r/sailing•
phizbot

Help me decide between a P34 and a C34

1984 Pearson 34 or a 1987 Catalina 34 MK1 tall rig.

Cat has unknown engine hours but “runs great”. Better tankage. Better space. Would likely upgrade the rudder. About $8k more than the Pearson. $35k range.

Pearson was refit 2012. Encapsulated keel. 600 engine hours. Better rudder and from what i can gather better sailing characteristics but they are close. No chart plotter.

Both in pretty good shape. I have about $20k budget reserved just for upgrading.

Sailing will be San Juans, Columbia river, and the PNW coast. 1-2 weeks and weekends.

Any thoughts would be appreciated!!!

Posted Jul 27, 2022, 5:16 PM UTC

25
climenuts•

Pearson 34 is a far better sailing boat. For primarily weekend cruising with the annual 1-2 week trip it in the PNW it would be my choice. We like to leave the apartment at home, don't mind doing dishes with saltwater on long trips to conserve water, care a lot about sailing performance, and don't mind living with things underfoot on our 3 week trips.

The Catalina is a great boat and still sails well but it has compromised sailing performance for the interior comforts which are fantastic. Big fridge, tonnes of tankage, two cabins, etc. If you have kids, do much longer trips frequently, etc. It is a good choice.

Check the propane locker situation to make sure it's been brought up to ABYC standards - many of them have improperly vented lockers that were retrofitted which an insurance survey will require fixing. Lots of forum posts on this topic.

7
florida-castaways•

As much as I love catalina I would personally go with the Pearson here purely on the fact that you know the last time it was refit and how many hours are on the engine, diesels are a pita to do maintenance on and cost a shit ton. If you don’t know how many hours are on the engine then I wouldn’t risk it. On the other hand catalina makes a great cruising boat that has a beam wider then most boats. Personally I would go with the Pearson but both are great boats

5
dothebender1101•

Pearson all day. Never been all that impressed with Catalina build quality.

2
public1177•

Bill Shaw made some incredible boats.

2
dave_pdxPrecision 18•

Bonus points for the centerboard version IMO. You don’t really want deep draft in this area.

1