A somewhat rhetorical question / thought experiment

[Edit: thanks for the replies. Sounds like I'm starting from a false premise of what "assigned" means. I guess a follow-up question would be: why do we use "assigned at birth" and not just understand trans or cis as a relationship to ones sex? That is, if your gender is different from your sex, you're trans; if not, your cis.]

I hope this isn't "stirring the pot." I just have a question that confronts the idea of gender as a social construct, and the definitions of cis-/transgender.

I'll start with two assumptions, please correct me if I'm wrong:

  1. A transgender person is defined as someone who identifies as a different gender than the one they were assigned at birth.

  2. A cisgender person is defined as someone who identifies as the same gender that they were assigned at birth.

The question is: what if someone is not assigned a gender at birth, or assigned a gender that does not match their genitalia?

So if I have a child born with male genitalia but choose to assign them a female gender, are they transgender or cisgender?

If I don't assign them a gender at birth, doesn't that preclude them from either cis- or trans-?

Posted Jun 19, 2022, 7:56 PM UTC · edited

18
ericfischerErica, binary transfem, HRT 9/2020•

Ultimately, "assigned" is probably not actually the right word for what we are talking about, but we use the vocabulary we have.

If someone is not assigned a gender, is genuinely raised without a gender, and continues to be happy about not having a gender, they are probably cis agender, and if they do later adopt some other gender, that probably makes them trans.

The case of gender assignment that does not match genitalia mostly comes up in the case of intersex people, and my understanding is that different intersex people have different opinions about how trans or cis they are if they take action to change their gender assignment later in life. In the case where the birth certificate just has a typo or some other sort of mistake, that clerical error does not make the person trans.

3
Transquisitor•

"Cis agender" that's an oxymoron. You cannot be cisgender and agender.

1
ericfischerErica, binary transfem, HRT 9/2020•

I think you could be if you were somehow raised agender, but I agree that this does not happen in practice.

1
PerpetualUnsuretyProbable trans woman; she/her•

I think perhaps you're taking the "assigned at birth" thing a bit literally. It's not really talking about the moment of birth when someone says "it's a boy" or "it's a girl", or the gender that gets written on your birth certificate.

It's a quick way to describe the entire mechanism of gendering that's built into our society, and that from the moment someone first looks between your legs you're expected to be a certain gender. It's useful because it makes explicit a societal structure that most people see as implicit and normal, but actually causes quite a few problems for the c. 1% that don't fit the norm.

The definition you're talking about only works because that mechanism exists and reliably genders people based on perceived genitalia. If it didn't, trans people would still exist - we'd just need a better definition.

3
vendettamoon•

You cant assign another person a gender. A cis boy growing up being told that he's a girl will experience dysphoria and want to be treated as a boy. Someone's identity is theirs alone to interpret. If you raise a child gender neutral, ex. Without using gendered terms at all, it will still be their decision what their identity is, and they will likely let you know if they're uncomfortable and want to be referred to a certain way. Don't try to influence anyone's identity, rhetorical or not

2
afurioushawk•

Everyone would be trans because gender identity is innate and they would eventually gravitate toward that gender, whatever name you give to it. But we don't live in this world and probably never will, so it doesn't matter.

2
PerpetualUnsuretyProbable trans woman; she/her•

Regarding your edit, about why we don't use "gender different from sex" as the definition - this is another definition that gets used, but it's not without its problems. "sex" isn't actually a straightforward thing to define. Sex in humans is a bimodal distribution of a large range of anatomical, hormonal, biochemical, and other features - many of which can be changed as part of medical transition. In a very real way trans people that medically transition change our sex - or at least, many aspects of it.

Using this definition you'd need to come up with a definition of sex that has no false positives or negatives, and which doesn't allow for "sex" to be mutable in any way. That's actually quite hard to do, and you'll probably end up with something very similar to "assigned gender at birth".

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Laura_Sandra•

question

Here might be a number of explaining resources.

And here was a summary as PDF with explanations that are easy to understand, and that can also be sent to others.

And this may help show that important is how people feel and not outer body parts, and that identity and orientation etc. are different things, and that they are on a spectrum.

hugs

1