I'll be the bad guy... Anyone else happy to see Breza on the bench and Pantemis getting starts?

Being honest with myself for a minute... With the defensive showing from the team in the later part of the game last night in D.C., and the amount of quality opportunities they had, we would have lost the game with Breza in net. No doubt in my mind.

It's shocking how long it took Nancy to see what even soccer neophytes could : Sebastian Breza looks lost in net. His positioning and game sense are dreadful, and only made up by his reflexes half of the time - the other half, it's like he's a deer in headlights.

Ever since the damn Atlanta game in April, I've had my doubts - but I told myself that I should be patient with the kid (even though he's 24, so we're getting close to the WYSIWYG territory), he's just getting warmed up. Getting used to MLS play. Then came the RSL and SKC games, and boy oh boy, did he cost us a minimum of 4 points there, arguably 6. His lack of composure was evident. It was time for a change.

James Pantemis is only one year older than Breza, he's the local kid, and now he has a chip on his shoulder. Some of his saves last night were phenomenal. His boxing of incoming crosses were clinical, redirecting all of them onto the defense. The only time he was beat was on a set piece where Birnbaum sneaked through 3 players, not much to do for him on that one. However, THAT'S what I want in a goalie. A guy who will give you a chance to win, from minute one to minute ninety. Hopefully that continues on, because solid goaltending is the only way we can be in the conversation for the top of the conference in late September.

Thank you for coming to my TED talk, now let's look forward to NYCFC and closing the gap to 2nd place in the East next week.

Posted Jul 24, 2022, 11:31 PM UTC

267

I was one of the one saying that Pantemis looks like he had a bad attitude last year, often complaining at the other players, I think his success at the beginning of last year got him to the head. Breza was connecting a lot more better with the defence at that moment so I was happy to see him start the year.

But honestly at the moment same as you I had doubts about him and happy to see Pantemis playing! He been playing solid past games and you can tell he’s been told about his attitude because am not seeing this at the moment. His definitely superior than Breza in a few aspect of the game. It’s was up to Breza to keep his spot and he lost it! now it’s up to Pantemis to keep the spot now! If he learned from last year communication issues I believe we are in business with him in the net! Totally happy to see him taking advantage of his second chance!

9
Electronic-Elk8917•

Agree with your evaluation. To me Breza was a needed calming force last year, but really struggled to make crucial saves this year. Panthemis was brilliant the last couple of games.

2
Pools9•

Pantemis got pumped for 4 goals against Toronto a month ago… neither of them are too convincing but breza wasn’t worse than pantemis. Pantemis has made good saves these last two games though so if he can keep it going I’ll take it

8
hetobuhaypaStade Saputo Fox•

I admittedly haven't watched enough matches to compare Brez and Pantemis (I mainly listen on the radio) but I watched last night and Pantemis was impressive. Definitely the MVP of the match (respect is due to Quioto amd Birnbaum but Pantemis made many vital saves). If Pantemis is usually providing a performance like that behind the team's shoddy defense, then Pantemis would be a starter on most MLS rosters.

1
Pizza_Salesman•

By the stats, Breza has allowed 10(!!) more goals than his expected goals against. That's completely dreadful and far worse than any keeper in the league. It's insane he even has as long of a run as he did, and maybe even crazier that we haven't acquired another keeper if we saw Pantemis as backup quality

1
simplestpanda•

The goal Breza gave up to Crew tonight...

I can't even.

Make a -tiny- effort and that's a save.

1
MarcoSamsonOPBernier•

Honestly, last night was indicative of what Breza can bring - he was excellent on a couple of big reflex stops, especially on Cucho. But when it comes to him reading the game and anticipating shots... Again, "deer in headlights" is the best way to describe it.

I'm happy because he kept us in it and we got the 3 points in the end (Joel Waterman, if you read this, I could kiss you), but before the last 15 minutes, I was about to notch it as more lost points thanks to Breza. Thankfully the guys rallied hard in the 2nd half.

2