Airbnb/short term rentals

Discussion

Hi all,

Im currently doing research into airbnbs and short term rental regulations for a city im interning with. I have looked at the nearby comparable cities and municipalities, but no one seems to have a real idea of how to regulate them. What are the best regulations youve seen or any resources on the topic? Thanks to all who respond

Posted Jun 17, 2022, 12:57 PM UTC · edited

724
sixtyacrebeetfarm•

In my opinion you’re better off looking at municipal ordinances rather than zoning regulations if you haven’t already. The problem with trying to regulate STRs through zoning is that most, if not all complaints are going to be made during the evening and on weekends when your zoning staff isn’t working. It’s also overall going to be an enforcement nightmare with staff dedicating way too many hours trying to enforce any sort of STR regulation with probably no results to show for it.

6
pala4833•

Zoning regulations ARE municipal ordinances

6
LP53OP•

Not looking at zoning, but yeah the challenges you list are definitely present

1
UncleBogoVerified Planner - US•

Zoning can be a useful tool in helping stop them from happening in the first place. If you get a complaint and the air bnb is in a structure where it's not permitted you can start the process of removing it.

1
jointli•

The approach will depend on the community… for a recreation-based economy, check out Chelan, WA.

6
JorisBohnson11•

Brisbane City Council just doubled the rates (taxes) on any property rented under a short term agreement above 60 days. This city in particular is experiencing massive housing shortages.

https://amp.abc.net.au/article/101153020

4
pickeldudel•

OP probably isn't in Australia, but a lot of municipalities here are rolling out local laws at the moment in relation to short stay accommodation, mostly focused on managing amenity impacts. Brisbane is the first that really appears to be disincentivising short stays.

The City of Fremantle has a similar scheme of increased rates (roughly analogous to property taxes), but it's not a 50% hike like in Brisbane. https://www.fremantle.wa.gov.au/business/your-business/short-stay-accommodation

They've also had short stay accommodation local law in place since 2008 and is the earliest example of such a law that I am aware of. Given it's been in operation for 14 years, they might have information on how the local law has held up with the rise of AirBnb.

In my state, Mornington Peninsula Shire was the first to have a go at AirBnBs, but mostly from an amenity impact standpoint through implementing a registration requirement, code of conduct and a three strike rule, but requires any complaints to be substantiated. Their website pretty much directly states that they can't go out to enforce: https://www.mornpen.vic.gov.au/Online-Forms-and-Services/Short-Stay-Rental-Accommodation-Local-Law There hasn't been a planning response from the state gov as to the affordability/housing supply impacts of short stay accommodation, despite calls from local government for it to be addressed.

It's being addressed at a state level in New South Wales, with the state gov implementing a statewide register and uniform fire safety requirements. Fire risk of short stay accommodation is a huge issue in Australia, particularly with accommodation that uses tiny homes or shipping containers. https://www.planning.nsw.gov.au/Policy-and-Legislation/Under-review-and-new-Policy-and-Legislation/Short-term-rental-accommodation

2
AcademiabratVerified Planner - US•

There are various approaches to this. I think it’s useful to require Airbnbs to register with the city. Then they can be tracked, the city can make sure they’re paying their taxes etc. Chicago does this, I’m sure that other cities do also.

A lot of cities set a limit on the number of days a unit can be rented as an Airbnb, say 60 or 90 days. The owner can make some money, but it’s still primarily a housing unit.

Some cities only allow Airbnb if the person renting it out is also on the property. This aims to prevent the proliferation of Airbnb management companies. Then cities of Los Angeles and Santa Monica have this rule. New York City has this rule too, though I don’t know how well it’s enforced.

In big cities and resort towns, Airbnbs tend to be concentrated in certain desirable areas, so they’re impacted more. Some cities, like New Orleans and Montreal, prohibit Airbnbs in certain areas of the city. In Montreal, unfortunately, the enforcement is very weak.

