ClintSlunt•

So the "magnolia-ification" of the TOH brand?

  • great room with only one place to put the tv.... over the fireplace? See you over at r/tvtoohigh

  • I hear you like subway tile and shiplap!

  • How about a barn door on a bathroom so you can still hear and smell toilet use from the adjacent room?

  • Huge-ass windows for lots of light, hard to clean, and provide heat loss in a Denver winter?

Aw golly here's a live-laugh-love word art we'll give you at closing!

9
Esher127•

The first episode is up today and I skipped through it and found that it didn't really hold my interest. It seems like a cookie-cutter HGTV show where they put a ton of effort into trying to create an emotional connection with the people and the house is just a backdrop. Maybe that's not fair as I didn't watch the whole thing, but it doesn't feel like This Old House at all... but then again This Old House is starting to not feel like This Old House.

7
AarunFastOP•

I'm a little confused as to how TOH is involved. It sounds like this is a Roku show that uses a name that comes from a segment in TOH, but also TOH is owned by Roku. Feels like they are trying to trick me into watching an HGTV show by implying its a TOH show.

2
Esher127•

"Idea House" has been a thing on the website and in the magazine for years. The show doesn't really say TOH anywhere when you're watching it aside from the intro from Kevin, so if I didn't know going in I don't think I would make the connection. What's bad is that I don't hate some of the HGTV shows and I might not hate this, but the idea of Roku diluting the TOH brand just makes me insta-hate it.

2
keithplacer•

If you click on the link in the OP's post you will see that it is clearly a TOH production. They aren't trying to trick anyone in that they state "The teams behind This Old House and Ask This Old House deliver an-all new 11-part weekly series". The VP in charge of TOH at Roku is quoted with the usual statements about how incredible it will be. Uh, probably not.

Given the steep decline in TOH/Ask TOH in recent times I am not going to bother with this. There are enough bad home reno/construction/flipping shows already on HGTV and the truly awful Magnolia Network already and we really don't need more. TOH needs to fix their foundational shows before getting into stuff like this IMO.

1
AarunFastOP•

Lol I am OP! My question is more about whether Roku is just using the TOH brand to sell a show that doesn't have the same heart and soul of TOH, or if this is something close to TOH. Looks like the former.

0
keithplacer•

More accurately, this is TOH using their brand to produce a show that is not much like TOH at all. More evidence of the ongoing decline, sadly. Just this morning I happened to see a recent ATOH segment with my least favorite TOH performer, Jenn Lagasse, that was full Magnolification - the construction and installation of a shipping container swimming pool in the backyard of a McMansion in a newish cul-de-sac development (purportedly her house) that involved a monster crane to lift it way, way up in the air because of terrain challenges getting it in there any other way. Nothing TOH about that. They seem to have lost the plot.

1
chrisinator9393•

I don't like that chick on the right in the picture. I watched some ToH stuff with her & it was very annoying and not very ToH-ey.

Like others said it feels way too HGTV.

1