Another (probably bad) Roster Prediction

Analysis

I enjoy doing these and talking about them so here we go. Italics indicate players I expect to start or see a lot of playing time. Last year we kept 24 offense and 26 defense and I think we'll be there again, after players go to IR.

QB 2 Rodgers and Love. Love has looked like a good backup this offseason with potential for more. No reason to keep more than 2.

RB 4 Aaron Jones, AJ Dillon, Tyler Goodson, Kylin Hill. I expect Hill to immediately go on IR until he is ready.

WR 7 Sammy Watkins, Allen Lazard, Randall Cobb, Amari Rodgers Christian Watson, Romeo Doubs, Samori Toure. I expect everyone agrees on Watkins, Lazard, and Cobb. I think LaFleur loves his gadget players, and Amari has improved enough to be that guy. I think he'll be on the field more than a lot of people think. The last 3 will be sort of rotated in and out and mostly running deep routes, similar to what we did with EQ and MVS their rookie season. One of them will win additional playing time as the season goes on and possibly even replace one of the first 3, but I'm not sure who.

TE 3 Marcedes Lewis, Josiah Deguara, Robert Tonyan. Tonyan will immediately go on IR and another TE will be picked up, probably Tyler Davis.

OL 9 David Bakhtiari, Elgton Jenkins, Josh Myers, Yosh Nijman, Jon Runyan, Royce Newman, Zack Tom, Sean Rhyan, Jake Hanson I think that at least one of Jenkins or Bahk is good to go quick. They'll be one OT, with Nijman being the other. Myers is starting C, and Runyan is one of the starting OGs. The other OG spot is actually still in contention, and I'm not sure who will come out on top.

DL 5 Kenny Clark, Devonte Wyatt Dean Lowry, Jarran Reed, Jack Heflin, I think Lowry and Reed will rotate pretty regularly. I also think that the roster spot freed up by Kylin Hill will go to either Slaton or Slayton, for 6 DL come game time.

EDGE 5 Preston Smith, Rashan Gary Kingsley Enagbare, Ladarius Hamilton, ?????. I think that we're going to be adding a vet EDGE guy still, and he and Kingsley will rotate as our 3rd EDGE. Hamilton makes it primarily as ST.

ILB 5 De'Vondre Campbell, Quay Walker, Krys Barnes, Isiah McDuffie, Ray Wilborn. Campbrll and Quay will both be on the field most of the time, which is a big change for us. Barnes will see some rotation. McDuffie and Wilborn will mostly be ST guys.

CB 6 Jaire Alexander, Eric Stokes, Rasul Douglas Shemar Jean-Charles, Kabion Ento, Kiondre Thomes. SJC is the backup if an injury occurs, but the other CBs will only see ST action.

S 4 Adrian Amos, Darnell Savage Micah Abernathy, Tariq Carpenter. Abernathy and Carpenter see a lot of ST play, but that's it.

Add to this K,P, and LS and thats 53.

I placed a bit more emphasis on ST contributions this year than I have before, because I think our FO is doing so. What do yall think?

Posted Aug 27, 2022, 6:51 PM UTC · edited

028

Rodgers has vouched for Juwann Winfree so I think he makes it. You seriously don’t have TJ Slaton making the team? Jack Heflin has played well but so has Slaton. I feel like Garvin and Galeai have looked better than Hamilton. Kobe Jones is an outside linebacker. KeiSean Nixon is making the roster over Ento for sure. No Shawn Davis at safety? He’s missed some assignments in the passing game but with all the injuries, I think he makes it.

6
vanweOP•

There is a fair argument for Winfree over Toure, but I think Toure passed Winfree in this last preseason game.

Likewise Heflin vs Slaton is a good argument. I think that Heflin has looked better more recently, which is why I give him the nod.

None of Garvin, Galeai or Hamilton are good enough to make the roster as EDGE IMO. Hamilton is the best ST player of them.

I really should have proofread this better. Fixed with Kobe Jones.

Nixon has barely played in the pre-seaosn games, and played poorly when he did. He's also not playing on ST. I'll be surprised if he makes it.

Shawn Davis loses the spot because of ST play. He hasn't really looked better at S than Abernathy or Carpenter, and they are ST contributors.

