r/sysadmin•
eob157

MSP charges for browser updates?

Hey y'all long time lurker first time poster.

I recently started a new job and one of my roles is tech manager. While fan a tech guy I have not been the liaison between a company and their MSP. I just received the first invoice from them since I started and was shocked to find a lot of quarter hours charged to updating chrome & Firefox. Is this normal? When I say a lot I mean at least a quarter of our billable hours to them. Is this normal? Before I go talk to them about it I want to know if it’s SOP in the industry.

Thanks for your help

Posted Jul 1, 2022, 10:27 PM UTC

2250
benderunit9000SR Sys/Net Admin•

I'd check your contract.

I would never pay for that. Browsers update themselves.

29
vCenteredSr. Sysadmin•

They do if they're being used regularly.

We got dinged for a while on vulnerability scans for old Firefox versions on devices where it wasn't being opened regularly.

Our solution to remove it entirely since it isn't used and we don't have a great third party patching solution yet.

11
TheMilkMan4•

There's a gpo for background updates. I just built some policies out for us.

2
dvali•

Even if they're not being used regularly, they can be updated automatically by any deployment tool.

0
vCenteredSr. Sysadmin•

Sure, but that's not what I responded to.

"Browsers update themselves".

If you are updating them with a tool, they're not updating themselves. Literally the opposite.

I mentioned a specific case we ran into at work where Firefox was on our image but none of the preliminary work had been done to set up the background updater, which means it would have to be opened to update itself.

We looked into it and I'm pretty sure that setting up the background updater after the fact still required the browser to be opened at least once, and maybe a configuration change on each machine. I don't remember the specifics.

We don't use Firefox and are specifically required to use Chrome or Edge (don't get me started on the "or"), so it wasn't worth the time investment for us to figure out. We just pushed a script to uninstall it completely.

No reason to manage something that isn't being used and will still show up on vulnerability scans if it isn't 100% current all the time.

3
eob157OP•

That's what I thought. I'm going to read the contract on Tuesday.

4
TechFiend72CIO/CTO•

OS and application patching is usually all covered in your endpoint mgmt cost.

7
DertyCajun•

I manage an MSP. Why are you working with an MSP that is billing you hourly? Why aren’t they automating that process? Are they a really small shop or just really greedy?

4
eob157OP•

We’re charged a rate based on what level of service the ticket requires. I haven’t been charged for the in person meeting we had nor the (sometimes) hour long phone calls we engage in so I don’t think they’re being greedy. I was brought on to right the ship and I’m trying to figure out where we are being overcharged and what things we can get rid of in favor of newer and more reliable hardware and services. Our current infrastructure is nearly a decade old and has more bandaids than a thing that has a lot of Bandaids.

3
R1skM4tr1x•

Don’t forget that your company could have put themselves in this position by treating the msp as their local high school tech guy and nickel and dining them and refusing suggested upgrades. It’s something I’ve seen with the SMB/MSP cybersecurity dance.

Be sure they are willing to spend once you figure out the warts.

1
HotPieFactory•

Are they a really small shop or just really greedy?

Or maybe the previous manager refused to pay a flat rate for updates or endpoint management. There really can be many reasons for why it is how it is. No need to blame the MSP before you know the facts.

1
lemachet•

I mean, if we have a bunch of end users calling to get us to do that, and it's not a covered jtem for some reason (or they are hourly) then we'd charge. Even if it's supposed to happen automagically,

"EU reqd immed assist upgd browser."

25
eob157OP•

Thanks for the comment. We have less than a dozen users that are Office Staff and are covered by the MSP. Of that dozen only 2 actually make regular tickets to the MSP and never about a browser update. There are way more charges for Chrome and Firefox updates than active devices on the network.

12
lemachet•

Ask them about it.

10
eob157OP•

Just requested the contract

7
Brook_28•

Where I work, this would be something we'd script via our rmm tool. If a client were to ask to have a new app deployed or updated company wide then we'd consider that a small project and it would be scoped out and sow provided.

6
Steve_78_OHSCCM Admin and general IT Jack-of-some-trades•

Chrome and (I believe) Firefox apply and necessary updates automatically when they're closed. So unless if they made some sort of GPO changes that prevent the automatic upgrade, I would definitely question WTF they're doing.

