I want to know why SPOILERS

SpoilerShow Discussion

The show decided to drop the Granville character after the few episodes of season 1. Nothing they did with the character later was any good (especially that poem. So hideous) AND they apparently permanently closed the door on LGBTQ characters ever appearing again, which leaves a sour taste while watching a show that purports itself as inclusive.

And since the 100% straight s2 is preferred over s1, I don't hold hope of that ever changing.

It's also disturbing how when Shondaland got free of network restrictions the first thing she got rid of in her first Netflix production were LGBTQ characters. Not a good look.

Posted Aug 16, 2022, 11:49 AM UTC · edited

056
Plums4•

I mean, none of the mains are gonna be LGBTQ because these are super traditional het romance novels they're adapting, but that doesn't mean there won't ever be future LGBTQ characters. I don't know where that idea comes from.

32
mgdraft•

There literally is a gay character in one of the later books, and he's a pretty significant part of the plot, so I'm surprised people have just decided there won't be... anyone. Like I'd like more secondary and background queer characters for sure but people seem to have latched on to it being Benedict when Gregory makes way more sense

5
Keating5OP•

It comes from how the only LGBTQ characters so far in the show were only used as props for a het romance and discarded immediately after.

-4†
Plums4•

There's been one so far- that's not a pattern. But you have a point that they could probably stand to think these things through more. Marina being a POC is another way in which they didn't think through some extremely unfortunate implications if they follow the books.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

If it ain’t one of the sibs then it’s irrelevant. The sibs are guaranteed an HEA. Side characters can unfortunately fall into harmful tropes like kill your gays. The show has a much wider audience than the books and the show audience is not stupid.

-5†
Forsaken-Gap-3684•

No. Thats a stupid. Perhaps if there were an entirely original show but it isn’t.

2
heatherhobbit•

When did they permanently close any doors to LGBTQ characters ever appearing again? Did you read all of the scripts for every episode that will ever air? Do you know things the rest of us don’t?

21
[deleted]•

If it isn’t one of the siblings then the door is closed. The siblings are guaranteed an HEA.

-6
Keating5OP•

They used the only LGBTQ characters as props for Benophie and then they literally had no one else.

-7
heatherhobbit•

It’s been two seasons. There’s potentially several more plus the queen spin-off. There’s still plenty of opportunities. We all knew the siblings were going to end up with the same people in the books. That’s not a surprise. But there are still many many opportunities for side characters.

12
[deleted]•

[deleted]

13
Keating5OP•

Aka, a gay prop to open Benedict to dating below his class (Sophie).

-3
LittleHouseofGeekyYou're Pen, you do not count•

My two thoughts:

*They don’t employ the same side characters over seasons because they might have to pay them more so it’s cheaper to replace a lot of them (I don’t think Fife will be in S3)

*i genuinely believe they took S1 criticism on and decided to distance Benedict from LGBTQ characters to reduce the queer baiting criticism so Granville is gone

11
tifferiffic83•

So it sounds like a lose/lose situation. If they introduce more characters, they get accused of queer baiting or using "gay props". If they don't introduce more characters, they get accused anyway.

I've seen the same issues with casting people of color. First its praised for the diversity. Then its criticized for tokenism.

4
[deleted]•

That’s because there is a thin line between the two. I mean there are 8 siblings and all of them have to have a cis-het romance?

0
tifferiffic83•

I guess from their viewpoint, that depends on 2 things.

  1. Are they actually getting 8 seasons?

  2. Does the agreement to stick to original HEAs exist or not?

If the agreement doesn't exist, I think Shondaland could and would make one of the siblings a queer character. But, if that agreement does exist, I don't see it happening with one of the main couples. Maybe in the spinoff.

I will say, I think it's an error to dismiss the idea of having queer characters/couples in side characters. Side plots with original characters get pretty heavy treatment with great screentime. Even if we didn't get a queer couple as one of the siblings, we could still get some good, fleshed out, well written ones in subplots.

1

The agreement with Julia Quinn and Shondaland is, in fact, to stick to the canon, HEA couple for each. And to be honest, as it should be IMO. The show is based on very popular books, from which there are very popular couples that fans want to see on screen. It is one thing to change the race, or even elements of the story. It is another to just tell an entirely different story all together. Imagine if Kate was erased from s2. Or Simon from season 1. Fans tune in to see these stories brought to life, it is why book ---> TV /movie adaptations are popular.

This isn't to say that there cannot be other characters, LGBTQ characters, etc., but when people are mad that they don't change the HEA couples it seems to miss the point of going popular book to show.

