Who would become the new Boss if Tony died?

Spoiler

I’m sure it’s been asked here before but I just finished the show and new to this subreddit. I know if Silvio survives he’d be next in land but he probably won’t want it especially after almost getting killed. So hypothetically let’s say he makes it but doesn’t want it who do you think he’d back as new boss. Larry Barese comes to mind since he’s the most senior Capo and has the largest Crew. But who do you all think would be candidates and do think a civil war in the family would happen like New York when Little Carmine and Johnny Sack went at it? I love to see this discussion.

Posted Jun 29, 2022, 6:46 PM UTC

1049
Jeberani•

Paulie fits the profile...this guy is at the age of Junior Soprano and still a foot soldier.

18
IceComprehensive6440OP•

He was a Capo wasn’t he?

14
Jeberani•

He is, although he still goes on the streets collecting errands for Tony.

9
Jazzlike_Page508•

Honestly absorbed. But I was thinking Patsy since his son is marrying Meadow…if that means anything. It could be a triumvirate like what Tony was trying to do with Lorraine.

15
IceComprehensive6440OP•

What is this the fucking U.N now?

21
IceComprehensive6440OP•

But seriously I could see the New York Crew absorbing what was left.

10
Snstrmnstr•

That's what I figured, too. I don't think Paulie would want the job and I'm pretty sure NY wouldn't think twice about killing him anyway just to make sure he didn't get it. Christopher, Junior, Silvio, and as I interpret it Tony too, all gone and/or incapacitated. I like the whole Soprano operation would fade away.

1
FWdem•

Patsy, Paulie, and whoever is running the Barese Crew are about all that is left.

12
IceComprehensive6440OP•

Larry Boy is a guest of the government still have. Have a hard time thinking Albert would be boss. Imagine that parakeet as a Boss

4

Can you imagine that. Youre a parakeet and one week later youre the boss?

9
MrBad1993•

He was a boss the parakeet

2
Woodchipper_AF•

it won't be cinematic

4
stugots__•

Paulie running things? Not that stronzo. Not in this life.

3
DocSanchezAOE2•

AJ of course, the Hair Apparent.

7
toblerownsky•

Probably should start him off small with Capo of event planning.

2
BillSharph•

Definitely Pauli. He paid his dues and he knows NY well. He’s also the guy Tony takes with him to the sit-down with Butch before they take out Phil

6
singh853•

He lived through the '70s by the skin of his nuts when the Colombos were goin' at it, for Christ’s sake!

3
cassiuswright•

Patsy with Paulie support https://youtu.be/hy4AGeuQ5pM

4
IceComprehensive6440OP•

After watching that video it seems like a stretch using random dreams from earlier season as proof isn’t strong evidence. I could see it being the other way around Paulie who’s a Capo with Patsy Support. That face Paulie gets when he says he’d give the Construction gig to Patsy made makes me think Paulie may have promised that spot to Patsy himself for when he becomes boss of the family

4
cassiuswright•

It's a LOT more than random dreams 🤣

It's patterns of behavior from all three characters - Tony, Patsy, and Paulie- across the whole series. You're gonna see it totally different when you watch it again with this theory in mind 🤷

1
IceComprehensive6440OP•

It more shows that they might’ve killed him not that they’d become boss if anything if people found out they killed him they could never be boss

1

They would probably just be absorbed at that point

4
IceComprehensive6440OP•

Would the other 5 families let that happen?

3
tonysopranosalive•

Probably. Soprano NJ family wasn’t/would never be as powerful as one of the NY five families/The Commision. Lupertazzi fam would probably absorb their assets due to their relationship built between Johnny Sack and Tony, and income would be whacked up between the families so everyone gets their share.

5
SonnyBurnett189•

I always figured that Patsy, Paulie, and the Bareses would keep their crews while the Lupertazzis move some of their guys in to fill in some of the vacancies like the Aprile crew. Then they kick up to either the underboss or consigliere, presumably Little Carmine.

