Various questions again...

Rules

Hi, it's me again, whoever caused a lot of trouble but somehow people still don't hate me :)

Seriously, thanks for anyone who actually read through all of my stuff previous and this time as well. There are 2 sections where the first part is relatively normal questions, but the second part is more like silly questions from a Chinese quiz.

I did read the related entries from the almanac or the wiki (English material), they are way less detailed than the so-called Chinese wiki, but I doubt all the rules are actually confirmed, therefore the questions.

Anyway, these are the questions.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Relatively normal part 1

  1. Somebody told me that "sects" in "Sects & Violets" is kinda a word play of >!sex !<(maybe not suitable for everybody to view, not sure, spoiler just in case). Is that true? Somewhat it sounds right, but I have no way to confirm and I want to know somehow :^)
  2. The description of Soldier is a bit confusing. Should the Soldier be safe against every Demon ability? For example, if a Soldier is sitting next to No Dashii, he's not poisoned?
  3. Since the game allows you talk during night time, how about a player talk about his madness during night time? I assume the ST can execute somebody during night time. However, do you announce that immediately or at the start of dawn?
  4. When a Pit-Hag creates a Townsfolk with "you start the game" or "once per game" ability, do they need to follow the action order of the night, or just immediately activate? This is rather confusing to me because many characters don't act on second night, so I can't tell the order of this character comparing to the Pit-Hag. For example, if a Pit-Hag creates an Evil Twin, and Evil Twin acts before Witch at the first night, so I don't know how I order them.
  5. A relatively stupid question, whenever the game tells "pick X players", should I always assume it's X different players?
  6. Does resurrection cancel "on death" abilities? For example, if Sweetheart died and got resurrected, the first person who got drunk will sober?

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Part 2: these questions are from a quiz and honestly, it's a bit overboard IMO, but I guess it's good to share here and see how others think, heh. The annoying part is that, there's no answer this time, so it's more like a discussion to all the weird interactions. As always, my thoughts are in spoilers, so please correct me if there's fundamental understanding problems from me. Thanks.

Note: I did the translation, and I double checked a bit, and I think it's unlikely to have translation errors, but sometimes the question is worded weirdly. In case of any problem, please let me know. Thanks.

​

  1. While the information is not clear, the Mutant claims he's the Philosopher and gained Mutant's ability last night. Then, this player goes ahead and say "the Mutant player can come out now because the Storyteller can't execute you anymore." The Storyteller executes the Mutant.

PS: It's a true/false question and hard to translate, but it sounds wrong to just put yes/no in the answer, so I assume "yes" means the ST did something right, and "no" means the ST did something violating the rule.

A. Yes, this can happen

B. No, this shouldn't happen

My thoughts: >!I have no idea on this one. I assume if the other players believe the Mutant player as a Philosopher, then he shouldn't get executed. I picked A, but I'm not sure at all.!<

​

  1. A character is woken and activates their ability. However, this character is drunk before the activation of the ability. When resolving the ability, the Storyteller still places tokens. This character CAN'T be ______?

A. Courtier

B. Philosopher

C. Seamstress

D. Devil's Advocate

My thoughts: >!The Courtier and Seamstress have one time ability, and no matter what, the no ability token should be placed after that, so I ruled out A and C. Then Devil's Advocate needs to place that in order to keep track the "can't pick the same player twice in a role" and obviously Philosopher needs to give him the false activation even they are drunk, so I have no idea again. However, after reading the Courtier entry in the Chinese wiki, it does say it shouldn't place anything if the "drunk for 3 days" has no effect, but I'm not convinced honestly...!<

​

  1. Which of the following statement of the Fortune Teller is WRONG?

A. While Vortox in play, picking the red herring will lead to a "yes" response to the Fortune Teller

B. While affected by Barista's first ability (sober & healthy and get true info), picking the red herring will lead to a "no" response to the Fortune Teller

C. If the Fortune Teller gets a "yes" by picking the red herring, this can be detected by the Mathematician

D. Usually, the red herring player won't be changed in a game.

My thoughts: >!D's wording is kinda annoying... but I assume unless the player somehow turned evil, the red herring shouldn't be changed. C means not intended outcome by Fortune Teller's own ability, so it shouldn't be detected by Mathematician, but does this count as not intended outcome? Not sure. Therefore I ruled out C and D. The rest I have no idea, I just feel B sounds more right than A, so I picked A...!<

