When it's Jessica Yaniv vs Rebel Media, who we root for?
bccourts.ca/jdb-txt/sc/22/11/2022BCSC1160.htmPosted Jul 14, 2022, 1:01 AM UTC · locked
Posted Jul 14, 2022, 1:01 AM UTC · locked
Yaniv sues Rebel Media for defamation, Rebel applies succesfully to dismiss the case as strategic litigation against public participation. Both sides look like total trash.
I'm fairly certain everyone involved looked like trash already.
[in thick Japanese accent]
Let them fight.
That's a well written decision, they both suck for different reasons. Rebel had good corporate lawyers, Simpson (Yaniv) was a self-rep. The judge concludes that even though Rebel won at Doing Litigation, they nevertheless were dicks.
[90] In assessing the value of the impugned expression at issue in this case, I accept that at least part of the motivation behind Rebel News’ reporting was to warn the public about what the reporters believed to be the threat that Ms. Simpson’s conduct poses to society. Rebel News says that it strives to present an alternative point of view. Many will find the views that it expresses, here and elsewhere, to be highly offensive. It is, however, precisely in such cases that the law’s commitment to protecting freedom of expression will be most sorely tested.
[91] Nevertheless, the expression in issue here was deeply problematic in various ways, both in terms of its quality and the apparent motivation behind it.
[92] First, it was, by any measure, heavily laden with vitriol and gratuitous insults. Although I have accepted that Rebel News has a viable defence of “fair comment”, on the basis that the views expressed were ones that could honestly be held on the facts presented, it does not follow that the underlying inferences were always reasonably drawn. Of particular concern in that regard is the fact that much of the name-calling directed at Ms. Simpson echoed, and tended to reinforce, pernicious stereotypes about transgender people generally.
[93] Further, the reporters’ conduct in confronting Ms. Simpson at her home or hotel and asking the same inflammatory questions over and over again, appears to have been intended primarily to provoke a scene and so provide entertainment at Ms. Simpson’s expense, rather than to elicit information to enrich the public discourse.
[94] Had Ms. Simpson been able to show real damage to her reputation flowing from the impugned reporting, the dubious quality of the expression in issue here could easily have tipped the scales in favour of allowing the action to proceed.
[...]
[98] [...] this is not a case in which a well-funded plaintiff has brought disproportionate resources to bear against an impecunious defendant. If anything, the imbalance in this case tilts in the opposite direction.
[99] In addition, although I have found that Ms. Simpson has failed to meet the burden upon her under s. 4(2)(a) of the PPPA, it does not follow, given my earlier observations, that she had nothing to complain about in how she was treated.
[100] In summary, I have concluded that an award of full indemnity costs would not be appropriate in the unusual circumstances of this case. Instead, my order will be that the parties are to bear their own costs.
[deleted]
You root for them to bankrupt each other in the process.
##Please read this message in its entirety.
Your content has been removed because it violates rule 2 of this subreddit, Inclusivity. If you have questions about why this was removed, please read our rules and FAQ in full before reaching out to the team in modmail.
Do not repost any version of this without explicit permission from a moderator in modmail.
[deleted]
[deleted]
Yea. My bad.
Everyone involved here sucks, so this is an acceptable decision.
Rebel News is your alt right news source if you feel like your fire is burning out and you need to rekindle your hatred of someone or ideology.
News source is generous.
Well, you know, it's an alternative to news.