PP Moving to 3d Printed Minis Moving Forward

Anyone else feel like that entire section in the MKIV announcement post sounded a whole lot like "We here at Privateer Press can't afford to produce miniatures through traditional casting methods anymore, so we'll be 3d printing everything in-house from now on"?

Because after having read the announcement, that's the feeling that I got. That entire section was full of excuses while also trying to drum up how exciting and innovative 3d printing can be. Actually, a lot of the MkIV announcement reads like that - a bunch of excuses for why a new edition was necessary, and how things will be different and changing from here on out. I especially rolled my eyes at the few digs that Matt Wilson threw in at Games Workshop, where he says "We don't have the kind of resources the publisher of the other game company has to contract marketing firms and PR managers" and "We're a small group of people who are passionate about making great games and miniatures".

If Privateer Press is lacking resources for basic things like advertising and some social media management, they have only themselves to blame; you'd think that a company who's been in the tabletop gaming business for 20+ years would be slightly better managed at this point, but I guess that's not the case.

Posted Aug 2, 2022, 5:54 PM UTC

729
LDukes•

"We here at Privateer Press can't afford to produce miniatures through traditional casting methods anymore

Well, yeah. Do you have any idea how much it costs to develop a single master mold?

so we'll be 3d printing everything in-house from now on"?

And thank Christ for that. They've found a domestic method of production that isn't beholden to overseas interests or proprietary tech.

absolutewin.gif

24
TobTobTobey•

Plus they can print up stuff in europe, asia etc. not everything has to be shipped out from the us

10
link_dead•

Yea, however they will likely order models to be printed at a factory somewhere in Asia using cheap labor, load them into blister packs and pack them on containers.

5
New_Canuck_Smells•

I really wish they said whether or not they're buying their own printers

4
link_dead•

They probably have some cheaper printers (generally speaking in the 10k+ range) to print test and studio models. However to do this at scale requires very expensive machines, large scale post processing, and QA. No way they are investing in that local capacity without some kind of kickstarter associated with MK4.

3
IcyShoes•

I believe they have a fleet of printers for this very purpose. PP are the ones making these models, not a 3D Printer farm.

3
GroupieXL•

Yeah but the Asian shipping is getting really expensive, even GW is affected.

3
CharlesComm•

I never really understood why everyone cared about traditional metal casting anyway? Maybe it used to be important before I really started getting into mini-soldier games (late 2015), but plastic always seemed fine.

3
ErsatzNihilist•

Well, PP themselves made a pretty brash about the HEAVY METAL side of things. And we went through a phase where their 'plastic' wasn't alright at all.

A long phase.

9
Blebbb•

Well, yeah. Do you have any idea how much it costs to develop a single master mold?

Molds for metal casting aren't that big of a deal. What is a bigger deal for them is the rapid increase in price of pewter and how the added weight affects shipping.(which is one reason for the increase in price of pewter)

Another cost for PP would be from maintaining and storing a couple thousand molds that are hardly ever going to be used. Doing a mold for a large run or some primary product that always needs produced isn't a big deal...having a mold for say, long gunners though is just a big question mark.

2
Grubbnubbnubb•

Honestly with PP I think they are just always super, crazy bad at PR on all levels.

I have been playing since MK1 and they always shoot themselves in the foot with anything they launch.

I think replacing cast metal and resin models with 3D printed resin is great.

Since they never really managed to be successful with sprue plastic releases, a large 3D printer will at least mean they can make sell every model, something they have had a real issue with over the years.

19
Kithkar-Jez•

Resin 3D printing has come lightyears in the past five years, this is actually a really good thing. Now, the rest of how they're handling it we will need to see but in a vacuum moving away from traditional casting to 3D printing is the future.

15
Vex1om•

I'd be more inclined to believe this if there was already a serious tabletop game company making models this way. Now, I haven't seen the new models, but PP state right on their website the issues associated with 3d printing.

  1. More model cleaning and less clean models due to the nature of the printing process and the required supports.

  2. Having too much or not enough UV exposure does weird things to the resin. Of course, this can already be a problem with their resin models (first hand experience here.) Still, it isn't going away.

  3. May need to wear a respirator when working on models, depending upon what you are doing.

So, none of that is great, but maybe it will be fine once we see the models, particularly if there was some cost saving involved. Unfortunately, though, that does not appear to be the case, based on what has been announced so far.

2
Massiahjones•

I think they genuinely believe it to be a step forward in terms of controlling production and keeping costs down.

I think that it is a naive decision and the tech isn't there yet, especially given some of the pieces they thought were ok to send out and then decided were a bad batch.

We'll see in 6 months time whether it has paid off but PP have never been at the forefront of industry trends before and it feels potentially telling that not many, if any, other mini games are doing this.

Maybe it's the best thing to happen to Warmachine and it is the start of getting PP back to where we would all like them to be but I'm tempering my expectations.

5
pattousai•

Honestly, PP is kinda weird with annoucements and drumming hype. But the 3d printing part is mostly, a good think.

The scalability of their production becomes much more maleable, and they do not depend on asian factories as much, which, because of covid and other reasons are becoming more expensive to mass produce minis.

While there is zero confirmation of such, i also believe that this means that if they wished so, they can start producing miniatures in any region as well. Want to sell your minis in australia? Boom, hire a 3d printing farm there and suddenly shipping issues go away. Officially they said they want to keep it in-house, but IMO it would be a financially interesting option for the future.

I understand that their announcement was underwhelming, but I don't feel like I got hit with any inherently bad news there. To each their own, but no need to feel like the 3d part is bad.

4
GreystormsOP•

Maybe I got a bit ahead of myself with the panic. The best approach is probably "wait and see", and we'll know more once the new printed minis start getting into more people's hands.