​

  1. Which of the following character's gained information will be affected by Vortox?

A. The Apprentice who gets Godfather's ability

B. The Apprentice who gets Dreamer's ability

C. The Drunk who thought they are a Savant

D. The Philosopher who gets Lunatic's ability

Note: >!There's a discrepancy among the 2 wikis and almanac. In the English wiki, Vortox states, "Townsfolk abilities yield false info"; In the almanac, Vortox states, "anytime a good player uses their ability to get information, they get false information"; In the Chinese wiki, Vortox states, "anytime a Townsfolk player uses their ability to get information, they get false information.!<

My thoughts: >!Actually no idea at all, I picked B anyway...!<

​

  1. Usually, the Storyteller can allow which is the following to happen?

A. Let a poisoned Snake Charmer to think they picked the Demon and transformed into a Demon

B. While the Lunatic is drunk, let the Demon know false information about which player the Lunatic has picked

C. Pick Spy as the red herring of the Fortune Teller

D. Let the Lunatic think they are picked by the Exorcist, and don't wake the Lunatic when it's the time for them to "attack"

​

  1. About Zombuul, which of the following statement is WRONG?

A. Only when Zombuul dies for real, and dies from execution, the Mastermind's ability can activate

B. Zombuul "dies" the first time by execution, the Undertaker won't be woken up during that night

C. When Zombuul "dies" the first time, and then get poisoned/drunk, Zombuul won't die for real

D. When Zombuul "dies" the first time, Scarlet Woman can be turned into Zombuul

My thoughts: >!D sounds the most wrong to me so I picked D. C is written in the almanac and it seems A is correct. Honestly, I have no idea about B, but either way, that sounds either way, it exposes the players as a Zombuul, so I'm not sure what will happen there.!<

​

  1. Which of the following will get an exact +1 reading for the Mathematician? [Can choose multiple options]

A. The Soldier, who sits next to No Dashii, is poisoned by the Poisoner

B. During last night, the Philosopher (drunk [status], not the Drunk) picked to gain Savant ability. When in the day, they visit ST and get 2 pieces of true info

C. The Fortune Teller picks the red herring and the Vortox, and gets a "no"

D. The Pit Hag, who is killed by Vigormortis, made themselves into a Flowergirl and lose the Pit Hag ability

E. The Recluse is executed during the day. That night, a sober & healthy Undertaker gets "Imp" as their info

My thoughts: >!C sounds right because the Fortune Teller is affected by the Vortox, and E sounds right because the Undertaker is affected by the Recluse. D sounds everything as intended. Then it's A, firstly I have no idea whether the Soldier will be poisoned by No Dashii (thus quesiton 2 above). However, the problem to me is that nobody touches the Soldier after that, so I don't think it will contribute to Mathematician's reading... Then I don't know about B, and the wording is confusing, but I assume it's drunk due to somebody else, so I picked B, C and E!<

​

  1. Which of the following statement about "backtracking abilities" is correct? [Can choose multiple options]

Note: Maybe "recurring abilities" sounds more right, but honestly this term is never heard of when I'm reading English material, or you can simply assume you need to pick the correct statements.

A. The Professor who chose not to activate their ability this night. During the next night, Pit-Hag changes the Professor into Po. Because this player chose no one last time, so they can attack 3 players as Po that night

B. The Juggler made some guesses during the day, and some of those characters are changed during that night. This won't affect Juggler's number

C. The Scarlet Woman is executed during the day, and the Pit-Hag changed the Scarlet Woman into the Recluse during that night. A sober & healthy Undertaker can get info of any Minion/Demon

D. The Poisoner who chose player X and poisoned them this night. During the next night, Pit-Hag changes the Poisoner into Pukka. Player X will die due to being poisoned last night

E. The Barber died during the day, and then Pit-Hag changes an alive Oracle into Godfather. The Godfather can know all Outsiders and attack using their ability

My thoughts: >!All these (A, D, E) changing character and using their previous abilities into the new abilities sound wrong to me. B and C sound about right so I picked B, C.!<

​

  1. Side question about 14 (true or false):

(1) You (not Juggler) claim you're the Juggler and made public guesses during the day. This night, Pit-Hag changes you into the Juggler, and you learn how many guesses are right

(2) You (not Gossip) make a true public statement during the the day. This night, Pit-Hag changes you into the Gossip, and somebody can die due to your true statement

Note: >!The Chinese wiki states that (1) is false, and (2) is true, but seriously this sounds can't be more BS to me. Hopefully somebody knows how these 2 are different from each other in a more logical way.!<

​

Sincerely thanks whoever reads until the end. Kudos to you!

