r/PLC•
oomchu

Question about VFDs.

I currently have a conveyor with a 1 hp motor that is being driven by a powerflex 4 VFD that is also 1 hp. My question is, if I were to switch the motor to a 0.5 hp motor could I use the same VFD? I had assumed that the power rating of a VFD was a maximum and anything less than or equal to that rating could be driven by the VFD. However, my knowledge is less than stellar in this area.

Posted Jun 21, 2022, 3:03 PM UTC

226
BrianFischman•

Yes, just change the motor data settings in the drive to match the motor

20
oomchuOP•

Ok, thanks for the feedback.

3
PLCGoBrrrBit Plumber Extraordinaire•

It will work fine. One customer I have does not want anything less than 3HP drive in the plant no matter how small the motor is so they don't have a bunch of different part numbers to worry about.

9
BrianFischman•

I have dealt with this at one client site. All drives are 5hp minimum.

1
Mizral•

What the heck why would someone ask for this? Do they just not know what they are doing or is there some reasoning?

-1
framethatpacket•

Less VFDs to keep in stock as spares?

11
BrianFischman•

What does it matter, as long as the drive is larger then the motor, it’s just a matter of changing the data in the drive. Why keep 10 different size drives on the shelf, if I can keep multiple of same size for half the price. This makes the bean pushers happy.

That’s the philosophy I run into frequently

3
Mizral•

I'm newer to the industry and working for a system integrator so perhaps I don't see that side of things. But I see two major problems with this strategy:

1 - If supply is short on that particular drive you are fucked. I've been doing a lot of purchase orders for VFD's lately and the lead times are not great for some models. 2 - Aren't you in some ways just throwing away money by having oversized drives? If you could have chosen between two drives and one is $500 cheaper and you went with the bigger one out of convenience, it seems like you are throwing money away when the actual job of sizing the VFD can be done rather trivially.

I get that 'it's easier' and maybe satisfies accountants but it seems like you might run into problems.

0
critik•

Definitely a thing.

Some plants (especially automotive) have thousands of drives and surprisingly little shelf space for spares (for whatever reason). They'd rather keep 10 of a single part number on hand than 2 of 5 different part numbers. Yes, it could be more expensive, but those sorts of places have figured out that the benefit outweighs the cost in their case.

The case of using a 5hp drive for a 1hp application is a little more extreme, though. It's more common to segment everything (0.5hp, 0.75hp, 1hp motors all just get 1hp drives, for example) in a way that makes sense.

Many VFDs come in different 'frame sizes', so a 0.5hp drive might be the same physical size as a 1hp. It could very well be the same drive, but software limited! In those cases, the cost differences aren't so big...

2
Mizral•

Thanks for the details, sorry if I seem obtuse I just am just curious. I am doing a lot of work with VFDs recently and am reading manuals a lot. Most VFD manuals tell you not to oversize too much I think this is due to the current sensing being thrown off in higher current applications. Not only that but conductor sizes in have to be sized based on the VFD not the motor so your conductors are all now more expensive. Is the utility factor of just using one really worth all that money? I can imagine with hundreds of VFDs this might get more economical but even then you add up x100s of oversized VFDs and conductors and man that is a lot of money!

1
MargertitaMan•

I had a machine that I changed out forty-one PF 40's w/22-comme cards for PF525's. Motor sizes varied 1-5 hp w/a mean hp rating of 2.1 hp. We purchased all 5hp drives.

  1. I received a buy 5 get 1 free discount from my distributor plus 50% deep discounts. The quantity buy was key to driving the unit costs down as well
  2. We only have to stock one pn as opposed to four.
  3. I configured all the drives on the bench w/CCW and really only had to change the FLA for each motor & IP addresses. Maybe a few acc & dec parameters.
3
TexasVulvaAficionadoCustom Flair Here•

VFDs will generally work fine on motors down to about 10% of their rated size. Smaller than that and you run into issues.

You'll be fine.

3
rdrast•

Eh, in V/HZ mode, our 3500HP Powerflex ran a 5 HP test motor just fine 🙂

Just playing around, but it did verify the drive was functional.

2
TexasVulvaAficionadoCustom Flair Here•

Yea, the primary problems you'll see when using a VFD that's oversized are when using a vector mode on a complex application. Speed control and overload control get wonky.

2
rdrast•

Absolutely true, they cant calculate the motor model, it gets lost in precision. No my old favorite, Graham 1570's? They would run anything from 1/1000 rated HP to at least 250% rated.

Wonder what ever happened to Graham. I used to work on a ton of them back in the day.

2
TexasVulvaAficionadoCustom Flair Here•

I thought they got bought/merged by Danfoss, but it looks like they might have their own thing again: https://www.grahammotorandcontrols.com/

Hard to say...

2
Shalomiehomie770•

Oversized don’t undersize. So yeah you’ll be fine. But I wouldn’t put a 1hp motor on a 0.5 drive

2
MrMime-godmode•

Not to mention if it's a powerflex drive the Human interfaces are interchangeable so it makes trouble shooting easier the only difference with those drives when it come to size is the power controller portion which while you maybe able to downsize it a bit I wouldn't recommend it because the internal components do differ as you increase the horse power so they won't last as long as they should resulting in more money loss. So basically you can swap the human interface only but not the rest of it (for best results)

1
GoupilFroid•

Siemens says to avoid going under a third of the drive rated power, probably mostly to cover their ass

1