r/asoiaf•
GMantis

(Spoilers Extended) Which of the surviving show characters will die in the books?

SpoilerEXTENDED

In his latest Not a Blog post, GRRM stated, among other revelations, that "not all of the characters who survived until the end of GAME OF THRONES will survive until the end of A SONG OF ICE & FIRE". So which of the characters that survived until the end of the show do you think will die in the books?

Polls are limited to just six options, so I've included only the most significant characters. Add other important characters in your replies.

View Poll

PS: Here's a list of other significant characters who survived in the show:

Edmure Tully
Samwell Tarly
Gilly 
Davos Seaworth
Asha Greyjoy
Robert Arryn
Daario Naharis
Meera Reed
Tormund
Grey Worm
Gendry
Bronn
Lollys Stokeworth
Podrick Payne
Illyrio Mopatis
Bronze Yohn Royce
Illyn Payne
Jaqen H'ghar
Tycho Nestoris
Salladhor Saan
Hot Pie

Posted Jul 9, 2022, 11:46 AM UTC · edited

1235
The_Coconut_GodBest of 2018 Comment of the Year•

The problem is, you're only looking at main characters here, when George could have just as likely been referring to minor or secondary ones, such as:

  • Sam
  • Gilly (and/or her baby)
  • Davos
  • Asha/Yarra
  • Sweetrobin
  • Daario
  • Meera
  • Tormund
  • Grey Worm
  • Bron
  • Lollys
  • Pod
  • Gendry
  • Illyrio
  • Bronze Yohn Royce
  • Edmure
  • Illyn Payne
  • Jaqen
  • Tycho Nestoris
  • Salladhor Saan
  • Hot Pie
  • Archmaester Ebrose

Maybe more?

35
GMantisOP•

As I mentioned, the poll supports only six characters, so I included only the most significant and asked posters to add additional characters. Though thanks for the list and will add it to the original post.

3
CaveLupum•

I don't think any of that six will die. Dany probably will and she's not on the list. She's certainly the only one of "Central Five" (GRRM said they would last through all three books of the planned trilogy) who is likely to die. Likely not because she did on the show, but because of her book fragility, tendencies, and ambiguous prophecies. But main secondary characters and tertiary characters are all fair game for GRRM's elimination bingo Unfortunately, I think Rickon is fair game too. I don't think GRRM will have the heart to kill his alter ego, Sam, or Davos.

8
xAyjay18•

George also said that some characters that died in the show will survive in the books, and I'm taking that to mean Dany until I'm proven otherwise.

7
sangvine•

Me too haha. Maybe Jaime as well.

1
GMantisOP•

GRRM's latest announcement has made me more optimistic about Rickon. If he has a role to play, he almost certainly will reunite with his siblings and then he'll be much safer.

6
CaveLupum•

Yes, it's made me more optimistic too. I want the wee lad to somehow survive his ominous "Shaggydog" foreshadowing. But I can't see GRRM having five Starks survive, and Rickon is the most expendable of them. The other four are all being groomed for major roles in the two storylines, and I don't foresee any of them dying, so... :( One consolation: Rickon has been overlooked or offstage for practically the entire saga, but it sounds like he will get his moments in the sun. Whether the boy dies or not, it sounds like he will be important to the narrative.

2
The_Coconut_GodBest of 2018 Comment of the Year•

I don't think any of the main ones are very likely to die. Tyrion might, and perhaps Brienne, but only at the very end, after she fulfills her task (I believe she is the Last Hero/Azor Ahai), but it's hard to speculate on them. I believe it's more likely that George was referring to one or more of the secondary characters. Here are some I deem likely:

