(Spoilers Extended) Which of the surviving show characters will die in the books?
In his latest Not a Blog post, GRRM stated, among other revelations, that "not all of the characters who survived until the end of GAME OF THRONES will survive until the end of A SONG OF ICE & FIRE". So which of the characters that survived until the end of the show do you think will die in the books?
Polls are limited to just six options, so I've included only the most significant characters. Add other important characters in your replies.
PS: Here's a list of other significant characters who survived in the show:
Edmure Tully
Samwell Tarly
Gilly
Davos Seaworth
Asha Greyjoy
Robert Arryn
Daario Naharis
Meera Reed
Tormund
Grey Worm
Gendry
Bronn
Lollys Stokeworth
Podrick Payne
Illyrio Mopatis
Bronze Yohn Royce
Illyn Payne
Jaqen H'ghar
Tycho Nestoris
Salladhor Saan
Hot Pie
Posted Jul 9, 2022, 11:46 AM UTC · edited
The problem is, you're only looking at main characters here, when George could have just as likely been referring to minor or secondary ones, such as:
Maybe more?
As I mentioned, the poll supports only six characters, so I included only the most significant and asked posters to add additional characters. Though thanks for the list and will add it to the original post.
I don't think any of that six will die. Dany probably will and she's not on the list. She's certainly the only one of "Central Five" (GRRM said they would last through all three books of the planned trilogy) who is likely to die. Likely not because she did on the show, but because of her book fragility, tendencies, and ambiguous prophecies. But main secondary characters and tertiary characters are all fair game for GRRM's elimination bingo Unfortunately, I think Rickon is fair game too. I don't think GRRM will have the heart to kill his alter ego, Sam, or Davos.
George also said that some characters that died in the show will survive in the books, and I'm taking that to mean Dany until I'm proven otherwise.
Me too haha. Maybe Jaime as well.
GRRM's latest announcement has made me more optimistic about Rickon. If he has a role to play, he almost certainly will reunite with his siblings and then he'll be much safer.
Yes, it's made me more optimistic too. I want the wee lad to somehow survive his ominous "Shaggydog" foreshadowing. But I can't see GRRM having five Starks survive, and Rickon is the most expendable of them. The other four are all being groomed for major roles in the two storylines, and I don't foresee any of them dying, so... :( One consolation: Rickon has been overlooked or offstage for practically the entire saga, but it sounds like he will get his moments in the sun. Whether the boy dies or not, it sounds like he will be important to the narrative.
I don't think any of the main ones are very likely to die. Tyrion might, and perhaps Brienne, but only at the very end, after she fulfills her task (I believe she is the Last Hero/Azor Ahai), but it's hard to speculate on them. I believe it's more likely that George was referring to one or more of the secondary characters. Here are some I deem likely: