Brief thoughts on shibblenutters and DogsBite.org statistics

Debate/Discussion/Research

The other day I saw a shibblenutter declare that, since DogsBite.org founder Colleen Lynn is not a professional statistician, this means her site's data is unreliable or suspect. As a statistics tutor, this claim struck me as completely absurd and stupid. Even if we grant that the data is unrepresentative of the entire population of shibbles, this is a red herring, as no one claims that the vast majority of shibbles are bound to eventually attack someone. As critics of the breed, our only point is that the probability of them rampaging is significant enough to do whatever is necessary to prevent these tragedies. Similarly, even though car crashes are exceedingly more improbable than shibble attacks, we still wear seatbelts and equip our vehicles with airbags and shatterproof glass in order to protect ourselves in the unfortunate event of an accident.

DogsBite.org contains hundreds (thousands?) of injurious or deadly incidents over many years—to say nothing of the innumerable non-injurious aggressive encounters that go unreported every day—confirming these beasts' deadly potential. As these useless creatures, unlike cars, certainly are not in any way essential to society, even one or two of these incidents should warrant the entire breed's elimination, particularly if they involve unsuspecting members of the public rather than shibblenutters themselves.

If I had more time I would've developed and organized my thoughts here a bit more, but that's it for now.

Posted Aug 17, 2022, 3:44 AM UTC

764
-TheHumblingRiver-•

Eh, you know the people who discard dogsbite.org as biased but have no problem mentioning the BFAS (who really has it's roots in a religious cult, ain't that cute?) or any other clear-as-day pro-pit, should sit this one out.

Something, something, pot & kettle....

I always look to the insurances and doctors. You know, the ones who have no dog in this fight, literally, but have to directly deal with the consequences. There's a reason these dogs are banned in many countries.

31
pitbutterEscaped a Close Call•
16
iphany•

Pitbulls and mixed breeds, aka pit mixes 😂

7
aSlouchingStatue•

My biggest problem with that website is that it's organized to persuade statisticians instead of the average person, not enough graphs and pictures. Very heavy on links to studies and articles. That stuff is good, don't get me wrong, but it should really be more of an addendum at the bottom of the page rather than the first thing you see. Pitnutters are by-and-large sub-verbal people, when they see a paragraph of text the most you can hope for is that they will just skim it. Even using the same data and graphing it 3 different ways with brighter colors would do a lot of good in making it much more persuasive than it currently is.

7