Bo1 BGA final cuts and opinions on a couple niche rares.
https://sealeddeck.tech/8HCxD0wqaK
With 14 dragons (4 of which draw more dragons) is kindred discovery good? Should I be worried about decking myself? Would it make sense to go over 40 cards just due the deck velocity this deck can have?
Not sure on Gale's Redirection. 5 mana is a lot for a counter but it's built in 2 for 1 and potentially a nice tempo gain if the spell if free.
Also curious on people's thoughts on if the change is Dragonborn Looter going to just (U) cost a buff a nerf for it in the context of this deck given 2x Lozhan? I think it's probably a nerf but the other changes are probably buffs for this deck. I think I'll probably cut the looter since it will only ping for 1 with Lozhan after the changes.
Is navigation orb good enough now with the drop in the activation cost or still too slow?
Posted Aug 11, 2022, 5:19 AM UTC
I don't think you should go over 40 even if you play Kindred Discovery. If you can play so many creatures that you're getting to the end of your deck then you are winning the game already. Odds of having a game where the extra card gives you the turn needed for lethal are a lot smaller than the odds of that card making you lose because you're drawing cards that aren't your best.
I also don't think you should play Kindred Discovery. Admittedly if there is a deck for that card, this is it. Experience with similar effects in past sets says that a do nothing 5 mana card is just too much of a setback. Even if you draw one extra card per turn after that you might be too far behind. Stats corroborate experience and indicate that it's a card you should never put in your deck.
Speaking of cards you should not put in your deck, Gale's Redirection is a 5 mana counter in a deck that doesn't have the best early game presence and has no instant speed cards. You're likely going to be behind on turn 5 and then you just have to pass with all your mana up and hope your opponent plays something good. Sounds awful.
Regarding your Dragonborn Looter comment, I think you're focusing way too much on the interaction with one specific card in your deck. Being able to play it on turn 1 is a lot stronger than any effect it might have in conjunction with one card in your deck (and a card that is likely drawing out immediate removal anyway). Same logic from the first paragraph applies here: if you're able to untap with the UR pinglord and start playing other dragons you're very likely winning anyway, no need to go out of your way and make your deck worse just for that card to be slightly better in the best case scenario.
Navigation Orb still seems too slow to me, and I don't think I would splash Draconic Muralists. It is a very strong card here, but mana consistency is a lot stronger than we usually give it credit for. I'm not 100% sure on this one, but when you are playing something like navigation orb just to be able to play your splash then imo you're better off just removing both.
I also think Valor Singer is a lot better than you give it credit for and should be in your deck. Same might also be true for Air-Cult Elemental, though in that case you'd have to check what your curve looks like. Can't look it up again while writing this comment on my phone.