Party Wall Survey gone wrong, with surveyor uncommunicative

Housing

Hi Reddit, I need some help with my party wall process please:

My neighbour has completed an extension to increase the height of his property. We both instructed party wall surveyors, who completed these.

Now that the building work has finished, it is clear that there are 1) a few bits of minor damage, 2) the neighbour has placed his soil pipe on our party wall, rather than on his side per the plans, 3) added a render which overhangs the original party wall, overhanging my property (only by 5mm, but the render does not match the finish below)

My surveyor has been very uncommunicative and is telling me the party wall act does not cover points 2 or 3 above. He says I would need a solicitor to write to the neighbour as trespass is not covered under the party wall act. Is this correct?

I understand I need get a party wall award drawn up by a surveyor, at least for the damage. Could I use a new surveyor to draw up this initial award (because the original one has been very unhelpful?? Or am I best to stick to the unhelpful but original one? And should we include the ‘trespass’ in the award?

Thanks in advance

Edit: I am in England

Posted Jul 20, 2022, 8:16 AM UTC · edited

44
cbzoiav•

Does your home insurance come with legal cover?

If so the first thing is I'd do is contact them. If not look for a solicitor who will offer a free initial consult. If work hasn't been completed to the plans you can also contact the councils planning team.

This sounds like any work to rectify will be at a high cost to the neighbour so you probably want to go straight to a solicitor.

3

Hi OP, I've spend a good deal of today reading through the records of past diciplinary action RICS has taken against members to inform my complaint against my surveyor. Appreciate that might not be the course of action you need or want at this point as your circumstances are different.

Nevertheless, I've had quite the find today - have a look through these https://www.rics.org/de/upholding-professional-standards/regulation/how-we-regulate/disciplinary-process/panel-hearings/disciplinary-hearings/?search=&contentTypes=&topics=&locations=&sort=3&page=3#results-top

Most will relate to something completely different, but you're bound to find a few that relate to surveyors not responding, this will actually allow you to get a good idea of how to present your case to RICS if you want to go down that route.

3

NAL, NAPWS (not a party wall surveyor). I am very sorry to read this and can't offer much advice, but a lot of sympathy. I'm also an adjoining owner and my house was also damaged by my neighbour's works, and my surveyor has also gone incommunicado as soon as problems arose.

From what I've been forced to research around this, I believe you'll need to identify what's true - do the works really not fall under the award (my surveyor told me that one aspect I was unhappy about wasn't covered by the award, but upon re-reading it, it very much was), then you cannot actually change surveyors unfortunately, but you can also contact your neighbour's surveyor who may have higher professional standards... make sure you put everything in writing and are very clear. From bitter experience: do not trust the integrity of the surveyors - make notes after every call and share them with them, record every in-person interaction. They are not above lying about what they discussed or explained to you.

Or, of course the third surveyor (unusual and doesn't tend to get involved directly, but helped kick my surveyor into action at least on one very serious occasion)... or are they not covered by the award, then this would suggest that your neighbour has undertaken works that fall under the Party Wall Act, but for which no award/notice exists? I believe it's going to be the first scenario, deviation from the plans surely must fall under the award. Anyway, if the second scenario applies, then it's probably best to go to a solicitor rather than to a party wall surveyor.

On a more general note, I must say that my experience with the party wall award has been that it leaves adjoining owners exposed to careless and lazy surveyors who can make legally binding decrees basically just on what they reckon. My surveyor pair certainly hasn't shared any costings or reasoning for the low compensation amount I was awarded, hasn't replied to e-mails or perfectly sensible questions (not even in cases where I was just asking for clarification or checking my understanding was correct). I do believe that my neighbour's surveyor is interested in keeping his appointing owner's (a large organisation for whom he is surveyor on a massive project) costs down, and my surveyor has simply gone along with it. I guess you're still in a better position than having only one surveyor, but in my case I wonder if it was worth all the hassle to essentially still end up out of pocket as a result of works that are of zero benefit to me.

2
AutoModeratorMOD•

###Welcome to r/LegalAdviceUK

To Posters (it is important you read this section)

To Readers and Commenters

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1