Posted Jul 7, 2022, 8:28 PM UTC · edited

716
ssojj•
  1. Violets is also commonly misheard as violence too ;)
  2. That is correct, a soldier next to a No Dashii is not poisoned. Safe completely from demon's abilities as long as they are alive.
  3. You would announce the execution at night, announce the death in the morning (as well as any other deaths that night) then go right back to the night phase. Edit: Correction Below
  4. If it is a you start the game knowing ability they would get the information instantly, otherwise they might have to wait till the next night if their turn in the night order has already passed.
  5. That is correct, the Shabaloth must choose two different players for example.
  6. It does. When a character is resurrected, they are considered to be a new instance of that character, so the old sweetheart is gone so someone sobers, and the new sweetheard will poison on death.
9
Bobebobbob•

You don't skip the next day just because a character was executed at night. The Mutant's almanac entry says:

If the Mutant hints that they are the mutant at night, you may execute them that night, even if an execution happened today. Declare that they have died, and continue the night phase as normal. An execution may still happen the next day.

4
GarrettChanOP•

Oh oops, I actually missed the almanac entry for the Mutant. I do think the next day shouldn't be skipped, but I'm not sure whether I should announce the execution.

3
SkidMouse•

Are you 100% sure about the Sweetheart in #6?

Because, if you are right, I believe the Sweetheart needs to be reworded, since there are some things, that logically don't make sense.

In short "When you die" is an event, rather than a persistant status effect. It's not the presence of a dead Sweetheart that causes drunkenness, but rather, the event of a Sweetheart dying.

Assuming your answer above is correct, the Sweetheart would need to be reworded to
While you a dead, 1 player is drunk

If the fact is indeed, that when someone with an event-triggered ability becomes drunk/dead/removed from game, their past event-triggered effects are no longer there, that opens a whole can of worms... For example, an Assassin can kill another player, that player would then have to become alive again, when the Assassin dies, because it was the assasins ability that made them dead.

3
ssojj•

I'm about 95% sure. I know there are no character independent effects in clock tower (other than maybe fang gu, but that is a discussion for another comment). So every effect is attached to a character providing that effect. The townsfolk beside a No Dashii are poisoned, but if the No Dashii turns into a different demon via the Pit Hag, those players are poisoned. This is a constant effect and is only in play so long as the No Dashii is. The same applies to sweetheart, if the sweetheart leaves play, so do all their ongoing effects. Since coming back to life is a new sweetheart, no one is drunk as the sweetheart providing that constant effect is gone. The Assassin example is different since the Assassin is not a constant effect, but one that just changes a character's state, then you can forget about it.

I agree that this isn't that intuitive, and I hope it's explained better in the official rule book since right now the best way to learn the nitty gritty of the rules is to do a bunch of reading on the unofficial discord server.

2
GarrettChanOP•

Thanks!

2
exclaim_bot•

Thanks!

You're welcome!

2
the_slate•

Sex and Violence is a song by The Exploited - a UK punk band from the 80s. Perhaps Steven is a big fan of theirs. Or sex and violence is just something that is used often as a title for things, thus the play on words.

3
Vargen_HK•

It’s also the title to the pilot episode of The Muppet Show.

It’s a pretty common phrase, especially when someone is complaining about the content of movies and books and such.

3
GarrettChanOP•

Oh, it's a cultural reference. Good to learn :)

1
jamie_ca•

Yay quizzes!

7: No execution: The mutant should only be executed if they are mad about being an outsider, and the Philosopher is not an outsider regardless of whether they have gained the Mutant ability.

8: Agree with you, I think that question is wrong (or wrongly translated), all four of those have reminder tokens that should be placed even if they use their ability while poisoned/drunk.

9: It's C - red herring is getting wrong info from their own ability so the Mathematician won't pick up on it. (A) Vortox forces incorrect info, which the red herring already is (source), (B) and similarly Barista forces true info. (D) as you say if the red herring turns evil you need to choose another, but also if the FT is killed and then resurrected (Professor/Shabaloth) it's treated as a "new" FT and the ST may select any play as the "new" red herring.

10: (C), english wiki + recent PDF almanac previews from the kickstarter explicitly call out Vortox affecting Townsfolk only, so it's possible for the Drunk[Savant] to get two true statements.

