If we can fight in the air, we can fight in the sea. Bring back underwater combat!

Posted Jun 11, 2022, 12:34 AM UTC

Posted Jun 11, 2022, 12:34 AM UTC
I have a dream, two dream
one is lagiacrus skeleton finally working and another is palamute jousting.
Jousting really needs to be added to Lance, it's such an obvious necessity.
I'd play more lance with that but then LS would get 3 new counters for mounted combat.
LS gets wirebug move that summons a spectral palamute they can ride on so they can bring a palico for the utility instead.
Well, the main difference, I think, is that outside of Insect Glaive and maybe Dual Blades, we're not fighting in the air for long periods of time, and even then Insect Glaive has to land at some point.
I don't think we'll be able to fight Lagiacrus in full underwater combat by just dipping our toes in the water for a second or two, lol. Underwater would require fully submerged combat, probably new movesets/animations to match, new locations, etc.
I mean yeah, we could have underwater combat if Capcom took the time to implement it, but... yeah. 😅
They already made this shit in Tri and more so in 3U. Its already figured out. It just needs a bit of refining to the new combat styles.
Well, yes. My point was that Underwater combat takes a bit more time and energy than "aerial combat" when said aerial combat is not actually done for extended periods of time.
More maps, bigger maps (unless they do an arena style map), new attack animations, not to mention figuring out how Wirebugs can be used underwater, if they be used underwater (which they probably would be since that's the main thing in Rise).
Plus there's the monsters. I'm sure they're not gonna make underwater combat for just Lagiacrus.
Plus there's the monsters. I'm sure they're not gonna make underwater combat for just Lagiacrus.
Lagiacrus isn't the only under water monster. Royal Ludroth was an underwater fight. Ghobul was too. GoldBeard as well. Plesioth too. And i don't think anyone is expecting water combat for sunbreak. But maybe for the next game where they might not bring Palimutes and wire bugs. We still haven't seen Prowlers make a comeback yet. Rise might just have game specific Mechanics like most monster hunter games.
Plus theres many more possibilities to be added. Jyratodus, Somnacanth, Mizutsune, Namielle. And best of all we get Dire Miralis back.
If No Palamute in the next game, there will be riots. Wirebugs can easily disappear without a problem.
I dont we’ll have to worry about wirebugs underwater. I think theres a good chance they wont return
I was referring to if they were to add it in Rise, but yeah. I'm sure they won't be returning to the next game.
I get the impression you didn't know that the whole shtick of one entire Monster Hunter game was that it had underwater combat. All of the stuff you're speculating about that "needs" to be done has already been done, the only new animations needed are for the weapons that have been added since.
Yes, I know. My comment was based on if they were to add underwater combat to Rise specifically, not future installments.
New movesets and animations and whatnot would need to be done if it were to be added in Rise due to things like Wirebugs, not to mention the weapons having different movesets in general with certain skills.
Now, if they did it for a new games entirely then yeah, I'm sure there wouldn't be any problems as far as what I've discussed in my post, but I thought the OP was referring to Rise, so I made my post specifically about Rise.
you say that as if there hasn't been a huge rework of most of the weapons since 3rd gen. Even if we assume that 6th gen will be more grounded like World without things like wirebugs and such, World alone made many core changes to most of the weapons that would need to be redone for underwater combat as well. Even straightforward weapons like Greatsword got lots of new moves and in general lots of movesets have been tweaked for improved fluidity and have more combos than they did back in 3U. And weapons like Longsword have had tons of changes since then.
Like sure if they do manage to translate all the modern tweaks to the weapons to underwater combat it'll probably feel a lot better than it did back in 3U, but they will basically have to start over from scratch with most of the weapons in order to translate it.
Also how would the Insect Glaive even work underwater? It's like the literal antithesis of underwater combat so it'd probably need entirely new mechanics to work.
as an ig main on rise it would be sick too have our air dash move as a warer dash move, it seems fitting
I'm now debating the implications of an "underwater" combat that is treated somewhat like inverse airborne combat, with the surface being treated as your "ground" that you and the monster will default to until the monster dives/"flies" and you use Wirebugs or certain weapon maneuvers to dive after them for attacks but then surface again once they're over.