  • Salladhor Saan - simply because I expect Euron to gain dominion over the Stepstones and the Narrow Sea, and book Euron is not a merciful guy. It could also be viewed as karma for not staying true to Stannis.
  • Daario - he may not die in Meereen (in fact, I expect him not to; we'll think he's safe after he survives that, but he'll die with Missandei in a twist revenge trap sprung by by Mellario Martell), but he likely won't be around if we expect Dany to look for solace in Jon's arms.
  • Illyn Payne - he was the man who executed Ned, so I expect there will be some comeuppance, either at the hands of the BwB, or the teeth of Nymeria's pack. IMHO there's a good chance he'll be our PoV character for the prologue, and they always die.
  • Grey Worm - he might die in the trap I mentioned earlier. Dany will probably suffer some losses if we expect her to have a believable dark turn. Her number of support characters is also likely to swell if she's going to claim the Dothraki and converge with Tyrion, Marwyn, Moqorro, Jon and perhaps others, so some of her old ones would have to go.
  • Illyrio - the Tattered Prince has unfinished business in Pentos, and Dany may take ill to some of Illyrio's schemes. Both of these are high risk factors. Them and his unhealthy diet...
  • Meera - sad because I like her, but she's not in a safe place. Far from certain, though.
  • Bronze Yohn - I don't think Sweetrobin will die, and I don't expect the Vale to get out of the series without incurring some significant losses of their own, so he might die along the way. Of course, Harry the Heir for sure is a gonner, so it could just be him and some others who were never on the show...
  • Jaqen - because it would be dramatic and there's no real reason for him to survive. His death could mean he passes on some mission to Sarella and by extension Sam and Gilly, driving their story in a new direction. Euron is also headed for Old Town, and it would cement him as a badass if he managed to see through and kill a faceless man (and readers would hate him more for ending Jaqen).
  • Archmaester Ebrose - I mean, mentioning him might have been half a joke, as he's barely mentioned in the books, but he might take up a more significant role in Winds and also end up dead in the sacking? It's not a character we'd care about at the moment, but they did get someone as well known as Jim Broadbent to play him on the show, so who knows?
  • Tycho Nestoris - I'll be the first to claim that Jon's deal with the Iron Bank will prove to be super important, but he does have a signed paper... Plus, Tycho could get killed later on, after he returns to Braavos, and we get to know him better, respect his role in the series and actually care for him.
  • Pod - the implication is that LSH is keeping him as collateral for Brienne's cooperation, and will continue to do so, but for all we know, he's dead already.
5
GMantisOP•

Personally, I'm most pessimistic about the survival chances of Jon and Tyrion. Jon has strong "sacrificial hero" vibes and judging from other examples, those who return to the death only wish to fulfill the tasks they become obsessed with and have no desire to life otherwise. Tyrion has becoming increasingly darker and might be beyond redemption at the end. And he's committed kinslaying and likely to do more of that and it's been mentioned again and again that kinslayers are accursed.

Regarding secondary characters, Thormund and Podrick Payne seem also rather likely to die. Thormund will be involved deeply with the fight against the Others, including leading a likely doomed expedition to Hardhome. Podrick just the kind of character GRRM would kill to create a moral crisis in Brienne's plotline.

21
HanksHistory•

Can’t kill off the tripod. 😢

4
GMantisOP•

I'm surprised at Brienne leading the poll. Considering that she has already been shown to be willing to sacrifice herself to save innocents ("Seven, Brienne thought again, despairing. She had no chance against seven, she knew. No chance, and no choice"), it would not advance in any way the story for her to actually sacrifice her life. Though perhaps she's leading because most convinced that GRRM will not kill his main characters.

Wonder if the percentages would be different if I'd picked one of the other surviving POV characters (Davos, Sam and Asha), which I thought even less likely to die than Brienne.

16
The_Coconut_GodBest of 2018 Comment of the Year•

A lot of people think it's unlikely for both Jaime and Brienne to survive LSH, so they're banking on her dying because they think Jaime is "more important". I think that's laughably wrong, though - among the two, Brienne is clearly the one with more character growth to go through, and then there's Jaime's dream as well, in which Brienne survives him. Personally, I don't think LSH will kill either of them, but Jaime will eventually die before Brienne.

Of the ones you mentioned, I'd be most worried about Asha, simply because I'm not sure where her story could be headed, and she does have a limp leg that could fail her at the worst possible moment... That being said, I'm not sure how dying could serve her story either, and I'm not fond of killing characters off just to get rid of them, so I'm taking a neutral stance on the subject.

14
natassia74•

I actually suspect he may be talking about Cersei, and that “the end” is being used a little loosely.

14
SerDuncanonyallBest of 2018: Dolorous Edd Award Runner Up•

Agreed. Lena Headey carried Cersei to the final few episodes, but I don’t think Book Cersei will be able to pull it off..

15
HanksHistory•

I think book Cersei is about to get messed up. I don’t really see how she retains power after feast/dance, but maybe im wrong 🥴

5

I had a dream once that Gendry after being legitimatized by Daernys decided he should be King because he was the son of Robert. Then he was killed for that lol.

5
glorilol95•

Arya story Is way too dark and look Way too much a like double edged sword for her to have a the happy ending she have on the show with basically no repercussions

Arya also showed no désire to go West of Westeros at any point of the books....if she do have a happy ending i dont see on where Jon isn't in it

In GRRM original outline the starks are far more dysnfunctional Sansa betray the Starks and is implied to die for her choice while Jon and bran relationship grow and worse as the story goes on...so i dont know

4†
elipride•

While I definitely don't think Arya dying is impossible, we are talking about a story where basically every character is traumatized and dabbling in morally questionable activities, where everyone has a really dark story, what does the darkness in Arya's story in particular has that makes her more likely to die?

