r/vegan•
Googelplex

What should a vegan product label mean?

I share in the sentiment that a well-regulated "Vegan" label on product packaging would be great.

And because I've seen a variety of opinions on what is and isn't vegan, I'd like to ask what you think should be allowed in a product marketed as vegan. I know there are a ton of answers, and I'm looking forward to seeing the different takes.

To be more concrete, here's a list of potential disqualifiers in no particular order. Which do you think should or shouldn't be allowed, and why?

  • Sugar processed using bone char
  • Avocados grown using farmed bees
  • Animals without a central nervous system like jellyfish (or animals with similar sentience)
  • Chocolate that isn't fair trade (and similarily low ethical standards in other products)
  • Ingredients from companies that mistreat workers
  • Crops whose production kills insects and rodents
  • Trace amounts of non-vegan ingredients not intentionally added (ie. May Contain)
  • A product from a company that makes non-vegan products
  • Ingredients/products tested on animals
  • Ingredients whose production causes great ecological harm

Posted Jul 31, 2022, 1:43 AM UTC

09
madelinegumbo•

I think it would be a mistake for vegan labels to reflect conditions for human workers or to not allow companies who make non-vegan products to indicate vegan products in their assortment.

(I absolutely think vegans should make decisions about which companies to support based on harm to humans, but they should do this as an ethical issue that is distinct from veganism).

7
datrandomduggy•

I think it should just mean it doesn't contain any animal products

3
GoogelplexOPvegan•

"Any" is pretty strict, so in your books it being processed in the same environment as animal products would disqualify it? That's certainly a stance. I mean strictly speaking there will always be some minute amounts of animal product (like insect parts in cereal, and are the very least some stray atoms), so I'm interested in how much you think is acceptable.

1
datrandomduggy•

I more meant in the same sense that "gluten free" would mean it contains almost no gluten, same thing with vegan

2
eveniwontremember•

If you insisted on vegan production lines, so no allergens cross contamination from the previous product batch, that might be useful but also might prevent useful products being labelled.

Fair trade is a separate label and should be irrelevant partly because other welfare standards may replace it.

Are you really going to exclude mechanically harvested grains because of rodent and insect deaths.

A vegan label is useful when enough products qualify.

2
AutoModeratorMOD•

Thanks for posting to r/Vegan!

Please note: Civil discussion is welcome, trolls and personal abuse are not. Please keep the discussions below respectful and remember the human! Please check out our wiki first!

Interested in going Vegan?

Check out 3 Movies and watch three thought-provoking movies that shed light on uncomfortable realities. 3 Movies also includes other videos, books, challenges and resources for you get started!

Some other resources to help you go vegan:

Visit NutritionFacts.org for health and nutrition support, HappyCow.net to explore nearby vegan-friendly restaurants, and visit VeganBootcamp.org for a free 30 day vegan challenge!

Interested in getting active for the animals?

Join Activist Hub to find and join local vegan groups, add friends, create or share posts, and chat with other activists! You can also use Activist Hub to track your local and online activism in order to see how many people you inspired to watch dominion, take a challenge, or even go vegan!

Some other resources to help you get active:

Last but not least, join our Discord server!

Thank you!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
asdf352343vegan•

Several of these are not about whether a product is vegan - company makes nonvegan products, may contain, companies mistreating humans.

Others are a mess - ingredients that were tested on animals - ever? within a certain time period? It could be reasonable to include this with a time frame attached.

Avocados are far from the only crop grown with farmed bees. And insecticides and insects and rodents dying in production is ubiquitous.

Sugar filtered with bone char I don't think should qualify for having a vegan label.

I think if something contains no (non trace incidental) animal product, does not have ingredients that were purified using animal bits (ex. sugar filtered with bone char), and was not and doesn't have ingredients that were tested on animals in the last 10? years it should qualify as vegan. I also think it would be reasonable to exclude that animal testing qualification and have a secondary label indicating number of years since most recent animal testing.

1
thiscouldbeitall•

In the uk we have products that are labelled “vegan society approved”. This means it’s been confirmed by them as vegan. I believe their standards are on their website.

1