It just needs an updated take on it. I do miss it, despite its flaws. It felt like a whole different level of combat. Like taking the fight to the monster. I'd even take it over wirebug.
Glaive only needs one change, and I kid you not, I would be able to complete a whole hunt without ever returning to the ground. Just let us draw into the helicopter attack midair and will never touch the ground again.
Underwater combat was really frustrating, Lagi is okay though.
For real, my god underwater was so shit.
I started playing 3U about a year ago and I can say that I genuinely enjoy it overall. And it’s not like I’ve just played a bit either, only monster I haven’t fought yet is abyssal (9 or 10 ranks away from it), so unless somehow that one singular fight makes me hate literally every other instance of it in the game, that won’t change anything.
It ain’t rose tinted glasses for everyone that likes it, some people genuinely believe it to be a positive experience, why do you assume if someone says they like it it must just be nostalgia talking?
It's not nostalgia for me. I never hated it. I was surprised when I took to the forums and saw many people not like it.
For real. I was never so glad to see a mechanic dropped. I hated fighting underwater.
As someone who recently finished 3U, I really hope it never comes back :)
Easily the worst part of 3U to me.
I went back to 3U not too long ago and I really agree.
Despite being a bow player, I specifically picked up lance in Tri and gunlance in 3U just to deal with combat underwater. Just doing "dash attacks" with GL underwater will get you through the Goldbeard hunt in 8 minutes solo if you move well and don't get hit, even when ignoring the rest of your kit. Found that out myself.
Lances in the water, guns and bow on the land, and the best way to deal with underwater hunts was to use the same 1 or 2 moves the entire time, from Laggy to Goldbeard to Miralis to Abyssal Laggy. But "Your weapon handles like crap: the gameplay mechanic" wasn't fun for me, and it seems they're exploring aerial space for combat rather than underwater. I wouldn't want to see underwater return unless it's more (ahem) fluid.
That's what made it my favorite old-school to be honest. I get it though. But I really do think they could modernize it to actually make it a good experience for everyone.
A good compromise for players opposed to swimming around would be to have maps with areas that are mostly underwater for the Monsters themselves, but with things like giant lily pads or other floating structures for our Hunters to run across while the Monster swims around us.
As for full underwater combat, the best way to bring it back in my opinion is to use the Palamute system, but underwater. Give us an underwater Buddy that'll allow us to move around fluidly beneath the waves, but have us stay on our Buddies' backs and wield our weapons at the same time; maybe also use harpoons with rope to occasionally tether to the swimming Monsters and be pulled along as they move.
No please no.
I almost lost my mind because of those clunky underwater fights. Just no. Cool idea, but no
No thanks :)
3U’s water combat wasn’t that bad (I’ve been playing it on the WiiU), you’re all babies, bring back Lagiacrus, Fish monsters, and water combat.
People really are remembering it with tinted glasses I love gen 3 but 90% of underwater monsters are a chore to fight
Maybe that's part of the charm. Maybe it's not all about obliterating the monster the entire time. Being in a disadvantaged state. Taking the fight to them on their turf. That's what I liked about it. Yeah it was clunky, but it added some more depth to the game.
No I that’s not what I mean I’m an old school player and I like struggling but it’s like actively not fun when the monster you’re fighting goes all the way across her map in 1 second and it takes you 30 to get there but once you do it moves again. Some of them were cool but a lot of them were like actually kinda bad imo
Yeah but that was just bad design. It doesn't have to be that way. I wouldn't want the same underwater experience as Tri. I just want the style back
Just bring back Lagiacrus
They keep trying, it's been on their list every game, but he touches the ground too much. The maps in Rise and world are just too uneven and it breaks his model.
But they are still trying, the devs haven't given up.
For the love of god please
I would not like to see it return :( I'm sorry.
To clarify, I don't feel that way because I think underwater combat isn't fun or anything. I had fun with it. I especially loved fighting Goldbeard Cedaeus.
