r/StJohnsNL•
hamcake

Simple electrical work in my house — is a permit needed?

I'm looking to do some basic electrical work in my house: swapping out switches, receptacles, and light fixtures. I know that some cities allow these types of things to be performed by the homeowner, but I haven't been able to find any kind of bylaw for St. John's that allows this. All I've been able to read is that any electrical work needs to be done by an electrical contractor.

Can I do my own work? Do I need a permit?

Posted Jul 28, 2022, 3:59 PM UTC

519
c79s•

I checked the bylaw, technically you need a permit for anything more than changing a lightbulb which is absurd considering how expensive they are and they can only be pulled by a registered journeyman.

4
JLearie•

No idea of the legalities of this, but I’ve done all of those things in my house in St. John’s without issue. But of course no one would know unless reported or there’s some kind of incident.

3
FuzzyPossession2•

Not if you’re just swapping out some fixtures, plugs and switches.

If you are adding or removing plugs/switches/fixtures you are supposed to get a permit. I’d imagine the permit office would almost turn you away if you showed up for a permit to add or remove 2-3 plugs and a light or two, the inspectors are busy enough and would probably be annoyed by having to write up a file and inspect the addition of a couple of plugs.

Side note, please only do the swaps if you are absolutely sure with what you are doing. Do not do this kind of work if the internet is your reference.

Improper installation could lead to a fire, and your insurance will investigate the cause. If it’s found that the installer was done by somebody that is not certified to do electrical work they will indeed decline coverage and you’ll end up costing yourself a whole heck of a lot more money than you saved by not hiring an electrician.

3
hamcakeOP•

Thanks for the input! Is this mainly your opinion, or what are you basing this on? This all sounds reasonable in my mind, but I'm asking because I haven't found anything documented...

3
FuzzyPossession2•

just call In and ask to confirm. No need to identify your location and who you are.

Turn off caller Id on your phone if you don’t want to poke the bear.

Something something better to ask for forgiveness than permission sometimes.

4
hamcakeOP•

OK thanks, yeah I may do that. At least if I hear the same kind of thing from the horse's mouth, then that gives me some ammo if there's a problem.

Definitely getting the sense that people don't normally get permits for these kinds of things.

1
c79s•

I'm pretty sure that insurance thing is a myth, I've never heard of someone denied coverage on that basis and would be interested if anyone has.

Also you can absolutely learn how to swap outlets and switches from the internet safely if you are comfortable with it.

2
FuzzyPossession2•

I can assure you, it is not a myth. I have seen coverage denied due to negligence and I’ve seen coverage revoked after an investigation.

Insurance companies are in and out of the courts frequently.

Anybody can basically learn anything from the internet. But I’m sure not interested in having someone injure themselves because they took my advice to follow the advice of someone online. Even if it doesn’t mean I will have to pay out of pocket for anything, I prefer knowing the advice I gave anybody will so less harm than more.

1
c79s•

So you got me to dig up my insurance policy with TD and see the wording haha.

For my policy, under the exclusions the text is:

"Faulty Design, material, or workmanship: We do not insure the cost of correcting faulty workmanship. However, we insure loss or damage caused directly to property by an insured peril resulting resulting from such faulty design, material, or workmanship"

It also mentions nothing absolutely nothing about inspections or municipal issued permits. So in my case if I wired a circuit using a coat hanger as a conductor and my house burned down they would still cover the house as it's insured and fire loss is a covered peril, however if my whole house was discovered to be wired with coat hangers they just won't pay to fix the out of code problems.

There are exclusions for stuff like if you are operating a drug lab or intentional arson.

I guess the take away here is to read your own specific policy. But remember, many typical insurance claims result from people doing dumb stuff, messing up your wiring isn't really different than deep frying a turkey on your deck while drunk.

2
FuzzyPossession2•

Also, as your insurance states they will not update the electrical if it is found to be wired improperly, a couple years ago, there was a home that the kitchen had caught fire resulting in some smoke damage and a burned countertop.

The clients insurance had a clause that the insurance would update any electrical/hvac/plumbing if it was outdated and not up to current standards.

Once the work had started in the kitchen, it was found the plumbing had been done with faulty copper piping that made its rounds on the island in the early 90s. The insurance company agreed that they would be replacing all the plumbing throughout the house.

Once the plumbing started it was then found that the hvac system wasn’t installed properly, so then that got the go ahead to get completely re done at the insurance companies expense.

When the system was spec’d for the home, it would need to have proper vapour barrier for it to work. So we then had to open up the exterior walls.

There was no vapour barrier installed on the home as it wasn’t standard at the time of building. The insurance company then had to remove the inside of all the exterior walls, re insulate vapour barrier, drywall the whole 9 yards.

At that point the company decided it was decided to remove every single piece of drywall and flooring in the house to complete all the work.

The owners basically hit the lottery with their type of coverage resulting in a top to bottom, top tier quality full on renovation of everything in their home for only the initial deductible of a couple thousand dollars from the kitchen fire!

The only thing that wasn’t done on the house was the siding and windows.

1
FuzzyPossession2•

​A peril is a chance event that is unexpected and accidental.

Wiring your home with coat hangers that lead to a fire would not be covered. Would You expect the wiring to function as it should when it’s been improperly installed or used the wrong materials?

Completely different situation when you compare improper wiring done with coat hangers to deep frying turkeys hahah

0
NerdMachine•

That is BS about insurance. Every house in downtown St. John's probably has something fucky with it's electrical. The whole point of insurance is to protect people from unexpected things like that.

1
FuzzyPossession2•

Yeah no shit genius. There’s a chance of being denied your claim if you do the work or an unlicensed electrician does it.

If you buy the home as is, and it already has shoddy work, insurance will cover the damage...

0
Luddites_Unite•

Electrician here. You are allowed to change fixtures, plugs, etc without an electrical permit in st. John's. You need a permit if you are altering the existing wiring, adding plugs etc.

As for who swaps fixtures or receptacles for you, that's really a matter of personal comfort. Most lights will have pretty detailed wiring diagrams with them.

2
hamcakeOP•

Thanks! This is what I'm hoping... Have you seen anything in writing that says this? All I'm able to find is the bylaw which seems to say I need a permit for any electrical work, and I can't just do it myself: https://www.stjohns.ca/ByLaws.nsf/nwByLawNum/1321

1
Luddites_Unite•

I have not. There isn't really anything for them to see if all you do is swap plugs or light fixtures. They aren't tracing circuits or checking loads. No wiring has been changed so they aren't checking if lights and plugs are separate circuits.

The next time I have an inspection I will ask the inspector and get back to you for sure but I can tell you that in 11 years of electrical I have never seen a permit get pulled to swap devices inside or outside the city.

2
handy987•

The reason you get a permit , because you get an indepentant profesional to check the work. It is for your safety.

1