Longer Holsters for AIWB?
Wanted to get some feedback from the community on using longer holsters to prevent gun from “rolling over” the belt line. Ex. G17 holster for carrying a G19
Posted Aug 2, 2022, 2:17 PM UTC
Wanted to get some feedback from the community on using longer holsters to prevent gun from “rolling over” the belt line. Ex. G17 holster for carrying a G19
Posted Aug 2, 2022, 2:17 PM UTC
If you’re going to use a longer holster, you may as well carry a longer gun.
I do it. Keel principle
I use the Tenicor Velo4 holsters for both my Glock G43X and my Sig Sauer P365X and they design their holsters to be a little longer in the body of the holster to combat issues such as this. It's not a lot of material, but it does help to keep the pistol from rolling over as some people have this issue. Myself, I've never had a problem with any of my shorter slide pistols doing this, but I love the Tenicor Velo4 appendix holsters and it seems they know what they're doing with this design.
This is a common practice.
A wedge treats the symptom by making it hurt less
A longer holster makes less leverage, therefore treating the problem.
A stiffer or tighter belt is just fighting the keeling issue rather than solving it
Typically you gotta get to the short muzzled double stack guns (G26, P365, etc.) before it's an issue (the more ammo in the mag and shorter the barrel the worse it can be), but depending on the holster even a Shield 1.0 can do it.
I find the biggest issue is the end of the holster stabbing me in the pelvic bone. Really uncomfortable.
I find a wedge on a subcompact serves the same purpose with less gun poking you in the groin.
A wedge treats the symptom, a longer holster treats the problem.
I think it's subjective to the individual. I've run guns with full length slides. They hurt.
No, it's physics. A longer fulcrum (and lower center of gravity) reduces tip out.
Now not everyone can carry a longer slide (I can't) due to their body shape... but the pain there isn't from tip out, it's from a gun/holster that's too long for their body
I’ve put foam (minicell) wedges on all of my AIWB holsters and it helps tremendously.
For small guns, one size up. For compacts, same size. Depends on the gun, and on the person. This is just what my body type likes.
For me, yes. It helps with tipping and weight distribution. Some weight on the groin and most on the belt 75/25 It also allows me to run my belt a little looser. Glock 42 is in a JMCK "long" with flat pad Glock 48 is standard length with pillow pad Glock 19 is 17 length with large foam wedge
On a shorter gun, it can definitely help. Once a gun is long enough, there’s not any more benefit to sizing up.
Obviously, you could also just use a longer gun with the same size grip if one exists, but that isn’t always an option. Plus, sometimes you have to go with what you already have gun wise.
Next size up no doubt
Check out PHLster’s concealment workshop videos. Keel principle for this questions specifically
I carried my 43x for the first time and noticed it rolling over my belt. Anyone think this is only a legitimate problem on gun bbl’s shorter than 4”? Hoping to hear plenty of opinions on this
Sometimes referred to as keeling. Can be common with shorter barreled pistols as there isn’t as much material under the belt line. A couple things to help would be a proper gun belt, longer holster, or a wedge on the back of the holster
Yes, I had the same problem with a shield plus 3.1 inch barrel. I went with a tenicor certum and they size those up to 4 inch slide size , if u order for 43x it will fit a 48. This has helped immensely, before I couldn’t carry without crazy printing. My 26 rides in a 19 holster. The 17 holster concealed real well but it was kinda long poking at my thigh sometimes
It seems like for guns under 4” (subcompact) it’s worth it to go one size up. I’ve never had my 19x keel over on me
Ya 43x definitely should go in a 48 holster imo
Pretty sure e.g. JM Custom Kydex doesn't even sell a 43x length holster because of this
19 in a 17 might not be necessary though
Use a wedge if it’s that big of a deal. A proper belt and good holster will go a long way in fixing that, though. Most people don’t need a wedge if they have both of those.
A lot of it depends on the gun but using a good belt, sturdy clips and a wedge can definitely help without having to go up to a bigger holster.
I carry a g19 90% of the time in my trex arms sidecar. I can also carry my g34 in the holster and I do when I know I won’t be sitting for a long time. I think sizing up is un necessary if you are buying a holster with a mag holder connected. Even without the mag connector I wouldn’t say it’s necessary. I’m kinda small though so your mileage may very. (5’8” 170lbs)
Depends on the gun. No issue with my g19. Might need to for guns with a short slide
c) it depends on the gun.
The keeling effect is usually only problematic on subcompacts and similarly short-barreled options, but as always, it depends… body type, height, belt, holster hardware, etc etc etc.