It's mostly because it would take the developers a lot of time and resources to not only implement new underwater movesets for every current weapon, they would also have to do the same for every new weapon they add to the game. On top of that, they'd have to rebalance all underwater movesets per game in addition to the land movesets.
There's other factors to consider on the topic of development, like how it could affect the designs of monsters and map designs.
But that's basically my point; I just want them to focus on other aspects of the game rather than two halves of combat, when only one is used at a time anyway. I would rather they invest in other new ways for players to hunt/fight, like castle defense (Lao), ship battles (Jhen), etc.
That's a fair pov, it's true that a lot of resources would be needed, but I think there are also some benefits to splitting the combat in half.
With how much they've been stacking mechanics to the grounded combat, our movesets have started to get a little bit overwhelming. Power creep is real. The monsters can't keep up and they have to resort to bs to provide a challenge. By splitting the combat in halves maybe they can incorporate all of their ideas, while still keeping the hunters in check.
[deleted]
I would play underwater if and only if we got wirebugs or something equivalent to that mobility. It's just so fucking slow to move around and has all the regular issues that underwater video game levels have
It's actually a pretty cool idea that I hadn't thought of. Combine the two to enable fast dashing and movements underwater.
Please Capcom give us Wirebug jet-skiing
Idk if you're joking but that's basically what I'm asking for lol
Loved diving underwater, not so much for the fighting itself though, and I'm someone who's always defends it! Personally wish it got reworked, since I always loved that beach/summer vibe that 3U had. With how good the engine is, would love seeing coral or fish all around as you swim through!
Thinking back on it, underwater never felt too annoying since you rarely had to interact with the mechanic. I think people would be fine with it, if it was good. Imagine fighting Mizu!
Honestly it’s weird playing through 3U for how little underwater stuff there actually is. Only 2 maps actually have underwater sections, and less than a fifth of the monsters actually go underwater (1 of those I think only does it when weak, 3 can be fished out, and another 2 spend a reasonable amount of time on land depending on the map).
If you go through and do every quest in order, you can go ages sometimes without ever even diving into the water.
Yeah, exactly. Never understood people who don't want to come back/try gen 3 because of the water. Can understand why people don't want to see it just get ported back in, of course, but I doubt things'll ever get that lazy.
If you ever miss the sea, I think the moga free roam helps. Messing around and taking in the atmosphere can be nice, sometimes.
Something I feel to keep in mind about the underwater combat too though is that that’s the first attempt at it in the series. A lot of the stuff in the first game is kind of terrible in some ways because it was the first attempt, and you look at most of the stuff the devs try out in a game and there’s some aspect of it that really doesn’t go over well. I’m pretty confident if they kept at it that it’d turn out way better, and for the people saying it’d take way too much development time away from other stuff, that would only really be the case for the first attempt, each try after that would take a lot less work since they’d have so much stuff they could reuse from older attempts you know?
Imagine coral highlands but with some flooded sections
nah
Underwater combat was miserable please no
I guess if it got a huge rework it could work but I just don’t see how it could
No clunky movesets, more iframes when dodging, less get up time when hit, faster swimming time.
Moving in 3D space was never the problem, the problem was that they went all in nerfing the hunters.
The difference between air combat in Rise in underwater combat in 3U is that you don't fly in rise.
You eventually hit the ground, thus the control, which you lack during the short time while wire bugging, is eventually returned to you after you touch gras.
Underwater combat takes control away from you over a long period of time while fighting monsters that don't have that issue.
The reason for that is that on the ground, your camera doesn't control up and down movement, because you can't move up and down. Thus, your camera controls nothing except for your field of view.
Underwater, your camera doesn't only control your x, y movement, but also your z axis, thus limiting your view cam to a fixed position which causes problems while fighting monsters that constantly move and attack you.
That fixed camera also messes with your depth perception, which is crucial for an action game that relies on positioning.
Unless they significantly increase the underwater movement to offset the lack of depth perception(look at Sekiro for an example), underwater combat will probably always feel janky, sluggish and weird.
Underwater combat takes control away from you over a long period of time while fighting monsters that don't have that issue.
