Why doesn't anyone use the tank commander seat?

Questions

Tank commanders are great.

  • Better visibility with Binoculars/dedicated radio man

  • Extra Hammer and Bmat when you repair.

  • ability to revolver/pitch gun from the hatch when you're being rushed.

  • quickly replace crewmembers who die to gas or get run over.

So, with all the benefits of being in a fully crewed tank, why does no one use the commander role and run just a driver and gunner?

Posted Jul 5, 2022, 7:35 PM UTC · edited

1116
patrickmen11texture man•

Almost always, the answer is going to be in some shape a variant of "not enough people."

60
FrGravel•

You have 10 people who wants to crew tanks. Would you rather have 5 tanks at 80% efficiency? Or 3 tanks at 100%? That’s the question.

Manpower is a finite ressource in foxhole, and most of the time, people chose to crew more tanks rather than have less but more efficient tanks.

I’m not saying it’s the right choice, but it’s the choice most people make.

25
hadhins•

Bolonials will release a skynet commander soon!

"Enemy tank spotted, 120m, NE"

4†
SpectroDE12•

people don't have the need for a dedicated commander or just don't have the people.

Organized regiments have dedicated commanders so extra people in the commander seat is not needed.

10

Tank commander here. it's fun, when people listen to you, and you have to communicate the way your crew likes too. Not super easy but cool and effective when done right. Also you can impress your crew once in a while by popping the occasional sticky rusher with your pistol before hes able to get his grenade off. One of my favorite positions because its chill, your basically an advisor/ visual info dude.

5
lordbaysel:Warden:•
  1. true

  2. True, but this won't save you most of the time, and only slightly increase your time efficiency.

  3. A lot of recently added tanks have better anti infantry weapon then sidearm, so it is only for emergency, also switching between bino and gun is annoying, and regular gunner can also do it by switching, to a degree.

4)that shouldn't happen in the first place

Bigger issue is limited server space. With 3 people in tank instead of 2 you can crew 3 tanks with gunner and driver or 2 tanks with full crew, and fielding more firepower is generally better. Additional crew member is worth it usually only for 1 tank in formation, as long as they are somewhat coordinated.

3
titan_Pilot_Jay•

My regiment normally has 1 tank commander per squad of vehicles, unless it's the new quad, then you go less tanks with a full load so we can use the rockets.

3
TheVenetianMask•

Snipers used to pick them out, before they were trashed.

2
Deep-Temperature-845:Colonial:•

you dont need it

2
King_of_Spaceworms:Warden:•

In my regiment we always have atleast 1 commander who works like a spotter. Its me most of the times that I log in. It saved our tank couple of times. Its more fun than LMG gunner I'll tell you that

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
RegularRoutine7929•

if you have 6 people you can either fully crew 2 tanks or you can have 3 tanks with gunners and drivers

1
Equivalent-Session68:Warden:•

I always prefer to have a tank commander but honestly don't have one about half the time because if someone I only like to have someone I know we'll doing it.

1
tacosan777•

Who tells you they’re not used? Clans usually use them, although only one or two commanders per tank squadron is required. In my former regiment the 1erBH used the leader of the clan as commander always, since it is a perfect magnet to attract shots when it was outside the hatch; he died but the tank never received damage

1
82dkBoston•

There have been times when I sit in world chat for almost an hour asking for a gunner and get no responses. Even less people are willing to do the spotter position even though pitch gun commander is insanely fun. I’ll always welcome a spotter into my tank if someone wants to do it but 9/10 times I’m just going to roll driver gunner for the sake of getting on the field asap

1
FullMetalParsnip:Colonial:•

It can be for a number of reasons.

One very common one is made by newer tankers which is "Commander doesn't shoot/drive tank, so it's not as important", coupled with "Shooting/driving is more fun/more involved so me and my friend want to do the most fun part and don't want someone we don't know bossing us around from the top hatch."

Objectively speaking the best thing to do is have your most experienced person in the Commander seat, your friend in the driver seat then pick up basically anyone for the gun. Gunning is the absolute easiest thing to do in a tank and can be summed up as "Shoot at whatever your commander tells you to". Tanks live or die pretty much exclusively based on situational awareness. A solid majority of tanks killed are from something they didn't see coming, be it a field gun at night/in a bush, a sticky rush or a few RPGs in a trench, or by taking a fight that was worse off for them than they thought because they had no spotter and by the time their gunner could see what they were up against it was too late.

I spend a lot of my time as a tank commander once tanks come out and maintain that no tank-line should be without at least one Commander, unless both you and your 2nd crewmate are really experienced and even then it's probably better to get some random Sgt on the gun.

Literally cannot be stressed enough how situational awareness is the single most important part of tanking and for that reason a tank without a commander will always be way way worse off than one with (assuming he knows what he's doing). Hell, I make every member of my crew carry binos when stocks allow so they can look ahead before we engage so they know what the area looks like/where AI is and what the terrain/cover is going to be.

Edit+P.S Revolver and pitch gun are both worse than the normal pistol firing from the hatch. The entire purpose of the hatch gun for the commander is to stop/kill sticky rushes and the pistol does this best at the longest range, 1 shot will always stagger/slow someone. The pitch gun can't stagger someone in 1 shot and have a narrow cone of fire while the revolver barely has more range than the sticky.

1
venum4k[82DK-✚] send help•

When you've got a tank line or something similar, you can also have a lead tank with a commander doing the leading for multiple tanks without really losing anything besides more eyes as long as the formation doesn't split up too much.

1