4

In controlled environments, the software does not get to update itself, auto updates are disabled. The IT team or their automation tools do the work. This enables them to reject unwanted updates and keeps them in control.

3
Steve_78_OHSCCM Admin and general IT Jack-of-some-trades•

Yes, but if they're preventing automatic browser updates so that they can charge more for manually updating browsers, that's a pretty big issue.

1
unccvince•

I fully agree with you u/Technical-Message615. Letting users run as root is not a good recipe for success.

Letting users run and update unmanaged binaries from their home directory is also a pending disaster.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Brook_28•

It depends on what's in or out of scope. We have multiple levels of agreements with our clients. Some where everything is billable and out of scope and they pay for it, others have everything in scope and they pay for it.

3
vCenteredSr. Sysadmin•

These are likely tickets being auto created by the MSP's RMM software whenever it runs updates.

When I worked for a MSP we did this to pad ticket counts and "show value". Basically to show customers who didn't call us a lot that we were "doing" "something".

Similar tickets were created for auto scheduled disk cleanups, etc.

18
eob157OP•

I hope this isn't it because when I did my "Please Get Me Up To Speed" interview with them they really talked up their ticket turnaround time. I'm hoping they weren't trying to pull something over on my being new.

8
vCenteredSr. Sysadmin•

You could have both these and fast turnaround on tickets. I'm just saying, it's a totally normal thing for tickets to be created and closed by the automation software with a small time allotment to show value.

If you're being billed for those 15 minute automated items, that's a different thing entirely and if I were you I'd take a real hard look at the contract, ask for a report of all tickets opened in the last year, including who opened them.

8
yuhche•

ask for a report of all tickets opened in the last year, including who opened them.

Finally someone said it! Either do this or request for your own account on their ticketing system and have a look at the tickets created for your company yourself then match up the ticket creation dates to update release dates for all browsers in use at the company.

4
AussieTerror•

Depends on the customer and contract, I've seen customers who use products like Tenable to monitor vulnerabilities. As soon as an update drops they demand all browsers in their organization be updated immediately to prevent vulnerabilities.

It's more effort than assumed to get browser updates to happen on a schedule, most require the end users to restart their browsers.

So, if they want expedited updates like this vs allowing the updates to happen automatically over time, then absolutely they should pay.

Explain to the customer that its not designed to update the way they expect, as well as what effort will be required around monitoring versions and contacting end users to update.

6

MSP owner here. Unless your contract says otherwise, this sounds shady. Browser updates can be automated through their RMM so they don't need to be performed manually.

5
vCenteredSr. Sysadmin•

They may very well still generate tickets with a small time allotment, and that is fairly normal. It shows something reportable to the customer about value being provided.

7
ccantrell13•

I could see this being a thing if they weren't charging hourly on the tickets. Honestly I dont know why OP would be paying an MSP hourly anyway.

2
MyMonitorHasAVirus•

MSP owner here, also agree this is shady. It shouldn’t be billable either way. Ultimately it depends on the contract, and maybe it’s excluded for some reason, but our third party patching is included and if someone needed a manual update in between regular, automatic updates it would be covered under normal helpdesk labor. I can’t imagine an MSP excluding any labor category from a contract that would include updates like this.

1
walkerreuben•

I've seen some RMM automation billed, but it was always "we detected a problem and resolved it, such as some clever event log monitoring with autoremediation.

Patching is a planned and scheduled automation that should be covered by the basic concept of managed services.

3
MyMonitorHasAVirus•

Yes I agree. Like I said this sound shady.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
vCenteredSr. Sysadmin•

Gonna eat crow here. Didn't read op close enough and didn't see they were being charged.

Read that contract and ask for a report of all tickets over the last year.

1
lemachet•

I mean, if we have a bunch of end users calling to get us to do that, and it's not a covered jtem for some reason (or they are hourly) then we'd charge. Even if it's supposed to happen automagically,

"EU reqd immed assist upgd browser."

2
BadSausageFactory•

Are users putting in tickets or is this techs randomly logging in and updating things manually? Replacing the processor threads with fresh recycled ones?

