[Lord of the Rings] How are the Grey Havens being preserved?

My understanding is that the Three Rings were made to preserve the elven realms, so when the One Ring is destroyed and the Three lose their power, the elves immediately book it to Valinor. That's fine, but haven't the Grey Havens been ringless for a while now, since Gandalf has the ring? They seem to be surviving just fine without one.

Posted Aug 30, 2022, 8:20 PM UTC

136
nessie7Interplanar Labour Acquisitions•

Cirdan was instructed by the Valar to remain until it was time for the Last Ship to sail.

That probably helped a fair bit.

24
Patient_Ad_9910•

And the last ship at the end of the trilogy still hasn't sailed. So Cirdan the shipwright still has a lot to do. Legolas Greenwood's people are still around,so are Elrond's people

15
Ostrololo•

It may have decayed. Perhaps it used to be a glorious coastal elven city with a large population, but diminished into just half a dozen people manning the shipyard. The story or Word of God never goes into too much detail on its current status.

15
vasska•

narya, the ring of fire, was there at least 1000 and maybe up to 3000 years (cirdan the shipwright got it from celebrimbor sometime after the fall of eregion but before the death of gil-galad). that's a lot of time for its power to manifest.

but even without a ring, cirdan was a powerful elf, and reasonably could be expected to maintain the havens for the next 2000 years. the three rings certainly helped the elves, but they were not dependent upon sauron's gifts.

5
YankeeWalrus•

Things that are created with the rings can endure as long as their power still exists within the world. Mordor and Barad-dur are doing just fine without the One Ring, as are the Nazgul.

Think of the rings as a cement truck. Just because you give the truck to your friend so he can run over a demon with it doesn't mean all your cement will now crumble. Now if you destroy the cement truck, then everything falls apart, of course, because the cement is magic.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1