Default Keybindings vs Custom Keybindings (The Smartcast issue)

Almost everyone on Reddit seems to think this setup works best:
Pinky on Q with custom keybindings so that 123456QWERFG are all smartcast.(People call that "Smarcasting")
With Smartcast Indicators on/off depending on preference.

Smartcast Indicators option is just bad, and counter productive, imo. It doesn't cast until you lift your finger off the key.

And having Pinky on Q means no shift which means you are slow when using default keybindings(because no access to shift for smartcast) or slow using "Smartcasting" with the smartcast indicators (read previous paragraph) or you are inaccurate because "Smartcasting" with no range indicators.

Just use default keybindings. Be accurate and just hold shift for the speed of smartcasting. But you need your
pinky on Shift
ring on Q,A,Tab
Index on W,S
pointer on E,R,D,F.
Or you could use what Zackcy says is better, I think that works fine as well if you are so used to "Smartcasting".

I know this has been discussed a lot, but this has been bugging me.

I say "Smartcasting" because I don't like calling it that. As I've explained you can easily Smartcast using Default Keybindings. Calling a custom keybind setup "Smartcasting" makes it seem like you can't smartcast with the default.

TL;DR Smarcasting using shift is just as fast as "Smarcasting". Just place your hands on the keyboard right.

Posted Jul 29, 2012, 1:53 AM UTC · edited

05
Erichilles•

I agree entirely about the pinky placement.

This is from a WoW keybinding guide and shows you how you can maximize the amount of easily accessed keybindings in a WASD setup. The green squares are keys easily reached with a normal keybinding and the blue circles are keys which synergize well with a shift/ctrl/alt modifier (i.e. shift+W).

As for hand positioning, I prefer the pinky on capslock because it's more comfortable and not too much of a stretch to tap shift. I also keybind my 6th inventory slot to "t" because it's just after "r" so easily in reach, and it makes active items a bit easier. For example, when i'm comboing with veigar, I just cage then shift+WTRQ and get the full combo in.

Edit Credit to the guide mentioned

2
TheEnigmaBlade(NA)•

Hey, I put my pinky on Q and I am plenty fast.

1
anarchy2465•

I actually just set smart casting as QWER and don't even use shift

1
ChaoticPenor•

This also seems pretty unnecessary to me, honestly. A lot of the time smartcasting is faster than just using default. So why not just smartcast everything, and use shift+Q/W/E/R when you want to normal cast.

Things like Ali W is useful for this when you want to do a headbutt pulv.

In the end when you look at it, the number of spells that are better when smartcasted out-numbers the spells that are good without it by a decent margin. So I personally think after you're used to smartcasting the whole entire keybindings should just be reversed where QWER are smartcast, while the previously "normal" keybinds are on shift, so that they're available when you need it.

Again, this is just my opinion, but we never said that not using shift is slower, but smartcasting using QWER is more efficient because the abilities you WANT to smartcast they outnumber the abilities that you don't want to use it.

1
TharcideOP•

TIL, like what Zackcy said. Also practice improves accuracy as well -.- Which was my main argument against it.

but still the hand placement is really weirding me out. Why would people place Pinky on Q.

1