2
[deleted]•

Any side characters would need a definitive HEA. There is too much of a convention in entertainment that LGBTQ characters either are killed off or used as props. This is why side plots don’t work because the LGBTQ needs to be centered and not pushed to the side. We are just as valuable as the standard cis-het one.

2
LittleHouseofGeekyYou're Pen, you do not count•

I think at this point they’ve shot themselves in the foot regarding diversity in the show due to the casting and I’d take anything off it meant just keeping the screen from being filled with cishet white people but queer side characters tend to get poor treatment historically in period dramas (ie sad endings)

1
Forsaken-Gap-3684•

Hahaha. That’s funny.

1
[deleted]•

If you read Gregory’s book, there is a major LGBT character in there. However, it ain’t the rep you are looking for.

10
Due_Lengthiness4488Sitting among the stars•

Source for permanently closing doors on LGBTQ characters? Haven't heard this before so I'm curious.

9
Keating5OP•

The whole 'homosexuality is illegal and punishable by death' thing.

-4
sungelly87•

But it was during that time. And although they’re not historically accurate idk how much leeway they would have.

11
[deleted]•

And that’s what makes an LGBTQ more powerful. These people during this time faced death should they be discovered but then those people were very crafty to ensure their happiness. That story needs to be told.

2
tifferiffic83•

None of the main siblings will be in LGBTQ relationships because they are bound to stay true to the original relationships. It doesn't mean side characters won't be LGBTQ. The characters that were in Season 1 were a part of Benedict's sideplot. Who's to say those characters, or new ones, won't be reintroduced as his story arc grows? Last season's sideplots went to the Featheringtons. Maybe next season will have a larger Benedict sideplot to build up to his season.

5
[deleted]•

This has been disproved over and over again. The is not bound to stick to all the original characters. JQ has given up all creative control to Shondaland. That includes if they want to they can change one or at most two of the sibs stories.

0†
GCooperE•

I see "Netflix is obliged to stick to the original ships" everywhere, but no one is actually providing sources for this claim. I've seen JQ and writers saying that the intent is to stay true to the original spirit of the romances and stuff like that, or staying true is currently the goal, but I've yet to see a source that says they're legally required to do so. So far, it feels like they've left themselves a lot of wriggle room.

4
[deleted]•

Yes. And if Shondaland is smart that is absolutely what they should do. I know the books have their audience but the show’s audience is way bigger and way more diverse. Shondaland knows this and yes Shonda is well aware of what diversity should look like.

3
PlantSuperpowers•

Show audience consists of book + non book. But the book audience is not enough to make it a hit show, they are a 6 digit number at max. So to make a hit show, they need numbers and that means they need to reel people in. They did that by adapting the book and pleasing the non-book reading wider audience by making the Bridgerton universe as an inclusive universe (( coz books are all white people pairings. >!Simon was blonde with blue eyes in the books yall!< )). But when it comes to losses, losing the book audience is a lot of loss, plus the negative publicity. So they chose to keep some of the book as it is. Keeping the endgame couples as it is, some of the names / surnames, some parts of the story kept, something else changed, keeping the theme of each couple (like fake dating trope, resisting true love trope, friends to lovers trope and >!love at first sight trope!< of benedict, >!desperate strangers to lover trope!< of eloise, >!finding love twice trope!< of frannie, >!loving the friend of my intended trope!< Of gregory, and >!was gonna trap someone but now im in love trope !< Of hyacinth.

1
GCooperE•

Bottom line is Netflix cares about money and ratings, not the integrity of the books. And Bridgerton prides itself on being diverse, so I can very well imagine the makers deciding to introduce an LGBT romance.

Like this idea of staying true to the 'spirit' of the romances. Well what tropes do Ben and Eloise have? Crossing class boundaries, forbidden love, epistolary romances. They could include these elements without keeping the love interest the same. For example, the better parts of Eloise's romance could easily be done with swapping Marina for Phillip.

0
PlantSuperpowers•

I think the thing is they cant outright say "every sibiling will have hetero HEA's accd to the book" coz that would cause riot coz even in regency times there were LGBTQIA people. There is a thin line they seem to be walking on while interviewing to not go off air, while keeping open room for LGBTQIA stuff without looking like queer baiting.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0†
LadyMissyT•

They will as there will be a contract with the publisher for a book/show tie-in cover and marketing like we have already seen for the first two books.

