals are there for emotional support. There should be a requirement of a specific psychological condition or physical handicap for an animal to be exempted from other laws on the ground of being an emotional support animal.
As someone who went through the correct, fair way of attaining my emotional support animal status for my PTSD and depression (psych agreed that taking care of my animal and him providing me some grounding during panic attacks helped tremendously), it disheartens and worries me so much that people who take advantage might erode my rights away. My dog is a border collie, is quiet, and has never met a person he didn’t love. I also never ever try to take him places that only task animals belong, he is only my at-home support. Is there anything people like myself can do to push for change while also protecting the rights of those who genuinely need this?
I didn't see this until now. What changes do you want to push for? To change things, the answer in brief is that you make your voice heard by local lawmakers and local law enforcement authorities, including animal control, the police and sheriff. Please see my comments about how to do this as I responded to similar questions in this AMA.
If your emotional support dog is only for home, isn't it pretty easy to find a place to live that allows dogs?
Do you believe there should be some regulation allowing law-enforcement officers to question the legitimacy of service animals? Perhaps like required documentation? From my understanding, you cannot even ask someone if their "service animal" is legitimate, let alone ask for papers. So there is basically nothing stopping someone from throwing a "service animal" vest on their pet so they can take it anywhere they want.
It is generally a crime to misidentify an animal as a "service animal." So the laws are already in place. You can ask whether the animal is a service animal because of a disability, and what the animal is trained to do for the person bringing it along. You can't ask about the person because that would be inquiring about something private. The loophole in these laws pertains to a service animal "in training." A person can bring any animal into a place and claim that it is a service animal in training. I have seen that "in training" vest on very badly behaved dogs. I feel very aggravated at people who claim to need a service animal when in fact they don't need it and their animal is obviously not a service animal. It makes all of us suspicious of ALL service animals, which is a terrible consequence of preventing us from asking questions about particular suspicious animals being misidentified as service animals.
[deleted]
How do you feel Denver repealing their BSL will affect dog bites and victims?
It's a huge, huge mistake. They had great success with their breed specific laws. They had fewer attacks, less damage to people and other people's pets.
I’m in Denver, a neighbor in 2019 had a pit bull who attacked a kid in our neighborhood. The police were called and the dog was taken away. It took her all of 3 days to get ESA paperwork and get her dog returned to her. She was a friendly neighbor so she confided in me throughout this process. Her attitude was basically that all dogs bite and her dog was demonized for being a pit bull, she felt it was like dog racism.
You suggest there was an abuse or miscarriage of justice. I'm not sure about that. After the dog was taken away, there should have been a 10-day hold on it, which could have been in the form of confinement inside the dog owner's house. If so, the ESA paperwork had nothing to do with getting the dog back, because many animal control departments prefer to quarantine a dog in the owner's house. Moving on, the next issue is whether being an ESA helped the dog avoid being classified as a potentially dangerous or vicious dog. It probably didn't because, as you imply, the dog had no training or history as an ESA. So I think you encountered a big-talking pit bull owner, not a miscarriage of justice.
Denver had a pit bull ban at the time. The dog was taken because it was illegal to own. She circumvented the law by going online and paying $175 for an ESA registration which only required telling a doctor that her dog helps with her anxiety in a 15 min online appointment. ESAs are largely a joke. Unlike service animals which are specifically trained to assist a person with a disability, ESAs have no requirements other than saying XYZ pet makes you feel good.
Mr Phillips, I have a short and simple question, do you think a statistically significant amount of people are waking up to the inherent dangers of the breed on average, or is the propaganda more effective across the mainstream?
Based on talking to people, not on any new studies, it seems like at this point in time the average person knows that pit bull type dogs are unreasonably dangerous, while 5 years ago people were just asking me whether they were. I think the constant maulings and killings by this type of dog has caused Americans to understand the danger. So yes, my belief is that the actions of pit bull type dogs are louder than the words of their publicists and loyalists.
[deleted]