Your favorite Defender class?

Xenoblade 3

I REALLY like Guardian Commander on paper.

That Awakening buff obtained through its Talent Art makes your defender capable of some seriously ridiculous damage when combined with certain gems and accessories (art cancel gem and fusion art dmg acc). Its cover skill can save a lot of party members low on health. But god does it feel freaking impossible to hold aggro. Like you absolutely need Glow Ring and Mighty Beat master arts to get any use out of GC's talent art. I love it but I think that's my biggest issue with it: The irony of the class' reliance on its talent art and having little to no aggro boosting arts to make it proc consistently. I do think its party cover skill is one the absolute best Defender skills in the game though, especially for protecting healers during revive phases.

What's your favorite Defender?

Posted Aug 21, 2022, 10:30 PM UTC

630
Echo1138:mio:•

Zephyr. Yes I have a bias because Mio is the best character, but spamming arts is fun, and evasion tanks are fun to play.

16
SuileDearg•

Indeed!

3
monhst•

Did you try using her for the lvl 200 superboss? I reaaally want to make a good Zephyr build for that but it just isn't working for me. She can't dodge nearly enough to stay alive for long and can't take a hit. If you have any ideas for a good build please share 🙏

2
Right_Durian6736:Mio_Chibi:•

Focus on evasion and block rate. Zephyr is the best at taking aggro

1
Chemical-Cat•

Evasion helps a lot more with survivability over actually tanking hits (which Zephyr can still do if something actually connects) and because its art cooldowns are so short it can actually maintain aggro.

I'm leveling Lone Exile and Guardian Commander right now and my incursor just cannot keep enemies off of her even with Shadow Eye.

1
Morag_Ladair:Eunie_Chibi:•

Lone Exile

10
MythraExplainsJokes:mythra:•

Zephyr, it's actually my favorite class between attackers, defenders, and supports. As a bonus the class is from my new favorite Xenoblade character.

7
fabulousfiddle•

Lone exile purely because double bladed swords are cool af.

Speaking of guardian commander working on paper, I recently came up with an dumb as hell idea for a build. I put him as the only tank class with no aggro arts/equipment then I make seraph take the aggro with all the critical hp=damage buff I can find.

GC will keep seraph alive as long as hes within the circle and seraph is at his strongest when hes low on hp. Since seraph is taking the aggro, any character with GC's protector's pride gets 30% faster recharge rate. Once seraph gets awakening through his skill, transfer his buff to GC using share buff art. You will die if you stepped out of GC's ring for even half a second which means you need both characters to have none of the side/back attack bonus arts.

I've tested this to varying success but ultimately there's just more ways to do damage without all the risk.

5
SolugadOP•

This is a big reason why despite having difficulties holding aggro, I find GC to still be good at its role. You get to a point where attackers are putting out so much damage that holding aggro is extremely difficult but at least GC can still feel useful in that situation by protecting. If you can figure out how to get aggro, the class just snowballs into an unstoppable machine.

Weirdly enough, I've been finding that stacking as much damage potential on GC as possible has helped immensely with taking aggro. That Qigong master skill that allows you to ignore a huge chunk of defense mixed with fusion arts dmg+ accessory and the art canceling gem boosted his base damage significantly, nevermind when awakened. And he seems to get aggro way easier that way.

2
fabulousfiddle•

Exactly this. All your arts goes on CD when you're down and your healer has to stop his progress to revive you. Unless you decked out your healer with revive gems, getting downed is a big penalty. GC's skill to protect without being aggrod allows you to bypass that so its is seriously underrated. Couple that with GC's above average damage potential and you have a very strong secondary tank.

2
SolugadOP•

GC's skill to protect without being aggrod allows you to bypass that so its is seriously underrated.

I've come to realize this when I took GC out of the group for a Lost Vanguard. Attackers were continuously taking aggro from the Vanguard because they were just dealing too much damage, while Healers were going down during the revive phase and the Vanguard had no consistent way to protect them.

GC can protect without the need for aggro and that's absolutely insane considering how ridiculously tanky it is. And when it does take aggro the class is borderline god tier with Awakening. You just gotta pay more attention to where those aggro lines are going when you don't have aggro.

2
ProfessorStardust•

You can make it work way better via the Flash Fencer's Capable Hands passive and just start every battle with an Awakening going up. Hold aggro by being a combat monster on par with Seraph.

Anyway I dislike playing most tanks but Guardian Commander was the exception, aside from my accidentally really good Soulhacker tank.

3
OblivionvsSkyrim:jin:•

Guardian Defender was my favorite for a while because it was pretty easy to have them well when you’re not controlling them. The awakening skill is cool too and I liked linking the share buffs art so everyone could become awakened. It’s def the best of the negating damage tanks, and I still have one just as backup sometimes. Glow Ring is def a super helpful for it but it’s like a debuff version of taunt and debuffs become very inconsistent later on even with sappy sap.