14
glorilol95•

While I definitely don't think Arya dying is impossible, we are talking about a story where basically every character is traumatized and dabbling in morally questionable activities

True but Arya kill her first man at 9...and was the closest to experience thé violent and cruelty of that world by Reading her POV Alone you understand that she Is Broken girl that devellope some small form psychopathic tendencies

For me she Is no different than Franck castle ...those aren't thé type to return and have normal life....those characters who are Plague to have tragic ending

-4
elipride•

was the closest to experience thé violent and cruelty of that world by Reading her POV Alone you understand that she Is Broken girl

So, if a person had a traumatic life that means they're broken beyond repair and can't live? I hope you don't apply this philosophy to real life people who went through trauma...

that devellope some small form psychopathic tendencies

I definitely agree her desensitization to violence is a problem, but I don't think that means she has psychopatic tendencies, otherwise she would've had no issue killing the insurance man instead of waiting and waiting trying to find a reason to kill him and only doing it when the kindly man basically convinced her by telling her he was a bad guy who took advantage of widows and orphans. She might have a sense of justice that's too extreme but it exist, she doesn't harm people just because and she can feel empathy and love. She has a lot of psychological issues for sure but I don't see the psychopathy.

And we consider someone has psychopathic tendencies because they did questionable things by our modern standard, you could make an argument for almost every character in this series being a psychopath.

Franck castle ...those aren't thé type to return and have normal life....those characters who are Plague to have tragic ending

I'm not familiar with that Franck guy but let's look at Arya when she was living as Cat. She was content having a stable life, she was making friends, enjoying people's company, other people seemed to enjoy her company, she formed attachments, she helped Sam for no reason, she was relatively happy. Of course she still has issues considering she killed Dareon and she's in a cult that's taking advantage of her situation, but I think that time proves that she's perfectly capable of living a relatively normal life if she had the right environment.

Like I said before, we should not automatically consider people as "broken" and destined to tragedy simply because they have trauma, that's an incredibly harmful mindset. Obviously that is the case for a lot of people, unfortunately, but everyone is different and there're a lot of other people who went through horrible things and made it through.

11
glorilol95•

So, if a person had a traumatic life that means they're broken beyond repair? I hope you don't apply this philosophy to real life people who went through trauma...

Dont be "that Guy"....don't turn a thing from 0 to 100 over something i Never Stated or implied...you know very well what i meant

I speak of storytelling and say that as the story of Arya goes RIGHT NOW thé possibility that maybe go a darker path Is a POSSIBILITY and mostly my own opinion

This isn't Real life but a fantasy World where you actions have consequence for the best or for the worse...

but I don't think that means she has psychopatic tendencies,

She named all the people she going to kill before sleeping, she become more and more unhi'ged and bloothirsty After red wedding and become less and less disturbed by the fzct that she Is murdering people

And let's not speak of her action on the show....killing and cooking people to then slaughtering an entire house isn't just "extrême"...its fucked up no matter of there were innocent or not

If Daenerys did this people would call her mad...

Édit: also Franck castle Is otherwise known "the punisher" a vigilante who kills criminals

-2†
GMantisOP•

I think when GRRM says he might change his mind the next week paying too much attention to an outline he made nearly thirty years ago and later dismissed is probably unwise. Perhaps I'm too optimistic, but I don't see any additional Stark deaths except for Jon Snow. In my opinion, the younger Starks will be the ones to survive and rebuild.

8
glorilol95•

Yes the outline different and GRRM obviously made some changes but i dont those are as drastic noir should be so easily ignored

-4
CaveLupum•

In her very first chapter three times she complained about minor issues that life wasn't fair. To the third, Jon replied "Nothing is fair." Her story (and his) is dark all right; since the Darry incident she's been suffering 'repercussions' for nothing. She's found no place she desperately sought and joined no one she longed to be with. And since GRRM has really piled it on, it's very likely he's going to reverse that karma. Meanwhile, she's in the darkest point of her classic Hero's Journey...so she will climb out. At some point, she will find some fairness. I think her fortunes will turn for the better by mid-TWoW. I don't know either. Only Lord George does.

6

Tyrion is my guess for the most major character that might die in the books. Considering how much his fundamental personality changed in the show, I suspect pretty much nothing about Show Tyrion is anything to go off of.

4
GMantisOP•

Of course more than one of these might die, but Reddit doesn't allow multiple choice polls. So consider this poll as being for the character most likely to die.

3
reineedshelp•

Jon already did

3
GMantisOP•

Jon already did

Yes, but he certainly will be resurrected. The question is whether he would have a final death within the books.

2
reineedshelp•

No idea. I reckon Hizdahr is toast tho, and Daario lives forever

2
balourder•

I feel like the important word here is 'until.'

Characters who died at or near the end in the show were Cersei, Jaime, Theon, Jorah, Viserion and Rhaegal, Missandei, Melisandre, Varys, and the Hound.

In the books, I really only expect the Hound and Missandei to survive Winds.

1
[deleted]•

way to kill the suspense

1
sangvine•

I think Tyrion, maayyyybe Arya. I think Jon also stands a decent chance of popping his clogs in an act of sacrifice or something.

1

All of them as the books will most probably never be published

-4