11: (C) is 100% legit, spy registers good and acquires red-herring-ness (but this is usually bad for Evil). (A) is definitely no, poisoned character can never change gamestate, even to themselves. I'm actually on the fence about both B and D, as "you can but probably shouldn't".

12: Zombuul dying "registers" as a death to other players, so (B) of course the Undertaker would be shown Zombuul :) It's a super-hazardous script combination. (D) is correct for the same reason, (A) is correct because Mastermind explicitly calls out he only triggers if the game would end, and (C) as you say is called out on the wiki.

13: (A) Soldier suffering No Dashii poison due to Poisoner's (redundant, but still a thing). (C) Fortune Teller gets a "no" when picking Vortox, due to Vortox. (E) Undertaker getting incorrect information due to Recluse ability. Incorrect choices: (B) We're only talking about the Drunk here. (D) Pit Hag used their ability, which functioned normally.

14: This I think translates to abilities referencing the previous day. (A) is wrong, Po charge relies on Po actively choosing "no one" for their ability (otherwise they could charge out the gate second night). (B) is correct, their juggle result is decided at the time of juggling. (C) Unsure, I could argue this either way (executed Character, vs current Character of the executed player). (D) is wrong, similar to A Pukka only kills characters selected by the Pukka ability. (E) So long as the Pit Hag acts before Barber, yes on their turn the Godfather can kill due to an outsider having died - the distinction here between A/D is that Godfather is not causing effects based on _Godfather_'s prior actions.

15: In both cases, nothing happens. You did not have the ability at the time you made the guesses, so there's nothing to trigger at night.

3
GarrettChanOP•

Thanks a lot for the detailed explanation, I'll read it whenever I have time :)

For 15, I'll quickly forward this from the Chinese wiki:

It states, there are 2 types of these characters, which involves "objective condition" or "subjective participation".

It's easy to understand "objective condition" as you explained Godfather's condition doesn't require you to be the Godfather.

On the other hand "subjective participation" means you need to select attacking no one as Po, and you will be granted a triple attack next night.

However, the most BS thing to me is that, the wiki classifies Gossip as "objective condition" while it classifies Juggler as "subjective participation".

1
jamie_ca•

I can see the argument they're making, but I disagree.

  • The Juggler makes a public claim, and at the time of claim the ST works out how much of the claim is correct. At night, they wake the Juggler to tell them that number (or a wrong number if they were poisoned).
  • The Gossip makes a public claim, and at the time of the claim the ST works out if it were true or not. At night, if the claim was true (and they were not poisoned) a player dies.

Sounds like the same flow of mechanics to me, making the public statement _as that character_ is what triggers the nighttime effects.

Trying to shoehorn the Gossip as "At night, if you made a truthful Gossip statement yesterday a player dies" just doesn't feel right (and honestly makes the ST's job harder if they need to remember _all_ gossip statements, in case of Pit Hag/Barber shenanigans).

2
GarrettChanOP•

Don't get me wrong. I completely agree with you on this, and yeah, it's stupid to force the ST to remember everything players said and resolve them later.

1
GarrettChanOP•

About 10, I'm confused by your wording as well, so I assume it affects Townsfolk abilities instead of Townsfolk players? Then in this case, an Apprentice getting Dreamer ability sounds like a thing to be affected?

About 11, the wording of the question is strange. I translated it accordingly at least, but that sounds like, "you can but not suggested", which is B, shouldn't be picked here. Honestly I'm not sure...

About 13, sorry for my wording. I thought using lower case "drunk" will make things clear but obviously that's not the case lol. I meant to say the Philosopher is drunk, instead of the Drunk thinks they're a Philosopher.

For others, thanks for the explanation and I do learn a bit from this :)

1
jamie_ca•

Back from the weekend:

10: Yes it's townsfolk abilities, in a Vortox game an Apprentice Dreamer would get false information.

11: Yeah 11B is a strange one. A drunk/poisoned Lunatic would lose its ability to keep the Demon informed of their choices so I think RAW you probably tell the Demon nothing, but giving the Demon wrong/no info makes it more likely that the Lunatic will figure themselves (and that they were drunked) out.

  1. Ah gotcha - Last night when the poisoned Philosopher chose Savant, their power malfunctioned due to another player's ability, +1 for Mathematician. During the day they visit ST and get two true infos, tonight I wouldn't expect the Mathematician to get +1 because there's currently no other player ability affecting the Philo. I think?
1