Should I Accept This Motherboard?
Help BaPC
I come to you all with an inquiry into what would you do in my situation. To put my situation in context the computer I’m referring to is my storage server that I store my photos and videos on. Last week the x99 system that the server was running on finally gave out so it was on the road to upgrades for me.
I purchased a motherboard on hardwareswap. It was listed as being in excellent condition and it was for a decent price. It arrived in good packaging and I opened it to find immediately, one of the three m.2 shields is missing. Upon further inspection I noticed the VRM heat sink was loose and unsecured. I have yet to boot it up because the VRM thing is a big red flag for me. I can’t for the life of me understand why someone would have removed it. As this motherboard is supposed to support a server I use for work I’m unwilling to accept he that will fail on me out of the blue again. I’m worried that the lack of proper VRM cooling could severely impact the performance and lifespan of the CPU and board.
So builders, what would you do? Request a refund and keep looking or am I overthinking it? All comments are appreciated.
EDIT: I’ll be using a 5800x with an option to move up to 5950x if needed. 64GB of RAM eventually to be bumped to 128GB
Posted Jun 20, 2022, 5:24 PM UTC · edited
To me, the only concerning part is the VRM heatsink. I almost never use the M.2 covers.
Is the VRM heatsink missing screws, or is it simply loose? If simply loose and you can screw it back in until snug, I'd say you're OK. I've received brand new motherboards where the heatsinks were a bit loose and just tightened them myself. If it's missing screws altogether though, that's a problem (request refund).
FWIW, I wouldn't be buying a used motherboard for any sort of critical application. For fun/personal use, sure, but for work? No.
The VRM heat sink is missing screws. And while I totally agree about the used HW, I was in a bit of a pinch and it seemed like the fastest fix.
Yah, fair enough. Sometimes used is the fastest solution.
I'd request a return. You can't run it with missing VRM heatsink screws, and I'd be very wary of any aftermarket replacements. Who knows what the correct screw type is.