[serious] what to expect as 9th step from 3 decades long SIL Q?
[ADVICE WANTED]. Generally, they admit their wrongdoing, is there an actual apology involved, or more “yeah, I did XYZ, whoops, get over it?”
Posted Aug 16, 2022, 10:52 PM UTC · edited
[ADVICE WANTED]. Generally, they admit their wrongdoing, is there an actual apology involved, or more “yeah, I did XYZ, whoops, get over it?”
Posted Aug 16, 2022, 10:52 PM UTC · edited
The many drinkers in my life haven't recovered except for one who didn't have past history with me prior to recovery. In any case, each person is an individual. My own amends have varied. I typically apologize but the focus is on "living amends," which means changing my actions and attitudes.
Alcoholic here 2 1/2 years sober. Did a 9th step not to long ago. Done correctly it can be one of the most freeing feelings in the world. It's a hell of a lot more than just saying I'm sorry. It's about being willing to accept the consequences of past actions. I know full well the damage I've caused most people. It was pretty much well received by most. I detailed all of what I thought I'd done, but a step further is needed. Asking the question is there any other way I may owe one? 2 of my 3 sons and I talked for a long time. They detailing what they felt. When it was completed we grew closer. My 3rd son still won't talk to me. That's fine if and when he does I am ready. My dad was probably the hardest, I was in tears talking to him. My long suffering wife, I am still making amends. A living one. We talked a long time still but she has seen the changes in me. Gone is the self-centered, selfish, egotistical SOB that had made her life miserable for so long. Making amends isn't just a one and done affair. It starts a lifetime process of yes, correcting past wrongs but doing that daily if the need arises.
IDK, that is how my sponsor taught me. It seems to work.
Nah. Just wanted to know what "amends" were with most alcoholics. Not here to make her better, still all about them. I'll remain estranged if that's the case. Thx. I'd forgive her, but want her toxicity out of my life permanently.
No one does it the same. Everyone is different. Just like in Al-Anon.
She deserves to hurt after what she's put her family through. I'd forgive, but she's done 20+ rehabs, about 30 detoxes, never changes drunk or sober. How do you deal with that?
I understand what you are going through- my sister has destroyed our family, abandoned 2 young kids, and continues to hurt and use people with no remorse. She’s been through rehab so many times and just doesn’t seem to want to change. She’s been in car accidents where she has almost killed someone, and I know as soon as she’s out of rehab she’ll do it again bc she doesn’t really want to change. It was rehab or jail, so she’ll do her little stint in rehab and be right back at it. I don’t blame you for wanting her out of your life. I agree with those saying her steps are about her, but at the same time you are able to make decisions about your own life and sometimes remaining estranged for your own mental health is necessary. People may not understand and they don’t need to. A lot of people are nice and want to “help” my sister and end up being burned badly- she “borrowed” a kind “friends” car while they were out of town, crashed their car, used their apartment keys without asking to get into their apartment, drank their wine collection, vomited all over, and was only found after a missing persons report was filed. Before this happened this person initially was appalled that none of her family members would take her in yet again. Even if she came to me and apologized sincerely for all the horrible things she had done to her family, including abandoning her 2 young children, I still would never trust her or want to have a relationship with her.
Ty. I am sorry for what you’ve been thru. This next stint in treatment is court ordered, not of her own volition, so I expect little to no change as she’s done detox/rehab/AA sooooo many times. Don’t think she’s truly ever made it past step 1. If she actually works the program and means it, I’d welcome her with open arms. I just have no hope left she’ll do, just shy of 50 years old, her mom enables her. Thank goodness she couldn’t have kids!
Yeah, my SIL will never ever do any of that. Glad it was mostly freeing for you, though!
I would suggest that you consider that someone else's ninth step is about them, not about you. If you feel better as a result of receiving their amends, that's wonderful, but it's icing on the cake, really. The Al-Anon program, instead, is the way you can find contentment and relief with respect to your Q, regardless of whether or not they make amends or are even sober.
I would second this. In my experience, the amends I have received were like the tip of the iceberg, made when my Q was a baby in his sobriety. With some time into the program, he has actually offered more heart-felt apologies, but they weren't part of his step work. And I was way past feeling like I needed them. Instead, I focus more on keeping my side of the street clean.
The other side of this is that you are under no obligation to "accept" the amends or even talk to them if they try to offer you one. If seeing her/talking to her affects your peace and serenity, just say "No thanks." AA says that they should only make the amends if it doesn't cause further harm.
AA also seems to make amends useless, and the addict is rarely sincere. Yet they've "cleaned up their side of the street." Ha! My a$$.