This is an argument I see in the comments. My argument is that exact issue could be a good thing. Fighting at (somewhat) of a disadvantage on their turf adds a layer of depth to the game. I think people want to be able to severely topple the monster in every situation and I think that becomes stale. Look how powerful ping ponging in the air had made us in Rise, for instance. People love it, but we're too mobile, and barely punishable, even after we get knocked around by a monster.
Although I definitely know that underwater was clunky. I still think they could make it work much better these days.
I still think they could make it work much better these days.
How would you fix the camera and depth perception issues.
Camera function was much worse back then, even on land. It felt off, or kind of unresponsive and I think that made underwater feel even clunkier. Depth perception was also a camera position issue I think. Raise the position of the camera slightly over the hunter and you should get a better depth perception.
Also, weapon actions should stay in line with how they are on land. Mobility should increase slightly, namely dodges. SnS felt awful because it lost half of its combo capabilities in the water and the mobility wasn't there to back it up.
I really didn't think it was that bad. In my honest opinion, to say it was unplayable is exaggerative.
I really do think the people that say that have either not played it with a camera stick or have never touched the game in the first place and are just riding the hate train.
It was clunky but it was not that bad at all.
CAPCOM: I miss the part where that's my problem
I think people should be willing to see it back in a refreshed and reworked manner. There’s no reason to believe CAPCOM won’t make it a fun addition. I mean…. They made Kushala FUN for crying out loud. It’s just too much potential wasted not having underwater combat, or at least giving it another chance.
Yeah, there's so much hate for underwater combat in this thread smh. It's true that it was frustrating, but it's mostly because of the clunky-ness of old mh. With the way the games are now, i'm sure they'd somehow refine it. And imagine, the many unique monsters designs and fights we'll get if underwater returns.
I'd rather they spent that dev time on new weapons and monsters. Things that have a higher chance of not being wasted time because it ends up playing like trash no matter the effort. Seriously. I can't think of a single game where 3D action combat feels great
Edit: 3D action combat = free movement in all directions/action in all dimentions/no gravity. Not just "combat that's in 3D" as MH is already that
I don’t hear Tekken fans say too many bad things about 3D combat but I could be wrong. I think they’d spend more time creating monsters than they would reworking underwater. The monsters are the stars and I don’t think anything would take priority over that.
I also don’t think underwater combat is something people can’t grow to love.
I'm sorry but Tekken is a 3D game - but you are definitely not fighting in all 3 dimensions. As in there is no ground/gravity and you can freely move in all directions. What a silly comparison considering MH combat is already in 3 dimensions by that definition.
It would be a massive effort to get a game with as complex combat as MH to work well in 3 dimensions. If you think it would take less effort then creating new monsters then I don't know what to tell you because that's ridiculous.
"Can't grow to love" how about "I want the game I pay money for to be good from the start and not a stockholm syndrome situation"
Due to a lack of poor wording, and understanding on my part… I didn’t say it would take less effort at all and that’s not what I was trying to convey. I’m saying they wouldn’t let it take priority to the point where it takes away from the game. There is no way they don’t put most time and effort into the monsters and weapons. That’s a absurd to thing to think and would be a bad decision. My point with the grow to love thing is that underwater deserves another shot in the future. I truly believe that. With the Tekken comparison, yeah not sure how I overlooked that.
I wonder when the switch happened... some years back there was nothing but hate for underwater combat.
people are probably just nostalgic for it since we dont have it anymore. sure looking back fighting lagi was iconic, but underwater combat was always horrible, i dont know how anyone who actually played it sees that differently.
Because unlike the rest of the game, it gave off a better feeling of what the combat was really about, it made every move count for more, and it felt like you were really going out there to hunt the monsters rather than navigating a human-geared environment where monsters just happened to spawn into randomly.
In the rest of Tri's land based combat, never mind all the other games since including Rise, combat is eminently 2D and geared to the absolute advantage of the Hunter above the monster. All flying mons are nerfed to not be capable of flying or hovering above about one person's head tall, and they are near unable to evade attacks in mid-air, let alone on land. A "king of the skies" like Rathalos shouldn't even deign swoop close to the ground to deal with a hammer or LS user; just barrage them to death from above.
