r/VaushV•
cloudhid

Christian Anarchism

The debate with the Christian anarchist was kinda interesting, but also very frustrating.

The caller is on the right track regarding some Hegel 101, 'freedom ethics', and the compatibility of Christianity with anarchism or socialism, but he wasn't able to properly defend these ideas when challenged. It was disappointing to have someone try to refute historical materialism so weakly and then hear Vaush just argue like there's no dialectic.

The way the caller talked about God and scripture showed that he hasn't actually let go of a more conventional theology in favor of the pantheism he alludes to. Pantheists in the tradition of the mystic Christians or even someone like Spinoza have no real allegiance to particular texts, except insofar as they're practically helpful in describing an 'inner empiricism' or lead to an actual experience of god-consciousness or what the Buddhists would call satori. They'd throw out 90% of the King James, and would elevate a number of apocryphal texts like the Gospel of Thomas.

For his part, Vaush was way outside of his wheelhouse. He doesn't seem to appreciate the complexity of the millennia-long history of Christianity. He apparently hasn't even heard of Leo Tolstoy or the naturalism of Spinoza. He ignores the spiritual influences of radical political figures like MLK, and the actual philosophical and political teachings of Jesus.

It was especially ridiculous to hear the inverse of the No True Scotsman fallacy: because most self-described Christians don't follow or care about the teachings of Jesus, then the teachings of Jesus are irrelevant. You could say the exact same thing about self-described Marxists and Marx.

My take is that reclaiming the pantheistic and radically egalitarian teachings of Jesus is necessary precisely because religious people are irrational and captured by world-historical ideologies. Spirituality has the capacity to change a person or a community's relation to material reality, and we have no choice but to leverage that capacity in a world filled with billions of religious people.

Posted Jul 24, 2022, 6:14 PM UTC

2730
Loading comments…