2
IceComprehensive6440OP•

I’m sure Butch would be the new Boss Little Carmine doesn’t want it

2
FWdem•

Larry gave up a murder victim (and pinned it on Jackie Aprile). Maybe he is getting our soon. He would have to be more removed than last time he was out, but he could be Boss with Allie Boy or someone else running the crew day to day.

3
IceComprehensive6440OP•

Imagine that becoming Boss then the next week you go to jail

2
vrcity777•

Paulie doesn't have the brains for the top spot, and ironically, he's too smart to want it. So it'll probably go to Patsy, with Paulie as underboss (just the way he planned it with Butchie).

3
Wiscooooo2210•

Aj. He’d be great at planning all the events

3
Hopeful_Cod_8486•

I DONT EVEN KNOW WHAT THAT IS!!!

3
Hopeful_Cod_8486•

Obviously the criminal mastermind Benny Fazio

3
IceComprehensive6440OP•

With Tony gone you just know Benny first order of business is putting a hit out on Artie.

2
Cjones2607•

Larry Boy with Albert as acting.

Biggest crew and biggest earners. Didn't have big loyalties to Tony like Paulie didn't. Relatively low drama. Albert would've been easy to control.

Neither Paulie or Patsy were in the leadership or Capos (Paulie was at the very end I think). Albert was at least acting Capo for awhile and kicking up a lot. Might have even been fourth senior of what we saw after Paulie, Patsy, and Larry Boy.

2
OkConsequence6355•

IMO, and there’s lots of evidence for it, Patsy and Paulie agreed with New York that Tony had to go (esp given Phil’s public death in front of his family, NY would have looked impossibly weak not to respond even if they were glad to be rid of Phil)

Paulie didn’t really have the mind or skills for being a boss - or the desire - but would have been a respected and senior figure in the aftermath

Patsy would have been boss, younger and sharper than Paulie, and you can see the ambition of him and his wife when he visits Tony’s house at the end

He may well not have had the same power or money as Tony after the chaos of the war, but there would have been a remnant Jersey family - more under the thumb of New York but with an (initially at least) good relationship given the deaths of the two feuding bosses as a result of an agreement between lower ranks of NY and NJ

2
IceComprehensive6440OP•

So you thinking Patsy Boss and Paulie Consigliere? It just seems odd that a soldier would jump Capos to be Boss even with Paulie support you’d have guys Like Larry and Alley Barese that have a larger crew and by that point been the largest reigning Capo. Perhaps one of them could be made Underboss to placate them

2
OkConsequence6355•

It could be that Larry or Albert get it, it’s a bit of a blind spot considering they don’t appear much in the show - and I admit to overlooking them.

Maybe they were in on it too, and the new boss had been pre decided amongst them, whoever it would be.

Perhaps it was for reasons of time, but not seeing much of either two may well indicate that they were very happy in their position, keeping their heads down. Wise guys are shown to be conscious of the heat that being a boss brings, see Tony’s logic behind keeping Uncle June boss.

1
crustyytuna•

How come nobody is saying Silvio? I know he was left in a coma the end of the show, but let’s assume he survives. I would think Silvio is much better equipped than Paulie

1
IceComprehensive6440OP•

Silvio didn’t want it it gave him a asthma attack and most likely after getting shot multiple times wouldn’t want that target on his back either

1
Ok_Sail_3052•

Noah

1
IceComprehensive6440OP•

My theory is Noah whack Tony he said he’s punch his lights out that’s why the show cuts to black at the end he punched his lights out.

2
90sfemgroups•

Carm and Furio marry. Furio runs the businesses and Janice runs the Family. Paulie remains loyal soldier #1. Silvio gets anything he wants.

1
IceComprehensive6440OP•

Janice nobody would listen to her

1
Ok_Conference3799•

We can't have this conversation again.

1
IceComprehensive6440OP•

I already said I’m sure y’all had it before

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Half-Icy•

Nobody.
They're a glorified crew!

1
Krieg_Supremacy•

Bobby Jr

1