She's been thru AA locally so many times, never working steps, the regulars literally laugh when she shows up yet again and call her "Crazy XXXX". No lie. She can't stick with it over 3 decades.
I’m sorry to hear that. It must be really frustrating. All we can do, though, is focus on us. I’ve told my Q hundreds of times that it would be so much easier if I could just do this for him. But that just isn’t how addiction works.
That doesn’t sound like the AA I know.
I know, same. She’s basically considered a repeater who has no intention of staying clean, over 3 decades. Just convicted of super dui in our state tho, so maybe for once she’ll embrace recovery. One slip up and she’ll just be in jail.
I’ve seen this sentiment repeated and I completely disagree. I understand where it comes from, for your own good you shouldn’t hold your breath because your Q most likely will not perform this step correctly, especially the first time, and it’s unfair to you and will only lead to disappointment if you are waiting on that.
But my interpretation of the literature is that step 9 is a very important step and if done correctly can be healing for both parties. If it was all about the addict, that’s just feeding their selfishness and the opposite of what AA teaches about the need for humility. And the step itself says they should not reach out if it would cause more harm than good which implies that it IS intended to cause good for the recipient. After all, they could just stop at the previous two steps which are about them, there would be no need to involve those they hurt if not to give them some comfort or resolution or peace.
In my case, my Q did it entirely prematurely and insincerely and it did cause much harm. I think that happens a lot. But they should be repeating all their steps including 9. Also, you can decline the amends. Someone I know who is a drug counselor and has a Q declined several times over years before finally accepting. She did so when it felt right for her. I am focused on my own healing but I think I would be open to an honest, sincere attempt at amends from my Q one day. And only to that, not insincere attempt designed to assuage his guilt. I just am not counting on that or making my happiness dependent on it anymore.
My contentment, acceptance, and recovery should not be dependent on how "well" (or even if) my Q executes their amends. My understanding of the Al-Anon program and the ninth step is that there is healing for the person performing the ninth step in accepting and admitting to the part they played in causing others difficulty, regardless of whether or not the other person actually accepts the amends or thinks that it was "good enough". Stopping at step 8 isn't enough. In other words, by performing a ninth step, I am not trying to "fix" or "satisfy" anyone else. Those feelings are the other person's responsibility. I'm working on myself. I certainly want the object of my amends to be happy, but making them so is out of my control. We will have to agree to disagree.
I think the difference is whether the Q is making a sincere effort or not. If they make a sincere effort and their amends is rejected then they should feel at peace knowing the tried their best. But too often step 9 is used as my Q used it, as a formality or a selfish attempt to relieve their own guilt. In that case they are not being true to the step or the program. And also, people in recovery repeat all their steps as needed.
I agree with what you wrote but I also think it’s fallacious and harmful to tell people that step 9 is only about the addict. Two people are involved there, and the interaction is about both of them. Otherwise the recipient just feels like a prop in someone else’s story. I sought advice when my Q reached out and heard this as well as the opposite: that if done correctly, step 9 is about the recipient and should be done on their terms. So it’s one of those things that is open to interpretation I guess.
To me, making amends ideally would be of benefit to both parties, requires sincerity and respect and consideration of the recipient’s wishes. I do not think the majority of people in AA perform it that way.
If the Q isn't making a sincere effort, then their recovery will unfortunately not progress as quickly as it could, but that doesn't mean the receiver of the amends needs to suffer, too. There's a difference between whether the person performing step nine gets what they should get out of it, and the person they are making amends to feeling somehow "validated" or "satisfied" with the amends. It may be the case that many amends are not performed in the best way for the recovery of the Q, but them doing it "right" isn't a requirement for my recovery and contentment as the receiver of those amends.
Of course people in recovery repeat their steps as needed; I'm not sure how that's relevant to this discussion. It may be the case that a Q does a better job with amends the second or third or whatever time, but I'm not withholding my serenity until that happens.
No offense intended, but I think it's fallacious and harmful to tell Al-Anons that their happiness and recovery is dependent on their Q doing the amends "right". That's making their happiness and contentment dependent on the Q. As I said originally, if the receiver of the amends gets something positive out of the amends made, that's absolutely wonderful and the ideal situation, but the "quality" of the amends made should be between the Q and their Higher Power. If the receiver of the amends withholds their own happiness and serenity because the amends weren't done to their satisfaction, they are only hurting themselves.
My local AlAnon group has attitude of "suck it up, take the abuse until you die." I noped outta there fast.
That doesn't sound like the Al-Anon I know. Consider trying a different meeting, or even one of the virtual meetings.
I will, thank you!