The Make-Believe World of David Graeber: Reflections on the Ideology Underlying the Failed Occupation of Zuccotti Park
marxisthumanistinitiative.org/alternatives-to...Posted Jul 12, 2012, 6:55 AM UTC
Posted Jul 12, 2012, 6:55 AM UTC
If I understood it correctly, It's the smash the egg vs. the "build from within the shell" argument. Honestly, I think they must both exist. One provides the resistance to power while the other provides an alternative in the resulting vacuum.
This is just the usual Marxist verbal tic of arguing with a position nobody actually holds, and then acting as if everyone who doesn't subscribe to their particular line of theory is a liberal reformist who's never even heard the words "revolution" or "class." MHI kept spamming Graeber's twitter feed with it, even after he told them he wasn't going to engage with something that utterly misrepresents what he believes, and he finally got ticked off and blocked them.
And here is a response to criticisms made of the essay.
*I think the whole argument basically boils down to,
’[T]rying to remake the existing society into something it’s not’ and ‘trying to gradually expand the new world that already exists within the old one’ sounds to me like a distinction without substance, or at best it’s a distinction over preference of metaphor.” I don’t really understand this. … You may be thinking that I favor the former over the latter. I don’t. I don’t think it’s possible to remake the existing society into something it’s not, just like it’s not possible to remake a turnip into a source of blood. This is why I think we need a wholly different society.
This guy seems a little crazy to me based on his responses to some of the comments.. He makes really silly analogies and blows Graebers analogies out of proportion..