what would cause a protocol paper to be retracted?

never really come across one myself but found the exact protocol i need, but it was retracted.

Posted Aug 10, 2022, 6:20 PM UTC

66
futuredoctor131•

Sometimes linked somewhere on the retracted paper there will be some sort of editor’s note about why it was retracted (in my experience this is frequently on a different page than the paper itself).

9
South-Gap-77•

Maybe they realized there's something wrong? Or its irreproducible?

5
drtumbleleaf•

Wasn’t there a bit of a scandal with stem cells a few years back, where some lab claimed they could make stem cells from fully differentiated cells super easily, and then no other lab could get their protocol to work?

7
Goober_Bean•

Are you thinking of the STAP cell protocol that came out of Riken? The researcher at the center of the controversy, Haruko Obokata, claimed she could make pluripotent stem cells by essentially exposing any somatic cell type to a weak citric acid solution. IIRC one of the higher ups at Riken (her supervisor maybe) committed suicide because of the ensuing controversy. So tragic.

6
drtumbleleaf•

That’s what I was thinking of. That’s even worse than I’d remembered.

3
South-Gap-77•

There's a lot of these happening. really sucks for science in general, especially in a society that already isn't too high on science and research.

5