Noob D2 heat treat

Long time knife nerd, not really a blacksmith. I bought a kabar dozier D2 folder a while back. Everyone said it was super hard steel. I was using it to cut a plastic bit off a fan and it just touched the metal fan shroud, rolling the edge. Wtf?

This led to me discovering bob dozier hardened his D2 to 60-61 hrc, while kabar kept it around 57. Logical since people do dumb things and kabar doesn't want pictures of broken knives on the net, but this isn't what i wanted.

How would i go about hardening this thing up to where its supposed to be? Not sure i want to build a forge for a $25 knife experiment.

Posted Jun 18, 2022, 12:42 AM UTC · edited

55
sativadaze•

D2 is difficult to heat treat and requires nearly a full day of annealing before you heat treat it. The annealing is delicate and requires a digitally controlled kiln to do properly. You be better off buying a new one unless you can pay someone to HT it for you. Also doing multiple quenches can cause micro cracking.

4
Gillilnomics•

This is the only response. Glad you’re a sativa person.

0
nomonopolyonpie•

I'm a machinist and have a good bit of experience with D2. If the edge rolled, it isn't at 57 HRC.

You need around 2200 degrees to harden, IIRC, and the for tempering it varies depending on final desired hardness. We always tempered twice. I'd have to look at one of my heat treatment books to give the numbers, as I haven't done any heat treatment in quite a while. Personally, the obsession with making it as hard as possible is....dumb...to me. The harder it is, the more brittle it is. That means your edge is more likely to chip, creating a stress riser that will cause the blade to fracture if stressed. Everything is a trade off with steel alloys. With D2 you get wear resistance thanks to it having more carbides, but at the expense of being more brittle than, say, A2 which is far easier to work with and sharpen and maintains an edge nearly as well.

2
CyborgHighlanderOP•

well, the edge absolutely folded on me like frosting on a cupcake.

1
SheeEttin•

As another noob, for $25, do whatever the fuck you want to it.

1