6
Allbellis•

That's what I think. They haven't announced they'll be sticking to the book couples, but I'd be surprised if the publisher had signed away the rights without the added benefit of book promo

3
LadyMissyT•

I had an idea last year during S1 press someone connected, either Shonda Rhimes or CVD, said that the couples would remain the same, but I can't remember where I saw it. The only thing that has been said will change is the order of the books.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
LadyMissyT•

Yeah, I don't think anyone really knows.

I agree, I don't think they will change the main stories either, the whole marketing of it is around the books.

1
sungelly87•

It’s a known agreement they made with Julia Quinn that the couples will remain the same

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
cyberlucyYour regrets, are denied•

It was something JQ talked about before S1 aired in several interviews during the first summer of the pandemic. There has been no official announcement about it. Just hints and clues from CVD and Shonda(like him comparing Theo to Sienna and her mentioning the names of a couple of the other spouses that haven't shown up like they are going to happen)

1
Allbellis•

Granville is like the Prince, Rose, Dorset and Benedict's s2 artist posse. Minor characters whose actors only sign on for one season.

Nothing they did with the character later was any good (especially that poem. So hideous)

I don't remember Granville and a poem?

they apparently permanently closed the door on LGBTQ characters ever appearing again

They never said that and I really doubt it

5
Forsaken-Gap-3684•

I don’t go conclude that lgbt characters will not appear again. Not at all.

3

they heavily queercoded benedict and eloise in season1 but then ignored it in season2

2

How is Eloise queercoded in season one? Feminist does not equal lesbian/bi etc. I am sincerely interested in how people think she gave LGBTQIA+ vibes.

3

all the conversations about thinking she’s different than all the other women and how she was not interested in any of the men. i know a lot of it relates to her feminism but there was a lot of things that pointed towards her being queer.

0

Thank you for the answer. I apprectiate your perspective. I guess it shows my age that I grew up in a time where many women fighting for equality were labeled lesbians or man haters which was so wrong. It made the concept of feminism and being a lesbian bad things in one swoop.

So, for me, Eloise was not the least bit presented as being LGBTQIA+.

I also see her fearing men or more a man's control than being disinterested in them. I find Eloise psychologically very interesting.

2
AutoModeratorMOD•

For this Show Discussion post:

  1. Book spoilers must be hidden.

  2. Be considerate, hide show spoilers that surpass the scope of this post.

  3. Be civil in your discussion.

See our spoiler policy on what is expected. 3-day bans will be handed out to those found disregarding our spoiler policy.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
vulpixess•

They’re all for diversity so long as it’s not lgbtq but they said they are including it in the spin off (the queens servant Brimsley I think, will have a queer scene) but it won’t be enough

1†
GCooperE•

I'm gutted too. He was an excellent character, with so much chemistry with Benedict. Seeing as Benedict is still very much moving in those artistic circles, he would have been perfect to keep around, acting as Ben's artistic mentor (not his sole reason for existing, just as a plot device to get him on screen) and providing a different perspective to society. There were so many moments where they could easily have slipped him in.

And that bohemian world is so interesting and such a fascinating counter to the rigid society it lives next to. I want to see more plotlines take place in that setting, with characters who have been stuck in society suddenly discovering a new sort of world that's right on their doorstep.

My only hope is that he will come back as Benedict gains prominence. The writers would be making a mistake wasting his character.

1
Sparkle_MarkleCrane•

They creators really said ‘oh no, everyone thinks Ben and Eloise are gay. Time to get rid of all of them and give El a boy crush and Ben a random lady to be naked with’.

0†
Plums4•

I'll grant you they probably went ohshit when they realized what they did with Eloise, but Benedict was having threesomes with women and becoming fuckbuddies with Madame Delacroix and being disturbed about Granville being gay all before any audience watched s1 to get mad about queerbaiting.

4
Sparkle_MarkleCrane•

Benedict wasn’t disturbed by Granville being gay, I think he was just surprised and intrigued. Even though Ben did have female romantic interests in s1, he spent most of his screen time with Granville and they had chemistry. So lots of people, including myself, felt queerbaited because the show promoted inclusion and showed the 1 gay scene in the trailer so we thought more was to come with that. We thought he would be bi 🤷‍♀️

3
[deleted]•

The second half of season 1 he was with Mme De La Croix. After Ep 5 Ben and Granville did not share any scenes together.

1
Sparkle_MarkleCrane•

Ok and he could have went back to Granville after being with Genevieve lol. I said we thought he was bi. And he did have scenes with Granville after episode 5, episode 7 they had that Oceans Apart talk where Granville admitted to loving Wetherbee (much to my confusion at the time)

1