1
Rainbacon•

Nixon played on almost every ST snap last year for Bisaccia in Las Vegas. He didn't play much on ST in the pre-season because Bisaccia knows exactly what he's got in him and he was trying everybody and their brother out to see what they could do.

1
vanweOP•

Thats possible

1
Casualuser3•

I think you're missing Keisean Nixon at CB. Brought over from the Raiders almost immediately when we hired Bisaccia as our ST coach. He'll make the roster, contribute on special teams, and maybe even see some dime or nickel snaps at CB.

3
vanweOP•

I disagree. That was the expectation when we brought him over, but that is not what has worked out. Across 3 pre-season games he's played a total 5 ST snaps, and has looked downright bad at CB.

-3†
Rainbacon•

Hill will not start on the 53. He's on PUP and he'll stay there. Tonyan won't be going to IR. The Packers wouldn't have brought him off PUP if the plan was to immediately put him on IR. He may not be ready immediately, but the fact he came off PUP means he'll be ready in the first few weeks. Otherwise, I pretty much agree with your assessment of the offense, though I think there's a chance we keep Jones or Walker and go 10 on o-line.

On defense, I think we'll go 6 DL, adding TJ Slayton to the 5 you mentioned. If we only kept 5 my guess is that Slayton would get it over Heflin, but I think this DL is too good to only keep 5 guys.

As for the secondary. Thomas and Ento have been meh at best. One of them might make it, but at least one will get cut and Keision Nixon will make it as a primarily ST player. Same thing at safety. Unless Dallin Leavitt's injury is bad, he'll probably make it over Carpenter, who has looked awful during the pre-season.

2
theJMAN1016•

Leavitt looking awful as well. Dude was getting blown up left and right

1
vanweOP•

My understanding is that if you are on PUP at the time of cutdowns to 53, you are not eligible to be on the active roster at all that year. That's why I have Hill on the 53. If Tonyan is placed on IR after the cutdowns, he only has to miss the first 4 weeks before he can play. I think he value that roster spot enough to give a longer look to a bubble player for the first few weeks.

6 DL would be better, but that roster spot has to come from somewhere. Which position should have fewer players?

Like I said Thomas and Ento are there only for ST. If there's that many injuries, we'd sign a vet FA before playing them. Nixon was certainly brought in to be a ST guy but he's not performing. They didn't give him a single ST snap against KC and only 1 against NO. I guess I just haven't seen enough of Leavitt to have him on the roster. I don't remember hearing much positive about him in practice either.

-4
Rainbacon•

Your understanding of PUP is incorrect. That's the way it works for IR, but PUP is different. If you are on PUP at the cutdown you have to stay on PUP for at least 4 games (was 6 or 8 before this season, can't remember which). At any point after that you can be activated and you have a 3 week window to practice. At the end of that window you must either be activated to the regular roster or placed on IR.

2
vanweOP•

I stand corrected. I really wish people would provide sources for things like this instead of just expecting strangers on the internet to trust them. At least I was able to find what I was looking for this time.

-1

No way keisean Nixon doesn’t make this team

2
vanweOP•

Based on what? The only thing he has going for him is that Bisaccia liked him as a ST guy last year. Unless his roster spot was already locked weeks ago and Bisaccia doesn't think he needs any practice, I'm not seeing it. He played 4, 1, and 0 ST snaps in our preseason games, and the little CB he's played has been downright bad.

1
Real_Piece:GB:•

K.hill already on IR, tonyan is already off PUP list, you have quay walker at 2 positions. We’ll probably keep 4 TEs since no fullback. Did you forget Ty summers, a special teams standout?

1
vanweOP•

If Kylin hill is not activated before the cut down to 53, his season is over. If we expect him to play at all this year he must be activated for the cutdown to 53, and if he is not ready then placed back on IR.

I have seen zero reports that Tonyan is expected to be ready week 1. He will be on the 53, then immediately placed on IR so his roster spot can go to someone else until he is ready to play. Because the COVID IR rules were made permanent, there is really no downside to placing a player on IR if you expect them to miss more than 2 weeks.

I meant Devonte Wyatt at DL, I should have proofread more. Fixed

4 TEs is likely what we will be at once Tonyan is healthy, but I think we use that spot early on to give more time to figure out ST.

I did not forget Ty Summers, and he has certainly played a lot of ST. However I do think he has played it well, which is why I did not include him.

