r/Teachers•
Jruff

"We already pay the most for education." Why this is wrong.

Policy & Politics

With the teacher shortage in the news, discussions of education budgeting are coming up. There is an old argument against increases in education budgeting is that the US already spends the most on education per student. I'd like to bring a few reasons where this is wrong and misleading.

First of all, it's flat out wrong. According to the National Center for Education Statistics, the US is lower than several other countries. We are higher than the average members of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, but this average is brought down several countries with lower costs of living like Mexico, Colombia and Turkey.

Second, among more developed countries, much of the spending on education in US is used to pay for services that would not be seen as education expenditures in other countries.

  1. Health Insurance: I would love to look at nationwide data on this. In my school district, 12% of the school budget is directed at health insurance, this would not be an education expense in many other countries.
  2. Sports: In my small school district, 4.5% of the budget is for sports activities. As far as I know, it isn't common for other countries to count their athletics as education spending.

I can't possibly calculate economies of scale issues that develop because the US has so many small schools and so many small districts. Many areas of the US require extra admin because of small school districts and extra transportation funds. If you account for these things I think you would find we are just in line with other countries if not below countries with similar economies.

Posted Aug 4, 2022, 2:43 PM UTC · edited

5114
Loading comments…