In terms of map design, Hunters have a layout and action tick advantage over pretty much every land based monster that is not a Hyper or a monster that doesn't suffer from fatigue such as Elders. Among the very few who manage to escape that advantage somewhat is Najarala, and that's because the camera helps it.
But underwater? Now it's you entering their turf. The layout and even the medium is to their advantage. You are at a noticeable disadvantage in that you can not profit from your strengths, the same way in our normal combat a Rathalos can not profit from their strengths. Now it's you who move sluggishly, whereas before it was Tigrex that moved sluggishly. Now it's you who has to keep track of the monster right below you, whereas before it was Duramboros who had to suffer that you could just camp their legs and slash away. Now it's your turn to become the Hunted, and that makes every move matter much more, your understanding of the monsters matter much more, and — with the caveat hopeflly this gets fixed when underwater combat returns — your understanding of the design decisions and limitations of the engine matter much more.
So I want underwater to return because barring the technical limitations of back then, it was glorious. It was how I felt a fight against a Zinogre or a Rathalos actually should have to go about.
But Gobul? F* Gobul.
People being nostalgic convinced new hunters that it was awesome and not jank trash
[deleted]
Tri was my first MH game, I wasn't even aware of the past games. So to me underwater combat was just as new as the rest of the mechanics and I thought it was fine. Never once did I think it was clunky, in fact the whole game was clunky. I loved Tri, I never had a problem with underwater and I played Tri with a wiimote for fucks sake. I'm sure we can manage better now that we have better control schemes available. The clunkiness of underwater combat came from the fact that hunters were severely nerfed underwater.
[deleted]
Yep. Even with the problems underwater had, it was far from unplayable as people make it out to be. I'd rather play Tri underwater with a wiimote than MHFU and its gigantic hitboxes.
Dodge does work. You have horizontal and two vertical. You gotta take em all into consideration.
Also it's been a hot minute so I could be wrong but I'm 99% certain you had free range of camera with a classic controller
conversely Tri was also my first game in the series and I actively tried to avoid underwater combat whenever possible and it's entirely possible that it's the reason I never got past low rank in that game. I didn't know it was a gimmick for that era of the games at the time, but when 4U came around I was glad to see it was gone and it was only then that I suddenly got super into the series to play each game for thousands of hours
I too did shit my pants everytime I went into the water, but I found it very thrilling!
Maybe underwater was what pushed you to drop the game, but honestly only a small amount of monsters went into the water anyway. I think the game was overwhelming to you and maybe underwater was what pushed you over the edge.
It sucked so much ass i droped tri after the first underwater quest.
Skill issue
Same here. Couldn't stand underwater combat and I've been playing since mh1.
The controls were just abysmal by a long shot. I heard if you used a classic controller, it was better; but never got to try that advice.
When people realized Lagi will never be back unless water combat does too, along with other monsters like Ceadeus (i just want to hear Ceadeus theme again pls Capcom)
Gobul:(
The satisfaction of frog-fishing that guy is unmatched
Absolutely
Ceadeus is one of favorite large-scale monsters. His armor set is god tier (normal model, not goldbeard).
GoldBeards Still my favourite. The black Anubis armour looked so fucking cool.
I was always for it.
One of the rare few, definitely unpopular still
That's fine but I thought it was awesome despite its flaws. I would take underwater over wirebugs, not even kidding.
Pitch me on how ig and cb would work underwater
[deleted]
Came to write exactly this. It's not like underwater combat should be mandatory to return, but there are always workarounds to all the problems people present as being unsolvable. Personally, I think it's very worth it to explore the concept again. The fact that underwater was clunky doesn't mean it has to be that way again. MH has traditionally been very clunky anyway, only recently has the clunkiness faded away.
If people want this back there are a lot of major rework needed just so that you can use these 2 weapons.
I’ve always just said rather than a rework give each weapon an entirely unique moveset underwater to add more gameplay variety.
That's not true, there were always people saying they liked underwater combat, it usually got completely drowned (hehe) out by the hate.
I personally loved underwater problem and really had no problem with it whatsoever.
It's just that the people that liked it were less vocal in past.
There was no switch, underwater still sucks.