Changing the suburbs violates the Geneva Convention on cultural genocide: How YouTubers use “history” to promote car centric development

Posted Jul 10, 2022, 2:16 PM UTC

8726
rileyoneill•

There is a very weird mentality in the US concerning history. I have been trying to sort of articulate an explanation and I do not think I get it right. But people more or less treat history as what started after 1945. The cultural things that happened from like the mid 1940s to mid 1960s people seem to have the attitude that is the way it has always been. The Baby Boomers were born during this era, and this era was a fairly high era in the US. Anything that happened before that era was seen as ancient history and didn't go much further than something like, my grandparents grew up in the depression or someone is really into the roaring 20s or maybe WW1 or Civil War.

When COVID broke out, I learned that a lot of Americans never heard of the 1918 Flu. Pretty much no one who had any memory of it was still alive. But even my grandmother who was born in the mid 30s was unfamiliar with it. I was born in 1984, I am certain that my knowledge is faulty for things in the 1960s, but I am fairly familiar with big events from the era.

This culture affected a lot of things. In the 1950s the phrase "In God We Trust" was added to money and "Under God" was added to the pledge of allegiance. To people who grew up with these things, their mentality was that they have always been there and are tradition, almost as if Thomas Jefferson himself personally came up with the idea.

The 1940s-1960s was like this total cultural do-over and the practices established during that era were seen as the new tradition. Car dependency was invented in this era, and people treat it like it was somehow something that we have always had. Like the types of neighborhoods that existed in the 1950s also existed in the 1920s (they didn't).

We are at an interesting point in history where the last generation to grow up remembering an era of non-drivers have died off. My grandpa was born in 1924. He definitely grew up where cars were a thing, cars existed, he saw them, but his household didn't have one until he was a grown man. He grew up in the disruption era, but it was still normal for the majority of Americans to both not own a car or know how to drive. His generation is almost entirely gone. The old people today all grew up where car ownership was the norm.

This idea that we now live in a world where car dependency is an ethnic identity and actively offering alternatives is seen as Genocide is asinine.

40
Hyaldjeisjaba•

I agree that a big portion of the problem is that almost everyone from before 1940 is dead, so almost everything you hear about stuff from before 1940 is hearsay or archival.

5
boilerpl8•

Wait, so postwar suburbia is old enough to be treated as "a significant piece of history" but the human rights the supreme court is stripping aren't?

Please get me out of the worst timeline.

22
Ketaskooter•

Unrelated but Oregon law allows as little as 50 years old can be designated historic. A rediculous low threshold for age. Oregon has gone somewhat coocoo regarding historic as I’ve seen uninteresting bridges and structures that aren’t habitable have preservationists try to save.

8
rileyoneill•

I don't think time should be how we gauge historic importance. There are things that are less than 50 years old which belong in museums as historic items (such as the Space Shuttle) but there is also stuff that is 100 years old that has no historical relevance.

There are buildings in my city where people want to preserve them even though they have been abandoned for many years. Hell, there was one building which I have no recollection of being occupied, it was a prime downtown location and I want to say the last time there was a major tenant was the the 1970s. It was redeveloped into a modern mixed use building (and actually a really great job!) but people were fighting it, wanting to preserve it as a historical building, restore it, and make it a museum, about the building. Like people would come to this museum, to learn about the building, when it was just like a retail store from the 1920s to the 1960s and then spent decades decaying. And it was in a really, really good spot for high density living.

Some people are trying to preserve a historic gas station in Downtown. I honestly have zero recollection of it being a working gas station in my lifetime. I will go out on a limb and say its probably been doing nothing of interest for the last 60 years, and is a place thats a good spot for mixed use high density. Its downtown, in a major city. But people want to preserve it. Its probably one of the few examples of a gas station from the 1950s or maybe even the 1920s. Yeah, thats great, if someone wants to pay to put the building on a truck and relocate it, they should do that, but its otherwise meaningless int he modern context and using up really good land.

Cities are supposed to be ever changing places, many places did have something of historical importance go on there and should be preserved, but I don't think we should try to lock a city in to the past.

9
NerdyLumberjack04•

A rediculous [sic] low threshold for age.

Not really. New York City's Penn Station was 53 years old when it was demolished.

3
Ketaskooter•

Something can be iconic without being historic. Iconic architecture should be protected more than simply old.

5

Those things have literally nothing to do with each other.

1
boilerpl8•

And yet, it's hard to not make the comparison, when we're told that constitutional amendments passed in the 1860s aren't old enough to be considered "entrenched". Like I said, this stupid cesspool or hypocrisy is the worst timeline, and I want out.

1

What are you talking about? The 14th amendment does not justify roe v Wade or planned parenthood v Casey. The entire legal commune it has always known that roe v Wade was an extremely dubious legal decision at best.

If Democrats want roe v Wade nationwide then they should enshrine into law. Which would be easy for them since Republicans haven’t had senate supermajority in 100 years and the democrats have the president, senate and house supermajority multiple times. Even with just a majority they should have been able to get it passed but ironically enough one of the main opponents of enshrining roe into law was….JOE BIDEN lmao cope

Also the overlap between pro life and pro suburbia might not be as big as you may think.

0
boilerpl8•

Which would be easy for them since Republicans haven’t had senate supermajority in 100 years

I don't think you understand at all how the Senate works. You don't just need to be not in the super minority to another party's supermajority, you don't just need to have a majority, you need to either have a supermajority (Democrats haven't in a long time), or a majority willing to abolish the filibuster (hasn't happened yet).

Yeah, I'm aware Biden has a pretty anti-choice history (including reportedly planning on nominating an anti-choice judge the day SCOTUS announced the Dobbs decision). Not sure why that merits a "lol cope" though...

Also the overlap between pro life and pro suburbia might not be as big as you may think

Given that anti-choice makes up only about 35% of the country, the overlap between that a pro-suburbia is limited to that percentage.

3
saxmanb767•

I didn’t realize everyone wanted the exact same thing, that is to live in a SFH out in the suburbs. Curious to see Alan Fisher rebuttal, if he does one. Haha.

21
davidty2006•

Oh jeez i didn't expect for a 50 paragraph article....

12
KitarnOP•

"Oh no, an in-depth look into a topic that's extremely relevant to this sub."

7
davidty2006•

I see how it's relevant.

but jeez i wasn't expecting my eyes to be filled with text....

13
lukeyman87•

yeah r/badhistory is like that

If there was an award for thoroughness and pedantry, they'd win it.

2
itsfairadvantage•

I mean...scoreboard.

1
BandarKianzad•

PragerU is literally fascist propaganda that denies reality and gaslights its viewers.

1
mrcustardo•

How many paragraphs do you need to conclude that right wing media is biased in favor the the car?

-1
KitarnOP•

Sounds like you're missing the point. Knowing how exactly these people twist information to support their arguments is essential for counter arguments. You're not going to convince anyone by just complaining about their bias.

2
[deleted]•

I'm not reading that. Just the first sentence reeks of carbrainitis.

-6
saxmanb767•

If you bothered to read it, it’s a debunking of carbrains. Take a look.

10
KitarnOP•

Couldn't be any further from the truth to be honest. It points out the various ways in which car centric YouTubers spin the history of American suburbia to support their 'carbrainitis'.

8
SomeNumbers98•

Did you read it yet

1
[deleted]•

No, and my mind is all over the place right now.

1
SomeNumbers98•

Darn it

1