Reddit admins are stepping up on their anti-"brigading" crusade, our sub may be targeted in the near future
Hey fellow shibblehaters,
Last week, in an r/modnews post titled "Introducing Reddit’s Moderator Code of Conduct," Reddit's admins declared:
Rather than attempting to determine whether a mod is acting in “good” or “bad” faith, we are shifting our focus to become more outcomes-driven. For example, are direct mentions of other communities part of innocuous meta-discussions, or are they inciting interference, targeted harassment, or abuse?
(bold added)
For subs like ours that have a reputation as a brigading hotbed, this does not portend good news. As u/Anomander told me last month in an r/ModSupport post I submitted:
It's been open conversation in mod communities for ages that your community is often a problem in any animal-related sub that hosts content containing a pitbull
However, this reputation is entirely unearned and based on no factual evidence. As I replied to him:
The burden is on those alleging that our users deliberately instigate or coordinate brigading campaigns to demonstrate that certain posts or comments explicitly or implicitly encourage this behavior. Importantly, even if some of our users are present in a pit bull post and making derisive comments, this alone does not suffice to prove brigading intent—clearly, it is possible for their joint presence to merely be incidental rather than planned.
Of course, he did not respond, evidently because he was unable to support his libelous charge. Reddit's new rule, which makes the determination of brigading even more subjective and leaves our fate to the whims of idiotic shibblenutters like this guy and their admin and mod supporters, of which there are apparently very many, is in my view a significant development and something we should take seriously. Accordingly, I will ask you guys to be more vigilant about possible brigaders here and report any violations of Rule 10 (No brigading) you encounter.
FYI, this is my position on brigading, as stated in response to that r/modnews post:
This is precisely the opposite of what us moderators need. In fact, the whole rule against "brigading" ought to be eliminated entirely. Users of certain subs ought to have the right to organize responses in other subs, so long as they are civil and otherwise comply with the rules. To be sure, the rule against brigading is deeply antidemocratic and nothing short of censorship that hampers discussion and understanding between communities.
I should also bring it to your attention that, while we have been directly warned by admins for keeping up content containing Reddit screenshots showing usernames under the pretext that it incites brigading—which prompted us to add Rule 7 (Screenshots of Reddit posts/comments must have usernames redacted)—they do not enforce this rule equally or fairly. For example, just yesterday I reported an r/DramaticText post that showcased and ridiculed several screenshots of comments with usernames in plain view, including one of my own, in response to which someone opined that I am "intellectually disadvantaged." Despite that I reported both the post and the comment, the admins promptly informed me that they do not consider them rule violations. Indeed, this is an object lesson demonstrating that controversial subs like ours that struggle against an unjust status quo are the true targets of the campaign against "brigading" and similar measures.
As always when I make announcements, if you have any questions or comments, feel free to leave them below.
Posted Sep 12, 2022, 5:34 PM UTC · edited
If this sub gets banned and you guys make another one, just paint it as being more for shitbull attack victims and survivors, usually subs like that will allow rants and "hate" as long as it's called venting
There's already one. You know the one. And it's become all but an echo chamber, they gingerly tiptoe over so many eggshells over there. I just said fuck it, it's pointless to post in a circlejerk sub and left it and all its offshoots. Good luck everybody else!
That has actually been the focus of our sub since I joined the mod team. As you can see from our About section, we have always "officially" prioritized victims.
You can also see from the screenshot that this has always been a venting sub, too. Now, I only made some minor additions to the language here—all I did was add "and others." But this has always explicitly been a sub for shibble victims and venters, since I've been here, anyway