Zephyr is really good and very fun. It’s way better at keeping aggro but it relies a lot on player control. iirc you actually lose aggro when getting hit which is supposed to be resolved with the counter/reflect damage back skills? But just evading everything with zephyr does damage back too + no aggro loss at all. The main problem I guess is you’ll wanna control then a lot so you can maximize chances for evading since the AI doesn’t cancel arts but it’s fun when everyone else is down except Mio and she’s soloing like 2 enemies and once and you win because she just doesn’t get hit.

Lone Exile is great too tho it takes a bit getting used to it and doesn’t become super great until later on when you are doing more damage. Def think it shouldn’t be a solo tank because even with evade stuff, it’s agility + art recharge isn’t nearly as good as zephyr. Usually kept as backup instead of guardian commander because the hero is amazing both as a character and stat wise.

3
SolugadOP•

Evade tanks seem to be the end game best as far as Defenders go, but something always draws me to guarding tanks. That's why I'm so obsessed with making Guardian Commander work lol but I'm starting to figure out just how to take aggro with it. I think I was simply not focusing on stacking enough damage. It's a tricky class.

I'm only in Ch. 5 and Lost Vanguard seems good right now, but I can see its severely low damage causing it to fall off in the next couple chapters since it would probably make holding aggro near impossible with the class.

But yeah, definitely seems like Zephyr and Lone Exile are the best tanks in XC3.

2
OblivionvsSkyrim:jin:•

Lost Vanguard was def the one I used the least. It has a smash art which is good for using as a master art but it’s kinda too specialized for machine type enemies. Other than the smash and agnian recharge it overall felt like Guardian Commander but less reliable. Still viable I guess but there’s prob something cool you can do with it I just haven’t used it much lol.

2
BanzaiBeebop•

Honestly Guardian Commander is great to play with that item that let's non-healers revive. It has an incredile amount of staying power so even if it struggles in the aggro department it's really good at getting an AOE KOed party back up and running.

3
SolugadOP•

That's actually how I play mine !

1
mhgamer321•

Dont like any tbh. Playing the tank never rly was for me. I always had 2 in the comp for easier chainatacks but that about was it. They feel kinda pointless as they cant keep aggro consistently when you spam fusion arts(what I relied on since I couldnt be assed to build proper teamcomps every few hours as I was lvling all classes on everyone) and never seemed to contribute anything besides topple since most classes need to stand together for buffs/heals and would thus get shit on by aoe atacks anyway.

2
SolugadOP•

They do feel very undertuned in this game.

2
Duckymaster21•

Zephyr easily! Something about seeing evaded all over your character is so satisfying.

2
YeLucksman•

Lobe Exile/Zephyr. I just love evasion tanks more than nlock tanks. Though shout out to Lost vanguard for having a 82% block rate with the block rate rings. Makes for a good back up tank.

2
SolugadOP•

Yeah I definitely prefer block tanks but can already tell evade tanks are the go-to. You can actually get even higher than that block rate. I saw a Guardian Commander build with 96% block rate!

1
Diggin-A-Hole:zeke:•

Believe it or not, Heavy Guard.

When you manually move all the Healers next to you, you feel invincible. Huge health pool, okay damaging Arts, and the absolute power you feel taking hits left and right from multiple different enemies and barely being scratched.

Heavy Guard is NOT the best Defender, but god damn, is it a power trip.

2
SolugadOP•

I saw a lot of people saying it's actually the worst but idk. I've made some really awesome builds with it early on. Mix Wide Slash master art from Zephyr with Variable Turret and you literally get like 8 or 9 seconds of total invincibility because of that absurdly long animation. Really helps when stalling out bosses and avoiding debuffs / large attacks.

3
Celtic_Crown•

I haven't played Lost Vanguard yet, but at this point I like Lone Exile the most.

1
Ray-Zide10:mio:•

Zephyr

1
GodKefka:Mio_Chibi:•

I think Zephyr is the funnest class to play and has some great synergy with some Master Arts. I do think Lone Exile is great as a "off-tank" can deal some decent damage with the right build. I do think there is not much selection for tanks, I think there is only 4 in total? I hope a DLC hero is another defender class.

1
deeman163•

Guardian Commander, but with Resonant Flag because Awakening is a buff

1
SolugadOP•

You mean to tell me this works with Resonant Flag? Meaning the entire party gets the buff?? Holy shit

3
deeman163•

Yes.

This class only needs an Aggro up Master art tacked onto it, but once you get Awakening in a fight, you can easily keep it up at a near 100% uptime and the huge dmg boost its Class original Arts gets from it resolves its Aggro issues

1