Don't just downvote, tell me what you disagree with. If you can make a good argument you can change my mind.

-3
Real_Piece:GB:•

I didn’t downvote and tonyan has practiced therefore no IR. Hill won’t be activated because they already put him on IR, his relocated spot is already taken from the cut down to 80 before 53. Jenkins is practicing just like tonyan with the same injury so if one goes on IR then the other will but I highly doubt they’re going on IR after just being activated from PUP

2
vanweOP•

Well I was wrong. The IR rules from COVID were not made permanent, but they are still more lax than they were pre-COVID. If a player is placed on IR after cut downs they must miss at least 4 games, was 3 last year and 8 pre-COVID. Up to 8 players can be activated from IR, was unlimited last year but only 2 pre-COVID.

You might be right about Tonyan not going on IR to start the season, But I still think he probably does. He hasn't looked close to being ready IMO. I think Jenkins will be ready before week 5 so he doesn't.

Maybe I'm wrong about Hill, I can't find a good source that says one way or the other. My understanding is any player that that is on IR or PUP when the cutdown happens automatically goes on season ending IR. He must be activated for the cutdown to 53 if he's going to be on the roster for us at all this year. I'd appreciate it if you could provide a source that definitively says.

-1
Real_Piece:GB:•

It’s not that serious just wait til final cuts and practice squad

1
Thunder84•

If they’re on the PUP, they stay on the PUP, which I believe is 4 games. Players on the PUP don’t revert to IR.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
vanweOP•

What? Goodson saw more ST playing time in 2 out of the 3 pre-season games, and Taylor was not the highest usage ST guy in any of the games. He wasn't even top 10 until the KC game.

1
davepyne•

Agree mostly.
I based my list on the # of players they kept at each position last-year:

OL 9 (Bakhtiari, Newman, Jenkins, Tom, Myers, Hanson, Rhyan, Runyan, Nijman)
QB 2 (Rodgers, Love)
RB 3 (Jones, Dillon, Goodson)
TE 4 (Tonyon, Lewis, Deguara, Davis)
WR 6 (Cobb, Lazard, Watkins, Watson, Doubs, Rodgers)
DL 6 (Clark, Wyatt, Lowry, Slayton, Heflin, Slaton)
OLB 5 (Smith, Gary, Enagbare, Hamilton, Ramsey)
ILB 5 (Walker, Campbell, Barnes, McDuffie, Galea'i)
CB 6 (Alexander, Stokes, Douglass, Ento, Jean-Charles, Thomas)
S 4 (Savage, Amos, Abernathy, Carpenter)

ST 3 (Crosby, O'Donnell. Coco)

Notes:
Only keeping 6 WR, just as they did last year. Rodgers doubles as a KR.
Tyler Davis is the 4th TE, even though he had a bad pre-season, they need him on special-teams

1
vanweOP•

Not a bad list. The only thing I strongly disagree with is Ramsey, since he was already cut.

I would also argue that we will keep 7 WRs. The last time under Gute we had this much uncertainty at WR, we kept 8.

1
davepyne•

Oops! Thanks for updating me on Ramsey. I still think they keep 6 WR's. They only kept more than 6 WR's one time: in 2018 as you just mentioned.
2018 => 8 WRs
2019 => 6 WRs
2020 => 5 WRs
2021 => 6 WRs

Heck, in 2020 they kept only 5 WR's! And that group was pretty uncertain after Adams IMO (Davante Adams, Allen Lazard, Marquez Valdes-Scantling, Equanimeous St. Brown, Malik Taylor)

1
vanweOP•

I don't think our WR were uncertain at all in 2020. Lazard, MVS and EQ were all in their 3rd season and each had a season with at least 20 catches from Rodgers, MVS had 2. MVS and Lazard each had a 400+ yard season at that point. Adding Adams to that, we had 4 WRs with a fair degree of experience and success with Rodgers.

Now we have 2.

1
davepyne•

Nice call on 7 WR's, u/-vanwe you nailed it!

And to make myself feel better, I found this quote from Gutekunst on keeping only two RBs: "I think the emergence of Amari Rodgers doing some stuff back there could help us on gameday"

So its kind like they have 6 WR's and 2 RB's if you want to consider Amari more of a 3rd RB than 6th receiver as Gute implied there.

1