Atheists, do you find supernatural horror films scary or does your non-belief surpass a fear response?

I'd describe myself as agnostic pretty much 98% non-believing, but was raised catholic and grew up around local legends of the banshee/haunted houses etc and these films manage to scare me because somewhere inside me I believe in the possibility that ghosts exist. Of course I'm assuming that most atheists wouldn't believe in any supernatural occurences. Maybe this question is asked a lot as well.