Is the Constant On and Off Safe for the System?

AC

This may be a stupid question, so I apologize in advance.

I had a new system installed this week. All is fine, but I am concerned about how quickly and how often it turns on and off to maintain the selected temp. For example, my old system was, well, old. We'd keep it at 73 degrees and it would never get there on warm days (let alone hot), so it would just run all day while it fluctuated from 78 to 75. It wouldn't get to the set temperature until the outdoor temp cooled, at which point it would shut off until the warmed up again. All was fine.

The new system is doing it's job well, but maybe a little too well? We have it set to 73. It reaches 73 degrees and shuts off. Twenty minutes later it turns on again, runs for about 10 minutes, reaches the desired temp and shuts off. Rinse and repeat. I've started alternating the desired temp. So during the days, I'll change it to 70, so it runs a little longer, and at night, I switch it to 73 so that it runs very little.

My question is, is this constant on and off bad for the condenser? Should I be worried? Do I need a new thermostat?

Thanks in advance.

Posted Aug 13, 2022, 10:22 PM UTC

29
Forward_HvacApproved Technician•

To have it run for 10 minutes and off for 20 minutes sounds reasonable it would be considered short cycling if it ran 1-3 minutes and shut off for 3-5 minutes and repeat then but it sounds like it is a single stage unit would run 2-3x an hour sounds good, if your humidity inside is good then I’d be happy. Sounds like your old system was a little low on refrigerant and couldn’t cool the house down

2
glass_superman•

Maybe the AC is a little too big or maybe it wasn't all that hot a day. But that cycle seems reasonable.

For reference, my zone controller has a time delay to prevent it from turning on too quickly after it has turned off: 4 minutes! So twenty minutes is not bad.

1
tempdroiduserOP•

Yeah, I think I was just being a little over cautious. I actually documented the times cuts on and off for a couple of hours, and it’s about 16-20 minutes between cycles, so just about 3 times an hour, which appears to be normal.

Thanks for the reassurance though, much appreciated!

1
Miercury•

Short-cycling is not good if the A/C can cool the space to the setpoint rapidly.

In doing this it removes heaps of sensible heat (°F) but not much humidity.

If your house is not getting cold and clammy-feeling, it's likely that things are fine.

You don't happen to know if the size/capacity of the A/C was increased on this new install?

0
tempdroiduserOP•

It’s the same size. Two and half tons. I wouldn’t describe the problem as short cycling though, as it is completing its cooling cycle.

1
Miercury•

It's probably fine.

I'd set the thermostat to a single temperature you're comfortable at and see how it runs after a few days.

3
tempdroiduserOP•

Okay, will do. Everything is under warranty, so I’m not too concerned. But I’d just prefer to avoid a problem if possible. Thanks for the advice.

1
Silver_goboApproved Technician•

Get a Honeywell thermostat with cooling cycles set

2