r/mac•
Mallen

First time upgrade question!

So r/mac this is my first time upgrading to a major release. Im a recent convert and have been running Lion for about 4 months now and have had to reinstall once. With the release of Mountain Lion in the next week or two I was wondering how everyone else will be upgrading? Do you just do a rolling upgrade and keep everything? or do you do a fresh install?

Posted Jul 16, 2012, 11:42 AM UTC

211
[deleted]•

I do a rolling update. A habit that I got from Ubuntu, but I will be probably reinstalling with this update. This is an install straight from the store (only updated it on Lion) and has never been reinstalled so I think I should benefit from it.

I only need to figure out how can I transfer licencies for my paid software (Alfred, Sparow and other apps that I didn't buy over App Store).

2
MallenOP•

Yea, I think Im going to go with a fresh install of Mountain Lion as well. How do you go about doing that? Do you purchase from the apple site/store or buy in the app store?

1
DanaKaZ•

You buy it in the App store, and then you can make a clean install from a usb.

This guide is for Lion, but the process for ML is the same.

http://lifehacker.com/5823096/how-to-burn-your-own-lion-install-dvd-or-flash-drive

3
[deleted]•

Thanks :D

2
MallenOP•

Thanks!

1
tijo799•

Just a quick point about running a fresh install: You don't need to make an external installer on a USB drive. The recovery partition will let you do exactly what the old install DVDs would do. If you want to run a clean install, boot from the recovery partition, erase your boot volume in Disk Utility, and then reinstall a fresh copy if the OS.

The upside to this is you never lose your install media. The downside is, if you want to clean install 10.8 from 10.7, you'll have to upgrade to 10.8 first, so that you have an updated recovery partition, then erase and install the OS.

2
MallenOP•

Yea, I had a feeling I could accomplish it this way. Thanks for the heads up!

2

I'll just get the App Store bundle and do whatever it defaults to.

1
fracai•

I've typically done a clean install, but I'm not going to this time.

In the past, a clean install was easy, you've already got the physical install media. Apple clearly wanted you to just run an upgrade, but a clean install was an easy option and it felt nice to clear away a lot of cruft.

Now though, it's clear that Apple thinks everyone should just be upgrading. In order to clean install you need to dig into the installer (only available from the Mac App Store, Apple isn't doing a USB stick this time) and create your own media. It's not too much of an additional step, but Apple is all but dropping support for a clean install.

Plus, I feel like things are maturing and I'm not seeing the benefit of starting clean or what "cruft" is around. My own usage patterns are cleaner (App Store apps go in /Applications, downloaded go in ~/Applications, etc.) such that it's just my user folder that would need cleaning. And that's mostly preference files that certainly aren't going to slow anything down.

I look forward to just running the upgrade and continuing on. I certainly won't miss having to run an extra backup, followed by hand picking which files and preferences are moved back in.

I just don't see any benefit to a clean install if you aren't experiencing any problems.

0
Demonomicron•

I've been going back and forth on this. I'm worried about kexts and libraries getting left around by weird apps. I've installed a lot of stuff with macports and I've installed a lot of weird audio software and drivers. I'd like to do a fresh install of 10.8 but I haven't messed with an Apple installer since Leopard so I'm not up on what's changed. Does the installer not provide a clean install option?

2
fracai•

Yeah, but at the same time, if you still want that app, you still want the kext. Keeping track of library files can get messy. I try to limit what gets installed there and when I need to use an installer, I look at the install list to see where things are going.

Lion and Mountain Lion are just apps from the Mac App Store. When you run them, they install some stuff, reboot, and finish the upgrade. There's a disk image within the installer that can be restored to DVD or flash media that will allow booting for a clean install. With Mountain Lion not out yet, there's always the possibility that this won't be possible, but there haven't been any rumors to suggest that.

2