2
JayDeeEss•

Check the contract. You need to confirm what is in and out of contract and what is billable at time and materials

2
axis757•

This is pretty bizarre IMO. "Patch management" is included in our MSPs standard package and includes Windows updates and other application updates since all of that is updated through their RMM tool. Also includes reporting and internal access to the RMM tool. Either they don't have it managed automatically through an RMM, and it would almost certainly be worth the time/effort to get that setup, or they're milking you.

1
DeadEyedAdmin•

No not normal, I mean a one off.....maybe.

Any good MSP will sell you a RMM for remoting in and managing devices. Any decent RMM can do windows and third party patching. Your browser updates should be included in that RMM Agent Fee, which may or may not also be bundled with an AV client.

You getting taken for a ride.

1
gigabyte898Windows Admin•

Previously owned and currently work at an MSP. Maybe, you’ll want to dig out the contract and figuring out what is and isn’t covered. Most places include patch management, some make it billable. Although billing for browser updates definitely feels excessive. At my past and current MSP we’d never itemize that out, it’d just be something we do under the normal support fee. A lot of patch management is automated with a periodic human spot check to make sure it’s working properly.

Quick phone call to the MSP might clear it up, and if not at least you can get information on when you can get out from under their management. There’s a running “low barrier to entry” joke in the MSP space but it’s unfortunately true. I’ve taken on a lot of business from people who worked in tech roles and rock at them but don’t really have the business experience to back up running a service provider, running into these sorts of billing/account management pain points. Until I got my own footing I was myself included in that group. If you do end up moving away from this provider definitely shop around. Get several competing quotes, ask questions about their business. How long they’ve been operating, what kind of background their staff has, etc.

1
tbakerweb•

10 year MSP manager here.

Preface this with a few things to get them out of the way.
I ran both Billable-hourly, fixed fee/steady state support covering windows, Mac, and Linux. Depends when, who and how it was sold, but it was my job to oversee it all. Roughly 2500 endpoints, including AV, Patching and a load of others.

Check your contract, any amendments to it, and talk to your account manager. Job 1 is understanding what's in place, and how it works. Then you can understand how and what to change.

Many of our clients were a hybrid of fixed fee, and were built based on the scope of the contract. Regardless, as a good MSP, we provided a comprehensive time and service accounting for all activities. The hours it showed matched what was listed as the monthly 'used', but didn't affect the cost shown on the invoice.

Either way, find out what you're committed to, for how long.

1
digitaltransmutationThis flair is only meant for the person to whom it was addressed•

Make sure those browsers are in fact configured to auto update. There are some 3rd party app updaters (PDQ does this) that 'helpfully' disable the built in updater because they assume you only want updates from there.

The only time I ever bill time into app patches is when they are on the 'patch missing > x days' report and that is something I have learned to look out for. Just force the browser's setting in gpo and they will never show up there again.

1
discosoc•

What does the service contract say?

1
Virtual-Lobster5595MSP Monkey•

They might have to package the updates and push them out over RMM, SCCM or intune? Depending on the settings.

1
lad5647•

Not unheard of in environments where the application stack requires heavy testing & UATing.

Again all depends on the contract on the supported design of the SOE.

1
Relagree•

Browsers update themselves. Patching should be included anyway.

You've probably for line items for "Downloaded more RAM" and "Defragged CPU" if you look closely...

1
cabledog1980•

NO, that's an MSP trying to run up hours on you. Browsers will update automatically unless set not to. There was a vulnerability that needled to be patched in Chrome but Google pushed out the fix quickly. I used to work for msps and that's clearly a times are slow cash grab. They are probably slow right now with all their clients and are looking for things they can bill on. I would not pay for that it's frivolous.

1
vic-traillSenior Bartender•

Here's an alternative; start deploying browser updates by PDQ Deploy free version and stop paying for those updates.

This PDQ page shows you how to create a Chrome update deployment package w/ PDQ Deploy Free mode. It's easy to do the same thing with MS Edge.

These updates come out weekly (at least). A VM and a bit of work up front can keep $$ in your pocket.

1