3
WCland•

I think the first step is to identify the impact. Create a distinction in municipal code between long term and short term rental. These are people operating businesses in the community so the city needs to have those businesses registered. I think Airbnb cooperates with municipalities, so if your city requires registration for short term rentals, Airbnb will provide a list of all in your city. Once you know how many short term rentals there are, you can determine if they are impacting the long term rental availability and price, and/or the general livability of the city. If residents are being displaced or if the city is becoming unaffordable, the city might consider only allowing places to be listed for one month out of the year, or only allowing owners who actually live at a residence to list it. It’s worth seeking information from Airbnb on how it works with municipalities.

2
twhizzler•

My city just passed a By-law stating STAs (short term accommodations) can only be within your primary residence and you must obtain a license to operate. We, like many other cities, are experiencing a massive housing shortage and Council determined the STAs would better serve as long-term rentals

2
jebascho•

Oakland has something about no short term rentals shorter than 30 days, or something like that. I'm not sure how it's enforced, as it was up to the residents in our building to report to the city as the landlord didn't care about tenants subletting their apartments out like that.

Palm Springs has a very strict noise ordinance. If any amplified music can be heard from the street after a certain hour, travelers are kicked out immediately. What's annoying is that AirBnB doesn't state these kinda of rules on their website for impacted properties.

2
projectaccount9•

I think it has to be based on property rights which are state law based. State law is needed to clarify that if there is no prohibition on short term rentals in an HOA or local government that any ban on short term rentals only apply to subsequent owners of the property so as not to deny property rights to existing owners.

That being said, I don't think local governments should be able to ban short term rentals but they should be covered by deed restrictions or rules inside condo complexes, etc, subject to protection of property rights for existing owners (see above). If your neighborhood is turning into nothing but short term rentals then that isn't very fun. People do want some kind of recourse and the proper avenue is your private agreements with the associations and deed rules.

Air BnB gets blamed for a lot of housing shortages, but it's really government regulations (and NIMBY's) that are preventing new builds in the most dense cities.

1
LaCabezaGrande•

I hear this a lot here in Austin. While govt does create barriers to creating more housing, the enormous number of STRs definitely does cause problems. Austin has a severe housing shortage and affordability problem and there’s no way that the estimated 14,000+ STRs doesn’t contribute to that. Walk into almost any apartment complex in the city and you’ll see dozens of lockboxes used by STRs near the entrance. Each one is an apartment not available to permanent residents.

Deed restrictions are definitely one of the better ways to manage STRs, but the vast majority of housing stock in cities was created before STRs really existed. It‘s virtually impossible to implement deed restrictions retroactively and some states (e.g. Texas) are actively hostile to them.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
UncleBogoVerified Planner - US•

I would look first for examples in your state or province and then go from there.

There is no 'one way' of approaching this as it depends on the local context of your municipality. Feel free to look at areas of a similar size and context, examine what works and doesn't work, incorporate local feedback and go from there.

Here in Canada, I've seen it approached from zoning and by-law enforcement. The zoning is key to help stop them from happening in the first place and by-law enforcement can keep track of them either informally or through a licensing system.

1
samyouelarr•

AZ made it so municipalities can’t regulate short-term rentals, so it’s pretty much free reign

1
digby99•

Orlando has whole developments built as Airbnb/Vrbo vacation home rentals. I guess it allows investors to buy them but keeps them all together so as to minimize impact on neighborhoods. There are vacation rental developments in champions gate with hundreds of vacation rentals together.

1
hotpepperh2o•

San Diego just did a thing on Airbnb. I think they are requiring short term rental permits and limited the number of permits

1
Caswell19•

Ban them or triple the tax rate for short term rental property

0
markpemble•

The best regulations are no regulations.

-8
SabbathBoiseSabbathVerified Planner - US•

Uh, really? For who?

2
markpemble•

It makes it easier (and less expensive) for visitors in your city.

A happy visitor is the goal of most cities.

-7
SabbathBoiseSabbathVerified Planner - US•

Not at the expense of local residents. How do local feels about STR in Whitefish?

4
LaCabezaGrande•

As opposed to happy residents?

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1