One thing that does worry me a little bit is the implication that once Privateer Press' supplies of resin and white metal run out, they just won't be producing any of those minis anymore. That's a potentially huge portion of their catalogue that will simply cease to exist.

2
pattousai•

Oh yeah. That is a proper worry. And I can understand that this is a pain. Like, the production move to 3d is not perfect, but its the sort of bandaid that needs to be ripped at some point. PP wants to avoid the issue with GW's production, which is having an overbloated cathalogue that they need to keep producing, and at the same time, they don't have the money that GW does.

I do not like that older minis will most likely phase out, but I understand their move. Also, nothing is stopping them from just getting a 3d scanner (technically doable with just a decent phone, but lets be professionals here) and remaking the sculpts for easy printing.

1
small__pp__man•

You are right about printing in different countries. They are looking into that to make the product more widely available and avoid overseas shipping.

1
thenerfviking•

They basically only had two options unfortunately. White metal keeps going up and for some companies that’s not too much of an issue but when you cast really big thick models like PP does that’s gonna make a dent in profit. They had to switch materials and they could have gone to that Spanish hybrid resin that Reaper uses for the Bones USA models which is honestly excellent BUT they are trying to avoid the supply chain issues and that material is made by one company in a foreign country. They could have gone full plastic which is much less expensive than it used to be but there’s not that many companies that do plastic miniatures casting and a lot of them have long wait times so that’s even more supply chain stuff and it also is relying on a separate company to handle all your shit. This way allows them to do a lot of production in house which I think is a fairly attractive proposition as long as they do it correctly. I guess they could have done slow cast pour resin too but these days that’s often harder than doing an 8k print and requires a lot more skill.

3
osmiumouse•

3d print off an industrial printer is very good - this isn't some USD $500 desktop machine (at least I hope not). All companies will eventually start doing this.

3
trulyElse•

I don't think it's that they can't afford it, at least not monetarily. I think they're just sick of supply side issues and decided to give up.

3D printing was already part of their process, as you can see in some of the advertising done when the Infernals were coming out, but that was mostly for the mold masters.

If I had to guess at what prompted this change, I'm going to go with them burning bridges with their mold material guys.

2
Radiant_Ad_4348•

I will hold my opinion until I get to see the minis. But I kind of glad that they don’t support proprietary solution like Siocast. Don’t SioCast also melt in the sun?

2
GreystormsOP•

I don't know much about Siocast beyond what I've seen in a few Youtuber videos, but apparently the Siocast resin is proprietary, which is an obvious issue here with using that casting process.

1
Radiant_Ad_4348•

Yeah that’s why I’m glad that they don’t support these kind of solutions. I have some infinity with SioCast, it’s fine but somehow get damaged easily. I dropped one and the teeth part of the model broke.

2
Sushiki•

Ok two things for this ridiculous opinion:.

Original siocast model up to bearpode at least were a rubber like siocast thermo plastic that I have had fun testing by throwing against a wall because it was so rubbery it would bounce back.

How can you shit on something you know little of in defence of resin loool.

Most resin if left unprimed too long in sun becomes frail.

Dropping most resin models will damage them as much if not more.

Gw finecast resin is probably what you are thinking about for melting in the sun. Infamously so.

Siocast is a thermoplastic, it shouldn't melt outside extreme heat.

Not that you should ever have miniatures in direct sunlight as paint will fade no matter how good the brand.

Siocast done right is the future, it's not toxic like resin, eco friendly, faster to make minis with, list goes on.

That doesn't mean having a siocast machine will produce results, there is a lot to learn, corvus Belli have a unique advantage as it's similar to their way of already doing their molds.

0
Radiant_Ad_4348•

Yes I don’t understand anything about resin and I don’t intend to. It’s not my job to understand, I buy stuff and I paint them and play with them that’s it. As for my experience, it’s been quite positive with it, but the bear’s teeth fell out and that’s by experience with it.

What I don’t like the most is that it’s a proprietary solution and the siocast company have monopoly on the machine and even materials. Which is why I will cheer for PP solutions even though it’s not the best right now.

1
HRM077•

It seems to be a good move.

Honestly, I just feel - perhaps naively - that Wilson is the biggest issue at PP.

2
Nuke_Knight•

I see it as them evolving and getting away from expensive factories with insane shipping costs. Only things they will need are the resin and magnets for the sets O heard would have them included.

2
UgLove•

Yes and no. I think 3D printed minis are exciting for a lot of reasons.

Regarding production: I would imagine minis production was the largest expense PP had/has. Traditional casting is labor intensive and not that agile in responding to orders for products in their vast catalog. It’s messy, wasteful, dangerous, and costly.

What your post seems to suggest is that printing was reluctantly chosen. I reckon this is incorrect.

I have a lot of experience 3D printing land am creating extraordinary minis that are easy to assemble, if it is required, paint, and play with. When the right printer, resin, and print file come together the output is superior to the best traditionally cast part.

The best part, the sculptors and designers gain immense freedom.

There is a lot to be excited about. I’m glad privateer is doing it, I think they are the right company to do it.

2
VancoreStudios•

It's honestly the way all wargaming in the future is going to go. I foresee less money made in the models, more on rule update editions, subs to apps, and maybe even selling/leasing STLs to legally make models. Not like that's going to stop savvy 3d printer owners just like anyone with a computer can get free songs and movies. If PP provides good service maybe it can be the first successful 3D printed game

1
maxkool007•

Sell STL files and be done with it. You are WAY too late to the game, I print 99% of the minis I use these days and refuse to pay the crazy prices they want for crap models these days. I print models that make PPs stuff look like grade school garbage. If they are going this route they really need to up their sculpt game. Cause they are entering an area where everyone is killing them in quality. Their models look really lousy next to the stuff I print.....

1