Caribbean honeymoon destination

I have been trying to look into options for a Caribbean honeymoon, but all of the islands look so lovely. How do I choose one?

We definitely want a place where we can relax at the beach, get massages, eat delicious food, and worry about nothing. Inclusive resorts sound like a good deal, but I don't have any experience with them. How would I choose?

I know we will also want to be in a place that we can still explore the island's culture and history, so nowhere too remote or where we can't leave the resort.

I've been looking into Puerto Rico, Curacao, and Bermuda. Any recommendations about these or any other islands? Thanks so much!

Oh, and we won't be going until next June, but I'm just a bit excited and can't help but but look into it already! :-)