is it even possible? has anyone ever seen or produced a photo realistic image of a shingle style building that doesn't look like an acrylic painting??
Posted Jul 16, 2022, 7:20 PM UTC
Posted Jul 16, 2022, 7:20 PM UTC
It's definitely possible. Most of the roofs (probably 90%) you're talking about are made by applying a texture with displacement to a flat plane. That works great for some things, but if you are going for realism your best bet would be to model the individual tiles as geomerty. Then use an array mod or a plugin like railclone to place them. It's a lot more work than just applying a texture ( thats why most people (myself included) don't do it and have crappy looking shingles)
Edit: Just remembered, I actually posted a house here on Reddit featuring some pretty terrible looking shingles. Made me laugh when I realized. You can check it out here
ugh they are really bad. I hated them when I first made them and I hate them now just looking at them. But I was in a time crunch, someday I’ll go back and fix them…
100% displacement maps OP or geometry nodes for railing. It took me ages to get the shingles looking good buy eventually it worked with displacements
Thanks...this image you created and shared is amazing! I would guess no client would be able to find a difference between your render and an actual photo. Very well done...
I know exactly what you are saying about applying a texture rather than modeling each shingle...and I think this is the root of the problem. It's a shame that there isn't a direct and less time consuming solution...ill look into the plug-ins you mentioned...
With shingles...for my projects it compounds because often the roof and the walls are red cedar shakes or shingles...I'd still rather present something that is hand sketch & marker quality, or a model that is b& w with shadows applied, over a poor photo real viz attempt.
Thanks! I feel pretty good about that one ( other than those goddamn shingles lol)
I think you should definitely check out railclone especially if this is something you have to do often. I use the free version,but I haven’t needed it enough to actually drill down into all the features.
Here’s a YouTube tutorial that shows what it can do
Most people on this sub are hobbyist that can only do box modern houses and don’t actually do this for a living. First off, keep in mind photorealism is not always the best approach and homes using these types of roofs are a possible example. Photorealism partially involves imperfections, dirt, grime, lens defects, the breaking up of repeated patterns that our minds eyes perceives. These types of houses are usually presented as exteriors in a pristine fashion for marketing purposes and Photorealism is possibly detrimental to the overall intent of the image. Keep that in mind. On that note doing good shingle roofs are somewhat time consuming but are essential for contemporary homes in parts of the US. They should never be textures with displacement as others have said as it is not accurate and is unacceptable for professional work. It should be actual geometry. You should either use a plug-in like Railclone or atiles or do it the old fashioned way that hasn’t changed in years. I would explain it but it’s complicated. The basic idea is you would accurately model one tile then place rows of tile instances on the pitch and turn it into a single piece of geometry. Then go to town with your slice plane and delete on your dormers and such. Repeat this for every roof plane. It goes slow at first but once you do it enough you can do a complete roof in no time. Just make sure you have good quality shaders and textures with variations for a realistic look and that will get you to the dance.
Thanks of the detailed reply!...I get what you mean about building the shingles and actually placing them on the model...I've thought about this but time is always an issue for a sole practitioner architect.
I got into sketchup at first for checking my 2d geometry. I know my process is slow, but I visualize, sketch. design in 2d cad and then build my model. I often do this to verify the framing geometry first, and as a presentation medium second.
The idea of a program like lumion is very appealing... to add a feel of realism to a model I already have on hand is a great thing. I suppose my problem, which is one every architect should have, is I always want it better..
ill give the individual shingling a try to see how it turns out...
We tend to overthink it sometimes. It seems like a lot of objects but it’s really only one tile instanced and one material with randomness. The hardest part is placing the first column/row on the roof spline.
Your way of working is still fairly common for many architects especially smaller offices. A lot of jobs I received in the past were just cad drawings and the first task was to get inside the architects head and clean up the drawings. Lumion is actually great for a sole practitioner such as yourself because it’s so easy and fast for the results you achieve. It brings visualization back into the hands of actual architect where it belongs.
The book 3ds Max Design Visualization for Intermediate users has a whole chapter on roofs. That’s mostly where I learned to model a roof. It’s an old book but nothing has really changed since it was published. The roof chapter used to be free on line somewhere but I can’t find it.
I like lumion quite a bit, when it works for me. I had some tech issues but bought new machines and it seems that did the trick...
Thanks again about the info, i'm in an info vacuum being solo and any ideas from the outside is very useful. ..ill look for that book!
Try Enscape!! It far more better than Lumion.!
Im an architect in the US who has been working on rendering skills for years. I work on smaller buildings, mostly higher end homes and office buildings. Many clients in my area want shingle style or "traditional" northeastern American buildings. I have tried myself to produce viz drawings for these types of buildings and can't get close to satisfactory results or near photo realistic... ( admittedly I'm no viz expert. I use sketchup and lumion, they are both fairly easy to learn) the drawings I produce do the job for clients and planning board submissions, but they just aren't where I want them to be.
On this note, I have tried to find other images for these building types and haven't found any that are all that spectacular. I've had the same result hiring out to viz consultants...this is why I stick with doing them in house...I've seen others that have used vray, and i have browsed many rendering engine sites to see what's out there, but I haven't seen anything too inspiring...
Has anyone seen great images of shingle style? Is it possible? Is photo real only attainable for modern buildings?...any help or information on well done shingle style building renders is appreciated...
Thank you!...I will check it out. You definitely should be proud of that render...it's very, very good!
Could you provide some example images of buildings? Im not sure of what exact qualities that Definition would include.
That being said, I don't see why it wouldn't but likely harder then more modern architecture.
To get deeper into it images AND a description of what you don't like about them and optionally pictures (CG or Photo) that you'd deem good would really help.
I'm hesitant to post images. I don't intend to rip apart someone's work ( including my own) or a companies software product.
I also haven't found many if any, all shingle clad homes, that were rendered well. The designs may be fantastic but the render quality of the textures applied just never seem to work. I'm hoping that anyone out there has found a way or has better information that could help...
I agree modern buildings, because of their materials, seem to lend themselves to being rendered much better...