Is this normal?

Hi y'all! This morning my sister (20F) had an attitude for no reason with my (18F) brother (24M) and I. I asked her if she had seen my black jacket and she said she put it in her bag in her room (idk why she did that because I wear it all the time). I gave her a look because she was giving me attitude for asking a simple question and i was fed up with how she was treating me. After I gave her a look, I start past her to go up the stairs and she got aggressive and said "what's the look for" and hit my arm. I then yelled at her not to touch me and if she ever touched me again, I would punch her back (basically implying that she was starting a fight she couldn't finish). As a person, she's a control freak and when she gets mad, she'll try to hit me and I'm angry but idk if it's justified because it's not like she's caused me great bodily harm or hit me in the face. I would like to add that about a year ago, her and my older sister (28F) were arguing and she whipped a phone at her which left a bruise where her ribs are. Is any of this normal? How do I deal with this behavior? Here's a photo of the bruise: https://ibb.co/pff3mJs

Posted Jun 26, 2022, 11:20 AM UTC

06
gooberfacedElder Sage [318]•

Sounds to me as if none of you know how to have a conversation without fighting- you're all just stuck in your immature childhood dynamic as siblings.

Try discussing things like adults- no yelling, no hitting, no childish BS.
Call a family meeting to have a talk about all of this- you guys are adults now and need to start communicating like adults.
If you're the only one refusing to play these childish games then so be it- leave them to their foolishness. But don't take part, walk away.

3
NoticeSubstantial225OP•

I completely 100% agree with you. I'll never get physical with anyone (my dad was physically abusive so I don't want anyone else to feel how I felt) but she has a tendency to get physical with me when she's upset. At that point, to me, all bets are off: if someone hits me, I might hit back. I yelled at her because of my history with my dad and that's the one thing I swore I wouldn't let anyone else get away with. I told her she has anger issues but she doesn't see it. In general, she doesn't respect me and tries to control me and there's so many things wrong with our relationship. I'm honestly tired of the whole family dynamics and it's so surreal that people act like that in real life. I just need confirmation from someone who isn't part of my fucked up family to tell me that this is not okay because sometimes I feel like I might deserve it.

1
oiledbroccoliAdvice Guru [73]•

I think there's part of the point you're missing here. The argument this morning didn't poof into of existence. She has a little attitude, and that should be fine, whatever, wrong side of the bed she'll be alright after breakfast or whatever. Hell, maybe you misinterpreted, that's likely even imho. But instead, you throw the perceived attitude right back. Big sis then does overstep a line a bit by hitting you in the arm. Granted, a light hit is honestly reasonable between siblings, but a serious hit is an overstep by her. Then the situation escalates further, by turning a "hey don't hit me" into "touch me again, and I'll kick your f#cking ass". Ya see how this wasn't an argument about the jacket or about nothing? You thought she had an attitude, so you gave her one, she escalated, you escalated, and here we are. Not saying you were wrong, just saying there are better ways to deal with these situations when you're in them, or better yet, avoid them altogether.

That being said, while yes your sister should work on her actions, understand that you can only control your actions, not those of others. For slight bits of attitude/aggression, or something you think might be attitude, just give the benefit of the doubt/that they're just not in a good mood, and let it go. Don't throw it back at them, it only makes it worse. And, if a fight has already started/looks like it's about to start, cut it off. I can basically guarantee It's never that big a deal. Say whatever, say okay, say 'I mean, I guess'--heck, even just walk away.

1
Disastrous-Brush620Super Helper [8]•

Its natural for siblings to fight here and there try to save her because that temper will get her in big trouble at some point on her life. Anger management might be needed if she refuses you did your best stay away

2
NoticeSubstantial225OP•

I'm currently living with her for the moment but I'm going to try to get away asap. I've already told her I think she has anger issues but she doesn't seem to comprehend it or try to change her behavior at all.

1
Disastrous-Brush620Super Helper [8]•

I see just try to stay on her good side and work hard towards your out

1